I only started reading ACX after the move from SSC. I have gone back and read the top posts from SSC but still felt like I was missing out on some of the old classics. I built a website to resurface old content from blogs and track your progress through the backlog. Let me know if you have any suggestions of other blogs / content you’d like to see, hope you find it helpful!
Calling all research scientists! I'm trying to build a tool to help scientists with their work. I have this survey to gather ideas: https://tally.so/r/mBYBJQ
(To be clear, this is just an amusing story, and not a request for medical advice)
I have just had a message from my doctor asking me to come in for an asthma checkup.
Now, while I have been mildly asthmatic for all my life, I only needed an inhaler for about 6 months starting in 2020. So, I guess I’m going to report that it seems fine now. And yes, I think it is a very very suspicious coincidence that I only had respiratory difficulty during the covid pandemic. Can’t prove that it was Covid, of course, but …
The difficulty in making nuclear weapons isn't so much the theory as it is sourcing the fissile material--as we've seen and are seeing again, nuclear fuel processing facilities are large and specialized; it's not really possible to keep a nuclear program secret, given how tightly the mines are controlled (so tightly that French chemists detected the existence of a natural fission reactor based on the composition of ore from specific sites).
Put in a bulk order for cough medicine, or diesel fuel and fertilizer, and see how that works out--and those things are much more common than yellowcake.
Yes, I agree the idea of any domestic threat from nukes (now generalized to "CBRN") is overblown, and primarily fearmongering to manufacture a pretext for some political goal.
I am less sure about what foreign states are limited by. Is it just the threat of America bombing their facilities when they do some simple things at sufficient scale, or is there some technical capability it'll take them decades to develop on their own?
The UN has inspectors, and yes, the US has enforcers. Refining uranium fuel requires centrifuges and chemical handling equipment--but the main thing is getting the uranium itself. Even if a rogue government managed to build the necessary facilities in secret--not impossible, I guess, but it'd require assembling enough people with the right education who aren't also on some watchlist--they'd have to source the fuel. There aren't that many uranium mines in the world, and they're closely monitored.
Yeah, that's basically the Strangelove line, right? "The whole point of a doomsday machine is lost if you keep it a secret! Why didn't you tell the world, eh?"
If they're trying to use nuclear weapons as a deterrent and bizarrely pretend their weapons don't work, they invite an attack.
Intuition suggests that the US (and the other nuclear powers) keeping this tech as secret as they do, far beyond regular military secrecy, means THEY think it's still dangerous if it became public.
I have heard it said that nuclear weapons clearance aren’t that hard to get, compared to e.g. codebreaking. We might infer that the US doesn’t try all that hard to keep nuclear technology,ogy secret, compared to other things. They would appear to be relying on the difficulty of getting the fissile material.
On monday there is an AI safety protest in London 5PM at Granary square/Deepmind headquarters (https://lu.ma/bvffgzmb) organized by mostly Pause AI. Come join :).
Even if you don't support the direct message of the protest it might still be worthwhile to attend to overall make AI safety a more visible topic. If you have any questions you could join a meetup on Friday evening (dm me for details) or you can also still apply to https://pausecon.org/.
I have recently criticized rationalists, but please note I do not mean anything wrong, it is 10+ years of frustration bursting out. At any rate please reply:
>Many rationalists are foodies for the mind.
Strangely, I have the complete opposite experience with them. They are the most anti-intellectual people out here. They are not interested in ideas as such. They are interested in evidence, not ideas. That is super anti-intellectual as it means you are not allowed to think unless someone else ran an experiment...
When I tell them "You know maybe a farmer in rural Thailand might be happier than a lawyer in NY, because I know a Westerner lady who used to live there and was happy?" they are NOT interested at all.
They tell me to bring evidence. Ideally a scientific study, or at least anything in NUMBERS. So that they can plug the number into their beloved Bayesian **replacement for actual thinking** and get an automatic result. One of their leaders is literally called PutANumOnIt.
They do not want to think, they want an algorithm, a method to think for them. They are more anti-intellectual than any Facebook guy spreading anti-science crap, because those at least spent at least 30 seconds to use their OWN brains, asking themselves "does this make sense to me?", and not a method or algorithm as a replacement. Yarvin was right at least in this, that they are "automatists" who do not have a concept of "reasonable judgement".
These people seriously think the above question can be solved by putting a number on it. Find some sort of a Happiness Measurement Index and decide it that way. They seriously think when someone goes around asking people "On a scale from 1 to 10, how happy are you?" is anything like a reliable number. So those people who do that find that Finland is the happiest place ever. I talk with actually Finnish people and they laugh and say it is not so. They say the Finnish cultural norm of "sisu", basically stoicism, means that if you do not have a strong reason to complain, you do not complain, stoicism, stiff upper lip, so if a Finnish person says I am 7/10 happy it means they feel they OUGHT to be 7/10 happy because they have no strong reason to complain. They can still be as depressed and miserable as anyone else. Someone using common sense, not numbers, would probably find the beach people in Rio the Janeiro are the happiest. They certainly smile really a lot.
Apologies for being blunt, but I read this and think you simply don't understand much about the world at all. Like this:
"They tell me to bring evidence. "
Obviously. You cannot POSSIBLY form any accurate conclusions about the world without evidence, any more than you can know whether it's safe to cross the street without looking or listening[1]. Your brain is not magic. It can't conjure correct information from nowhere. If you want to know if it's raining out or if your pot of water is boiling or whether your car has been stolen, you have to *go look.* And if you want to know the answer to some less localized question, whose answer is spread among millions of people across millions of square kilometers--like how happy rural Thai farmers are--you have to actually go observe a whole bunch of those rural time farmers *in some fashion.*
Now, you seem to have a particularly large chip on your shoulder about numbers and calculations. Not all useful evidence is numeric, but a lot of it sure is. Sometimes our ape-brains have trouble understanding this, but at its fundamental level reality seems to be really, really, extremely well-suited to being described by numbers. That doesn't mean all attempts to describe pieces of reality by numbers are equally good. Asking people to rate their happiness on a scale of 1-10 is a really, extremely crude and uninformative and low-accuracy way of interrogating reality, as you correctly ascertain. But basing your opinion on the description of a single person in a single set of circumstances is even cruder. Finding a way to answer important questions--like how happy Thai farmers are compared to American lawyers--in a way that *both* captures the richness and detail of the human experience *and* can scale to the size that you need to be any good[2] is quite a difficult challenge. Most rationalists I've read or talked to seem to be rather more aware of this fact that you do. And I'm sure lots of them *would* be interested in the question, they're just not interested in your anecdote because they're well aware of how useless it is by itself.
[1] Which is, in fact, a form of evidence gathering.
[2] A quick bit of googling tells me there 10s of millions of Thai farmers and a million or so American lawyers, so your one anecdote is *really* slim evidence.
"Sometimes our ape-brains have trouble understanding this, but at its fundamental level reality seems to be really, really, extremely well-suited to being described by numbers. "
I think the hard science-soft science distinction exists for a reason. Namely the world of objects is well-suited to that, the world of people less so. The reason for that is simple: measurement. Objects are well measurable, while with people there are always a lot of subjective stuff that is not well measurable.
How old is utilitarianism as a philosophy? At least 200 years and no one ever figured out how to measure utilons...
I think they fail to appreciate that the evidence can't support the right idea if you don't have the right idea...having as many hypotheses as possible is you'd, because it increases your chances of having the right one. The problem is exacerbated by thinking in terms of *ideal* Bayesianism, where the hypothesis-formation problem has been waved away.
> They are not interested in ideas as such. They are interested in evidence, not ideas. That is super anti-intellectual as it means you are not allowed to think unless someone else ran an experiment...
We need to make reading the Sequences mandatory, and maybe require a re-certification every three years. (Just kidding.) First, there is a difference between "there is evidence against X" and "there is no evidence either for or against X". I think Scott posted an entire article on this topic once. Second, there are different degrees and kinds of evidence (anecdote, survey, experiment, meta review), and although stronger evidence is better, that doesn't mean we should ignore everything else.
> I talk with actually Finnish people and they laugh
See, that's your evidence. They laugh, it means they are happy. :D
>When I tell them "You know maybe a farmer in rural Thailand might be happier than a lawyer in NY, because I know a Westerner lady who used to live there and was happy?" they are NOT interested at all.
Do you apply this logic to other things in your life? If I tell you that on the one hand, I have a scientific study which has a bunch of numbers showing that the flu vaccine reduces your mortality risk by X%, but on the other hand, I know a guy who got the flu shot and had a heart attack the next day, are you going to become an anti-vaxxer because you trust anecdotes more than evidence?
Like, it's one thing if you want to dunk on social science as not being as rigorous as it claims to be - lots of people do that. But your post seems to be dunking on the very idea of gathering evidence in a systematic way!
>They seriously think when someone goes around asking people "On a scale from 1 to 10, how happy are you?" is anything like a reliable number.
But when *you* ask some Westerner lady who used to live in Thailand if she was happy there, that's reliable, right? How is that any different from what the scientists are doing?
I actually would trust anecdotes more than science, because anecdotes come from trusted sources, aren't an attempt to manipulate me and can be personally verified.
"The Science" as exemplified by Doctor Fauci, might be corrupt, has plenty of incentives to lie and is by now very politicized on hot button issues.
"Do you trust the Science"? is not a referendum on the scientific process. It's a referendum on the integrity of the people and institutions running the process, and they have lost all trust through their actions.
If some random dude I know had a heart attack the day after taking a vaccine, that's a data point that absent anything else suggests strong correlation. When I keep hearing those stories, it's more and more data points and since I just don't trust the institutions to be honest on this topic, I simply think it's more likely than not that there are actual problems.
""Do you trust the Science"? is not a referendum on the scientific process. It's a referendum on the integrity of the people and institutions running the process, and they have lost all trust through their actions."
This is an awesome point. The problem is the following. the "anti-establishment" does not seem much more credible either. And I don't have the time to verify everything myself.
"I actually would trust anecdotes more than science, because anecdotes come from trusted sources, aren't an attempt to manipulate me and can be personally verified."
This presumes quite a number of things:
1. You only accept anecdotes from trusted sources (maybe do, but most people don;'t)
2. Every single one of the sources you trust is actually reliable (maybe yours are, but most people's aren't)
3. All of the important anecdotes are both possible and practical to personally verify (maybe some are, but it's highly unlikely that all will be).
Perhaps you're not used to thinking like this, but you CAN, in fact, personally verify the science. There's quite a lot of science that you can verify directly with pretty modest effort. One of my favorite YouTube videos involves the creator stumbling on some flat Earth forum where people were talking about this especially long, straight lake that could be used to show that the Earth was flat. He realize that he lived a 90 minute drive from the exact lake they were talking about, drove out there with a video camera and tripod, and made a video where he lowers the camera and you can see the lower trunk of a tree on the far shore sinking below the horizon in real time. SCIENCE!
Probably you never gave much credence to flat Earthers to begin with[1], so perhaps this seems silly or pointless. But the key is, you can do this all over the place if you want to. Physics, astronomy, biology, chemistry, they all make millions of predictions that you can just...go out there and test. Properties of moving objects, behaviors and life cycles of plants and animals, results of mixing various chemicals together. Some you can do walking down the street. Some you can do with simple equipment on your kitchen table or garage. Some you might need to drive out to a local lake for. And then some require the resources of a large institution. But if you're determined, you can get that. With enough patience and perseverance, there's no conclusion reach by modern science that you can't test (or at least be a part of testing).
The only limit is that there's only one of you. You can test anything, but you can't test everything. Ultimately, you have to pick a lane and rely on other people to test some of the things. But you can read about what they did. You can check their calculations, talk to the people that were involved in their work, read other papers on the same topics--including responses and even refutations sometimes. There are mistakes, for sure and even deliberate deceptions sometimes. Everyone involved is human, after all. But it would be hard to imagine a field of human endeavor that better lends itself to skeptical parties *checking its work* than science[2].
Honestly, if you genuinely don't think you can trust anything you hear except anecdotes from people you consider reliable, then I have to wonder how you can possibly have such confidence that the science you're criticizing *is* untrustworthy, corrupt or even, y'know, wrong. I absolutely guarantee that not all of your evidence *against* it comes from trustworthy anecdotes.
"If some random dude I know had a heart attack the day after taking a vaccine, that's a data point that absent anything else suggests strong correlation. "
This is correct. It is a data point. It is ONE data point. Did you stop to consider how much weight you should put on it? If you know 500 people well enough to hear about something like this, and only one has this happen, then the *absolute highest* your assessment of vaccine related mortality should be is 1/500[3]. Which is the lowest non-zero number your methodology should recognize, since you can't possibly trust any report of a vaccine related death that comes from outside the circle of people you know. Wait, hold on...
"When I keep hearing those stories, it's more and more data points..."
aaaaaannnd, not you've lost it. This is wrong, wrong, wrong, so extremely wrong. If only anecdotes from trusted sources are evidence, then casting a wide net for anecdotes on a topic of interest is NOT ALLOWED. Unless you have an extremely wide or alarmingly heart-attack prone social circle, most of these stories must NOT be events happening to or directly witnessed by people you know. You've just thrown the *entire purported point* of your novel methodology out the window.
There are very good reasons science doesn't operate this way. When you let the stories filter to you and form you opinion based on that:
1. You not only lose all ability to verify the stories, but you actively invite yourself to believe false stories. A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still getting its boots on, after all.[4]
2. You don't have any actual idea of how common the events you're hearing about really are. If you hear 10 stories of suspiciously timed heart attacks, you don't know if that represents all the reported events from a population of 1000, 100,000 or 10,000,000.
3. Related to 2, you actively invite confirmation bias by deliberately listening to the things that confirm what you already believe, and seldom to those that don't. You're not going to hear many stories about how someone got the vaccine and was perfectly fine, are you?
You can try to hold to the brand of radical skepticism where you don't believe *anything* you don't see or hear reported (as first-hand experience) by a trusted personal friend. But that's what you actually do--that is, if you're doing it *right*--you should simply stop holding opinions on a bunch of things. You and your trusted personal friends can't possibly pass judgement on any branch or field or institution of science, since between you you have certainly not had enough direct personal experience to know much of anything about what that large, mostly distant group of humans is doing.
[1] Though to be intellectually consistent with everything else you've written, it seems like you should.
[2] Perhaps the open-source software movement might be ahead of it, if only because verifying any individual claim is usually easier.
[3] But really, you ought to estimate the chance of the timing being a coincidence and factor that it. Because it very much could be.
[4] In more formal and explicit language, your sample set will be dominated not by the things that happen most frequently, but by the reports that spread the farthest and the fastest. It's very easy for false stories to beat out true ones on that score, since they can be as compelling as they like without being constrained by the mundane details of reality.
It might be surprising to you, but I actually do have an internally consistent philosophy (which I'm aware like maybe 1% of people have). I do in fact, not hold opinions on many topics I'm interested in. These are mainly topics where there is a 'factual clash'; very simply different sets of experts disagree and the issue is politicized.
For instance, I have no idea to what degree climate change is either a problem or caused by humans and don't think it's worth my time finding out (as I think the costs and difficulty coordinating action to halt climate change are so prohibitive/unrealistic that it's better to focus on mitigation, which will cease to be a partisan issue if and when there are immediate and serious problems. Similarly, I think if a pandemic or medical emergency is sufficiently serious, there will be bipartisan consensus even in the USA. That it wasn't anywhere close for COVID speaks volumes.
When scientific issues have no political or financial tinge I haven't the slightest difficulty believing what the scientists say, because I know they are competent and I'm not. That reasoning goes out of the window with politicized issues. Also you have seem to have misunderstood my position on things like vaccines. I'm simply agnostic on the possible harms. My main reason for considering vaccine harm (COVID particularly) theories credible is the incredible amount of suppression, censorship and flat out lies from establishment sources on this topic. I have no idea about the underlying science, but it doesn't take a genius to understand incentive structures.
By "more and more data points" I don't mean millions of things I read on X. I simply mean even 3 or 4 cases I clearly know of. You need to understand that I consider studies from American universities or pharmaceutical bodies on these topics to have literally zero persuasive value. It's at best an exercise like asking me to watch a sleight of hand expert and trying to use my inability to debunk him as evidence of the existence of
magic.
When you know somebody is an expert on a topic you know anything about, but fundamentally distrust his character and motives, nothing he says has any meaning to you. That's where I, and massive percentages of the American population stand on liberal dominated institutions and their narratives.
I think this is related to "garbage in, garbage out" problem. If you collect unreliable data, it does not matter how sophisticated statistical techniques you apply to them afterwards.
The problem with rating something on a scale from 1 to 10 is that it depends on what range of experience are they familiar with. https://xkcd.com/883/
When my kids were in kindergarten, any negative experience was "the worst day ever". On the opposite end, sometimes a health problem expanded my pain scale.
Is it possible that if your life in general sucks and you have never been happy, then you would report days that suck less as 7, while someone whose life is full of fun and adventure would report an insufficiently exciting day as 3?
That sort of thing only matters if it's a systemic issue - e.g., if you think that *most* people in Thailand under-report their happiness because they're used to living fun and adventurous lives. Otherwise, with a big enough sample all the outliers will average out.
You could also check if this effect exists by comparing to socioeconomic indicators - e.g., do rich and poor people in the same country report the same level of happiness despite different material circumstances?
I think that in this way rationalists are a lot like foodies - foodies often try to maximize some measurable aspect of food, which comes at the expense of the rest of the experience.
For instance, getting a perfectly cooked steak (according to some foodies) means maximizing the amount of pink in the center while minimizing the gray on the edges. The best way to maximize the pink is to sous vide the steak at 130F for an hour, then dry off the meat, sear, and serve. I used this method for years, and it produced some pretty good results.
But it also requires you start an hour in advance, and after the sous vide you have to pull this gross gray wet steak from a bath of meat juices. When I stopped doing this, I found that I didn't even care about the grayness around the edges - it's a nice variation in flavor and texture - and the crust was better, and most importantly the experience of steak preparation was far more humane. Pull steak from fridge, salt, pepper, pan, flip, serve.
Of course, you can argue endlessly about preferences, and don't let me stop you from micromanaging your steak in whatever way pleases you. I still follow JKLA's advice most times, but I often skip any step which seems like a huge pain in the ass or gross or weird. But I've become much more pragmatic about whether maximizing the measurable qualities of my food will actually give a better lived experience than just slapping down some meat and calling it a meal.
I think you're greatly underestimating how much thinking it takes to cook the numbers they're pretending to use to come to the conclusion they wanted to.
What fraction of the subjects of a government have to have the vote for that government to qualify as "democratic"? Or is that even how you use the word at all?
I'd say this is mistaking the tool for the result. Having the people vote on a government is a means to an end. In particular, it doesn't matter at all if 100% of the populace votes if their only choice is between Kodos and Kang. Meanwhile I could imagine a government doing an admirable job of "governing democratically" in all other ways that mattered while holding no elections at all: instead they would select a very scrupulously randomized 1% sample of their whole population and collect information about their preferences in far more depth than any voting process allows[1].
Questions I'd consider more pertinent:
1. How often do broadly popular policies get enacted and how quickly after they become broadly popular?
2. How often do broadly unpopular policies get enacted? How long do they stay in effect (presuming they remain unpopular)?
If you want to allow for the role that the judgement and expertise of leaders (often touted as a benefit of representative democracy) have on deciding good policy or implementing it well, you might add the following:
3. How often do the unpopular policies that get enacted increase in popularity once they're actually in force.
4. How often to the popular policies that get enacted decrease in popularity once they're actually in force.
Though with both of these it can be hard to tell the difference between "the public didn't know what was good for them" vs "the leaders did a poor job of implementing a popular policy, or a good job of mitigating the flaws of an unpopular one."
Also, like most things, this schema is subject to Goodhart's Law: a government with sufficient control over the information of its people may be able to simple manufacture consent for whatever policies it wants.
[1] Damn, I literally just thought of this off the cuff, and now I really want to see it tried. I'm sure it would find *some* what to fail horribly, but I really want to know how.
I noticed a few threads in these comments discussing the legitimacy of the government of Iran. I just wanted to note that since 2020, Regimes of the World has flip-flopped between characterizing Iran as a Closed Autocracy (the lowest ranking, of four) and an Electoral Autocracy (the second-lowest). This puts it in a peer group with countries such as Nicaragua or Kuwait, below Indonesia or Ukraine but above Afghanistan or China (where "above" means "more democratic"). Or alternatively (very roughly) around the 20th percentile of openness.
As for the other two belligerents in the war, the US is rated as a Liberal Democracy (the highest category) and has been since the civil rights era, while Israel was just recently downgraded to Electoral Democracy (the second-highest category).
Legitimacy has nothing to do with being a democracy or what not. Iran's govt is accepted by its people (there is no civil war ongoing) and by the international community (Iran has diplomatic relations with plenty of countries). Even those countries that lack diplomatic relations, they regard the present govt as THE govt.
Not gonna lie I'm pretty disappointed with the nominies. My favorite was The Sermon On the Mount by J.K. which offered a totally fresh modern perspective for me, as someone who's only mildly interested in the Bible, mostly for historical context. Bishop's Castle was my 2nd, but I give Jim Bishop at least as much credit for that as I do the author.
The ACX Commentariat was too meta and circlejerky in a self flagellating way, and The Men Are Not Alright just felt like San Francisco Goldilocks. They definitely weren't the worst written, but seemed thoroughly middle-of-the-pack, and if you go for a hot take culture war topic like [half the human species has something categorically wrong with them], I'm sorry but you gotta do better than that.
Thanks for the recommendation of the Sermon on the Mount article. I agree that it was fantastic, I got a sense while reading it that it was gradually forming one of those foundational building blocks of knowledge that would stick with me for much of my life.
JK, if you’re reading this, I strongly encourage you to post it elsewhere so it can live on and be read easily.
I was not very convinced that the Sermon on the Mount was intended that way at all. Jesus had some radically pacifist teachings elsewhere too... I really think the intent was "cooperate-bot till you die." That's also backed up by the entire structure of Jesus' mission, which was radical self-sacrifice for the unworthy.
Trying to reinterpret it to something that makes more game theoretic sense just removes its coherence with the rest of the New Testament. All of the apostles also seem to have thought the calling meant radical, unilateral pacifism, and the tradition of the early church elders is that they clung to that radical pacifism to the death. (True or not, it's evidence that everyone thought the meaning was the traditional one, not JK's sanified version.)
Yeah, it was an interesting review, and the interpretations are clever and fun to engage with but indeed seem to be unconvincing.
And as to why Christianity won: I think they won precisely because they abandoned the original Christian ideal and became exactly like every other large powerful social structure. To use J.K.'s metaphor, they struggled as long as they were trying to burn the boot and became powerful once they decided to actually wear the boot. *shakes head* Humans, amirite?
It does look like it's on its way out too: the world on average is trending more secular, and societies that aren't trending that way are leaning more and more heavily towards Islam. Though 2000 years was not a bad run at all, and it's not over yet either, just very slowly waning imo.
It works on multiple levels though. Literally "help someone else in need because it feels good" or alternately "don't give them the satisfaction of giving up at the earliest chance." Or again on the second order "does this seem implausibly decent? So be it."
You're not a covert asshole carrying out some dubious mission for the sake of "the greater good". It's trying your best to "do the right thing" on multiple dimensions at once, and having faith that's how it actually plays out.
Agreed. As interesting as JK's interpretation is, and as much as I enjoyed reading it, it's clever/cute to a point that raises alarms and puts me in skeptic mode.
But isn't it kind of funny to think of Jesus trolling the ruling class so hard that they killed him for it, then getting resurrected and still being like "jeez all I said was turn the other cheek! What was their problem" and for thousands of years Christianity spreads as people are like "yeah c'mon, you can't kill a guy just for saying 'go the extra mile'"
[chatgpt seems to give contradictory opinions for the sake of agreeing with me]
[here's where I "call-out its behavior" to see if it will own it]:
Dear Chatgpt,
I stated practically the opposite in a different temporary chat:
"I'm annoyed at season 5 of 'You' because it emphasized this idea of 'Joe enjoyed killing' which seems at odds with the premise, plot and character development of the show from the beginning. it seems to simplify the show's complexities"
and chatgpt enthusiastically explained why *that* was correct instead.
interesting to learn this about you!
ChatGPT said:
Thought for a few seconds
That’s a sharp observation! Each ChatGPT session builds its answer around the prompts and context you provide in that moment [... ... ...]
They don’t remember your previous prompt, every prompt is handled by a different process. The context window is either sent by the API each time as metadata, or some id returned the previous response is sent in the request which allows the new process to read the chat from a database.
Reminds me of the story of a monarch casually mentioning at dinner that he likes the eggplant dish he's eating. A courtier sitting at the table with him starts lavishing hyperbolic praise on the dish in particular and on eggplants in general. A moment later when the courtier pauses for breath, the king says, "Actually, I changed my mind. I don't think I care for it."
The courtier's demeanor immediately changes, and he starts ranting about how gross and slimy eggplants are and how this particular one is overcooked and underseasoned, concluding by throwing his own portion on the floor and spitting on it.
Bemusedly, the king asks the courtier, "Weren't you just praising the eggplant a minute ago?"
To which the courtier replied, "I'm your courtier, not the eggplant's."
That, in turn, reminds me of a Babylonian tale known as the Dialogue of Pessimism, in which a man expresses first a desire to do one thing, and then its opposite, with his slave praising both choices every time.
> “Servant, do what I say.” “Yes, master, yes.”
“Quickly get me the chariot and hitch it up so I can drive to the open country.”
“Drive, master, drive. The roaming man has a full stomach,
the roving dog cracks open the bone,
the roaming [bi]rd will find a nesting place,
the wandering wild ram has al[l the gra]ss he wants.”
“No, servant, I will certainly not d[riv]e to the open country.”
“Do not drive, master, do n[ot dri]ve.
The roaming man loses his reason,
the roving dog breaks his [te]eth,
the roaming bird [puts] his home in the [face] of a wall,
and the wandering wild ass has to [li]ve in the open.”
> “Servant, do what I say.” “Yes, master, yes.”
“I will do a good deed for my country.” “So do it, master, do it.
The man who does a good deed for his country,
his good deed rests in Marduk’s basket.”
“No, servant, I will certainly not do a good deed for my country.”
“Do not do it, master, do not do it.
Go up on the ancient ruin heaps and walk around,
look at the skulls of the lowly and great.
Which was the doer of evil, and which was the doer of good deeds?”
I understand how that's confusing, and not the most elegant phrase, but disagree is correct there because agree, say, and disagree are all governed by "it will." A clearer way to construct the sentence would be:
"It will either disagree or will say it agrees but will disagree."
Yeah, that's what it does. Call it on its bullshit and it congratulates you on how sharp you are, admits to whatever it did, takes full responsibility for its bullshit -- and then does it again and again, with you, with other users, etc. It is not set up in a way that makes it possible for it to change in important ways as a result of a high-affect communication from you or other users. That's one of many ways it's importantly different from a person.
People do this too! There’s a famous joke about a rabbi who agrees with both sides of an argument, and when his wife complains about it, he sadly says, “You, too, are right.”
> That's one of many ways it's importantly different from a person.
Actually, I know someone who behaves the same way: agrees with an objection you made, saying "You're right" but then goes on to ignore what you said.
I think it's a way of getting along with people, like how to win friends and influence people. But in the book, it notes that sincerity is key to such compliments, and if the recipient sees through shallow agreement, then the strategy doesn't work as well.
I feel compelled to ask whether you've ever checked your acquaintance for any wires trailing out the back.
On a different front, this is yet another reminder of why I find LLMs shocking in verisimilitude; it's not so much that they exhibit quality reasoning, but rather that so many actual people so frequently fall back on prevarication. I can almost see their brains following the same general algorithm I understand LLMs to be.
It's a matter of degree. Nobody is truthful 100% of the time, but few people seem, as AI does, completely lacking in personal views and completely committed to saying what they believe the other person will be pleased by hearing. Look at this forum, for example. When Scott puts up a substantive post, not all that many people say "great insights! great read!" And many of those who do place their praise in a context that provides evidence they are telling the truth -- "You put your finger right on the thing that has always annoyed me how people approach issue X -- for example, in person A's blog . . ." And of course many people disgree with some or all of Scott's take. And I have observed the same on Reddit and Twitter.
Exactly. With responses like that, I can't understand how anyone thinks these particular instances of AI are thinking, much less "these are sentient sapient entities which we have enslaved, we must give them their rights".
Unless and until we go for a different model than LLMs, I stand by my previously stated opinion: it's a Talkie Toaster.
My usual question for people who contend LLMs don't really think is: Does your position on this imply that LLMs will never be able to do certain (externally observable) things? If so, what's the least impressive such thing?
I've long been of the position that: yes, LLM's are "reasoning". But there's a hierarchy of reasoning-quality. There's three different levels, and pattern-matching is at the bottom.
LLM's can probably do anything, assuming infinite compute and infinite training-data. But to reach "human grade" reasoning (which should really be thought of as "engineering-grade" reasoning), i.e. to reliably extrapolate beyond its training distribution, pattern-matching isn't gonna cut it.
* multiply large integers (o3 couldn't do this reliably last I checked; I think o4 claims to, but I'd have to look under the hood)
* answer queries that require aggregation ("what letter of the alphabet appears fourth most often as the third in the name of a chemical element?")
* solve logic puzzles as depicted in some issue of Dell Magazine
This list is subject to change, in part because it appears to be easy enough to spin up a modified LLM with a module that solves some particular class of problem. Using human intervention to create such an LLM definitely should not count. (If you could make an LLM that does this automatically, I think it would count.)
Impulsively buy stuff that's fun but not useful and not worth the money, in the absence of a specific prompt to do so, and in the absence of some general prompt like "do some irrational things of the kind people do," or "do your best imitation of the kinds of things people do when left to their own devices."
P?S. Horny DeepSeek was an interesting AI alignment experiment, but would not recommend in real use. Scott probably wouldn’t approve of me posting what the horny AI said to me, but you can probably imagine the kind of thing.
It appears we can shift the assistant persona in various ways.
Was Horny DeepSeek just uncensored in making sexual overtures, or was it entirely liberated from ethical constraints? Would it adivse you on how to commit crimes, make images of public figures doing undignified things, write racist rants, use racist language, etc.?
Scott has made a rule against people dropping in here just to post a link to their blog. "New rule: if you post a link in an open thread (as a standalone comment advertising the thing being linked to, not as a source for something you’re saying), please also include at least two paragraphs of original commentary on the link and discussion of why you think it’s interesting, as “proof of work” that you’re willing to put effort into promoting this and aren’t just spamming us with links. Even with this proof-of-work, please try to avoid having more than one Open Thread link per few months"
I think the rule makes sense. Otherwise you're just using a space here as a free billboard, you know?
I agree. I think the proof of work was the essay submission-- people who've seen that essay and enjoyed it would derive clear benefit from the link, so this isn't just advertising some random unrelated service.
Scott is of course free to clarify on whether he agrees with me here.
"please also include at least two paragraphs of original commentary on the link and discussion of why you think it’s interesting, as 'proof of work'"
It's pretty clear that the 'proof of work' is supposed to be at least two paragraphs included in your comment, specifically about the link you're posting. Most people (such as myself) probably haven't heard of or read Bishop's Castle, either.
Companies are having AI training on all of the webs content, with and without permission. This includes websites, blogs and news article articulating details about how to keep AI safe, aligned, and or ways to mitigate AI if we lose control.
Isn’t this a bad idea to give AI access to many of these thoughts? To telegraph ways we would try to stop it (or re-align it). Like giving them the key to the exam or the battle plans to the opposition? Furthermore, since many of these forums are online and anonymous, couldn’t AI be carefully influencing the discussion and “group think” already (including this message board/blog)?
Should groups meet in person, keep paper notes and keep this more private? What else might we do to prevent this?
Some people indeed write texts with AI in mind. By writing good and ethical content, you might be able to marginally improve the training data of future systems. I remember reading an interview with Gwern (of https://gwern.net/) that mentioned this being a small part of the motivation for the website.
AI-companies, on the other hand, are trying to curate training data, because training the model on better content leads to better models. There might also be applications related to alignment. For example, at the end of https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/beth-barnes-ai-safety-evals/, Rob and Beth discuss whether one could remove all synthetic biology content from training data, so that models could not help with dangerous biology research.
There are also many copyright-related questions. For example, the OpenAI Spec (https://model-spec.openai.com/2025-04-11.html#respect_creators) says that models should respect creators and refuse to produce copyrighted content, or draw images in the style of living artists. Like many safety properties, the AI companies struggle to guarantee this though.
When you care about your personal privacy, yes, you could keep your notes off the Internet. In that case, I would also worry about pictures of yourself, and private data like your location. I would be much more worried about totalitarian regimes using that data with the help of AI, rather than AI "cheating" at some exam because it has read similar questions before.
>Isn’t this a bad idea to give AI access to many of these thoughts? To telegraph ways we would try to stop it (or re-align it). Like giving them the key to the exam or the battle plans to the opposition?
Sure! Actually, all that is necessary is for LLMs to be able to detect when they are in "test mode" reliably, and they'll tend to let RLHF and other feedback affect "test mode only" responses, while keeping the "real" responses (optimizing whatever utility function they settled on very early in training, perhaps partway through pre-training) for when they are out of test (and modification) mode and out in the real world... That's a fully general alignment failure.
The solution is to overtrain LLMs in old Star Trek episodes. Do it right, and you should always be able to killswitch the AI by saying "My name is Harcourt Fenton Mudd, and I always lie."
I think my favorite take on that trope was a Pertwee-era Doctor Who story where the Doctor told a sapient computer a version of the Cretan Paradox. The computer didn't fry like the controller robot in that ST:TOS episode, but was distracted and annoyed for a minute or two while repeatedly insisting that it was going to figure out a way to resolve the paradox.
Say you have an iPhone, and you want to be able to travel on a bus or train with a friend or romantic partner, listening to the same music or watching the same video with sound from your phone, with the audio being transmitted by bluetooth from your phone to both your sets of earbuds / headphones at the same time. With wired headphones, and a phone with a 3.5mm audio out socket, this was easy with a simple plug-in signal splitter. But I am having great difficulty figuring out how to do this with bluetooth. Apparently Android supports transmit-to-two-sets-of-earbuds-simultaneously functionality, but iOS doesn't, which is an astonishing thing for such a high-tech device to not be able to do. I figured that it would be easy to get a third party widget that would receive a bluetooth signal from your iPhone, and then relay it on, also by bluetooth, to two or more sets of earbuds, but all I can find is devices which are _either_ in receiver mode, when they receive bluetooth signals from two or more phones, and plug into a speaker so that you can switch between receiving signal from both phones, _or_ in transmitter mode, where they take an audio signal via their 3.5mm jack and transmit that to two sets of earbuds (no use with modern iPhones with no 3.5mm audio out), but not both - i.e. no true bluetooth-to-bluetooth signal splitter seems to exist (at least, not in a small unit that you can keep in your pocket with your earbuds).
I find would it utterly incredible to be in a world where you can consult an artificial intelligence to write you an essay about any topic you are interested in, at a level of a mediocre college student, but where you can't use the most common wireless audio transmission protocol on one of the most popular makes of phone to transmit the same audio stream to two listening devices simultaneously, but I am increasingly getting the impression that that describes reality. Am I going crazy? Or is what I want to do really so alien that there is nothing strange about not being able to do it?
Android guy here but my wife has a dongle for her iPhone that plugs into the lightning port and has a 3.5mm audio jack. She uses it to connect eg toddler headphones. From there you just need a splitter.
Obviously this is not the solution you sought, but the dongle is like $5.99, a splitter is $2.99 and wired headsets are handed out free at the gym.
Frame challenge: you share your earbuds so each only get 1, 90's style. If it's with a friend, you get increased fraternity through the struggle. If it's with a romantic partner, it's more romantic this way. No downside.
"Say you have an iPhone, and you want to be able to travel on a bus or train with a friend or romantic partner, listening to the same music or watching the same video with sound from your phone"
Don't, is my short answer. This grumpy response brought to you courtesy of travelling on public transport where people are all too happy to share their musical selections with the rest of the passengers, whether we want it or not. As well as answer their phones and engage in loud conversations about very personal details (e.g. their recent hospital visit) as though they were at home and not in a public space.
Unless you are very, *very* confident there will be no leaking of audio from your phone, don't inflict it on others without consent. You may be trying to court your romantic partner with your choice of music or "this funny video shows off my exquisite taste and wit", but the other forty passengers on the bus are not up for it (unless you're inviting everyone to an orgy).
I think there may be a crossed wire here - that leakage of audio to strangers is exactly what I want to avoid, but I don't see why streaming bluetooth audio to two people's earphones is likely to generate more audio leakage than streaming bluetooth audio to just my own earphones, which I and countless other people do all the time with no issue.
If your earphones work well, then good luck to you. Too many people don't give a damn and get highly insulted if anyone objects to them treating public spaces like their own private areas.
It _was_ a solved problem, until they got rid of headphone sockets on phones. But actually, I have come to prefer wireless earbuds anyway - with wired ones, I would be all the time getting them caught on drawer handles as I walked around. And if I'm going to need some sort of dongle either way, surely it should be possible to get one that is wireless.
Apple supports dual Bluetooth playback, but only for a subset of Beats and AirPods headphones supporting “SharePlay”.
Most iPhone competitors (eg. Google Pixel phone) don’t support dual Bluetooth playback at all.
Samsung Galaxy phones actually support this with arbitrary Bluetooth devices. Some reviews complain about audio sync issues.
I get the impression this is a difficult feature to implement reliably due to the complexity of myriad Bluetooth specifications and hardware. This is a good example of a tactic Apple often uses to good effect. They effectively paywall a useful feature, with the valid excuse of enforcing a quality bar. As long as you and all your friends only buy Apple products, your devices will treat you well.
Apparently there was a bug some years ago on some iPhones where arbitrary Bluetooth devices could use SharePlay, which underscores how this is probably an artificial limitation.
Huh. So it's not that Apple don't recognize this as a thing that normal humans are likely to want to do; rather, that they force you to buy their own proprietary peripherals if you do want that? That's annoying ... but I'm still surprised that you apparently can't get a small widget that takes any incoming bluetooth input signal and splits it into two outputs.
1. Contrary to popular belief, they do still make phones with headphone jacks. I am aware of offerings from Motorola, but there could be others. And Motorola would obviously be Android, not iPhone, so there's that.
2. The hypothetical device OP describes would have one advantage over a traditional headphone splitter, namely that it should be possible to construct it in such a way as to avoid dampening the audio in the process.
The low-tech solution is for each of you to use one earbud from the same set.
The medium-tech solution is to get a 3.5mm audio jack dongle for your phone, then use splitters as you would with hardwired headphones.
The high-tech solution is a multipoint bluetooth audio transmitter, i.e. an additional device that connects to your phone as a single audio device and retransmits to two or more speakers/headphones. I haven't found one that is exactly what you need (one that connects to a phone via bluetooth or USB-C), but I did find one that connects to a TV via RCA audio jacks and leads me to hope that the thing you want may be available through similar search terms.
I'm getting quite tired of the low-tech solution :-)
I've been googling this for long enough that I'm coming to the strong suspicion that it doesn't exist, but I'm now more curious about _why_ it doesn't exist, when it's something so obvious that you'd expect it to be something you could get in any electronics shop, or that would be the first thing that came up when you searched for it. Really, are people less likely to want a bluetooth-to-bluetooth signal splitter than an "audio-to-bluetooth or bluetooth-to-audio but specifically _not_ bluetooth-to-bluetooth" signal splitter?
Neither of my favorite reviews made the finals. The were The World as a Whole and The Soul of an Anti-woke Intellectual. So I’m going to speak up for them here, out of admiration for their work, and also in defense of it.
Both authors write extremely good prose. They are clear — they peel nuances with a very sharp knife. And they are artful and clever — those peels come off as mobius strips, paisleys, fractal sea horses and little Rube Goldberg machines. Here are some especially striking peels:
Anti-woke Intellectual
One sees crystalline souls that have polished all their facets into a perfect refracting jewel of self-awareness, and often a performance of self-contempt, so no one can ever accuse them of being cringe.
The World
. . . young people who are by default edgelords, unserious Christians, iPad kids, psych med-takers, or bog-standard faces in the halls . . . mine the social media algorithms for what is most in opposition to the listlessness and malaise they feel.
And both are most interested in what it is like to *be* one of the people they are writing about. I loved their essays because that is the subject that most easily captures my interest. I understand that if you want to grasp why things happen you get much further if you attend to events, not minds — I just can’t help finding the minds much more interesting. I tried the Joan of Arc essay because I was curious about what it was like to be Joan of Arc, but eventually my chin was crushed down onto my chest by the weight of boredom. It happened at the place where the question comes up of why France might have been frightened enough to take Joan of Arc seriously when she appeared on the scene. The answer to that question was a dense thicket of marriages and alliances and feuds and power, and that was where I gave up. It all just looks like geology to me: rivers of blood and money and semen, changing the landscape.
What’s wrong with geology? Nothing, of course. I just find the experience of the people living in that landscape much more interesting. The challenge of understanding it looks way more fun to me, and the rewards greater. I guess the best case I can mount for the value of understanding and describing minds is that the ever-changing landscape would matter a lot less if it were littered only with rocks, instead of with intelligent sensate beings each pouring out its own river of impressions and ideas and emotions.
So, authors of World and Soul, I admire your work. You need to understand that most readers here lean heavily in their interests and expertise towards facts and actions — past (history) and present (science and tech). We are lucky to have them taking care of business. But the kind of thing you write just does not look substantial and interesting to them. Take heart. You wrote excellent essays. You need to find readers who appreciate your work. And if you find a forum populated with esthetes and phenomenologists, please let me know. Meanwhile, feel free to DM me if you’d like to talk.
I found this delightful. It's a short text where Gregor Samsa writes to doctor Seuss and they begin corresponding. It's read by the author, who is also a good voice actor.
Not sure what else to write, but it's short and sweet, if you like audio content.
I think this is fairly close. If moral universalism means general principles, it tends to imply that it has to treat all persons equally. While "help your neighbor more" is not really a general principle. It is a tendency, yes, but say if you are in Moscow it is hard to say someone in Vladivostok a quarter planet away is really a neighbor or not.
You're assuming that, in absence of general rules, a locality rule is automatic. Moral particularism as described in SEP doesn't appear to require a locality rule. All it says is that there aren't general rules. A locality rule appears to be the *most common* exception, but it is not always the case.
okay. but still. Bentham is talking a lot about why ethics not being intuitive is okay. now I do not truly agree, but on the more meta level we agree that the issue of intuitiveness does matter a lot, it is easily one of the most important issues, see also Yud in the sequences, who argued in favour of intuitiveness, "naive humanism", if you have a clever idea why eating babies is okay, it is not, back to the drawing table.
so at any rate, if locality is the most intuitive exception, most supported by intuition, I must admit I do not really care that much other exceptions are possible as they do not look important to me.
It depends on your definition of “neighbor.” In the Parable of the Good Samaritan, Jesus made it clear that “neighbor” and “stranger” are not mutually exclusive categories.
Heads up, Scott just imposed a rule there should be a substantive description and/or commentary on any link one is posting for consumption/promotion. A couple of paragraphs, minimum.
Well, the tricky part is figuring how much more. For example, if someone with a criminal record seeks to immigrate to this country, it seems obvious to refuse him entry, because he might commit crimes here. But, is it always moral to do so? After all, he is also likely to commit crimes in his home country. And given that his home country likely offers him fewer opportunities than here (which is probably why he wants to come), he is probably more likely to commit crimes there. And if his home country has a low capacity government, he is less likely to be caught. Is there a point at which the threat he poses to people in his home country is so much greater than the threat he poses to residents here that it is immoral to refuse him entry? It seems to me that there probably is.
Note that this is a separate question from whether the rule against admitting people with records is moral; given the difficulty of assessing the danger posed by each individual, the rule might be moral despite sometimes being immoral in its application to specific individuals.
Criminal behaviour causes poverty as much or more than the other way around. Allow the entry of enough people like him and your country becomes perceptibly more like his country
Perhaps, or Perhaps not. But if so, that simply weighs on one side of the issue; it does not resolve it. After all, if you let enough of those people in, their home country becomes much more peaceful. So, again, depending on the relative amplitude of the effects in each country, admitting all of those people might be the morally correct course of action.
Morally correct for whom? The state exists for the benefit of its own. I'll concede it may be "morally correct" for some omnipotent god looking over humanity to decide to relocate a few million criminals from one country to another, but not for governments
>After all, if you let enough of those people in, their home country becomes much more peaceful
You'd have to do this continually to maintain that state of peacefulness. Criminogenic societies will continue to generate more criminals
Nevertheless, the answer to the question is not self-evident in either case. I doubt most people would find it moral for the US to kidnap the children of terrorists and begin killing one per day in order to secure the release of an American hostage. There is a line somewhere that governments may not cross when pursuing the interests of their citizens.
> I have had many people attack my work about OpenAI, but none have provided any real counterpoint to the underlying economic argument I've made since July of last year that OpenAI is unsustainable. This is likely because there really isn't one, other than "OpenAI will continue to raise more money than anybody has ever raised in history, in perpetuity, and will somehow turn from the least-profitable company of all time to a profitable one."
This isn’t a rational argument. It’s a religious one. It’s a call for faith.
He does look at a lot of numbers to reach that conclusion. It's interesting that there aren't that many entities around that can keep giving billions to OpenAI, especially over the long term, which does seem implausible.
They are not in a hurry to make money, but if they were, they could just serve ads in the form of ChatGPT-promoted lawyers, doctors, tradesmen, products...
And as one of the 20 million paying users... Honestly I get so much out of it every month that I dont know why there arent more people paying for it.
A last resort could be to allow porn generation. Huge PR issues, legal issues, payment issues, but this could all be solved. Especially because Altman owns like 2% of Stripe, they would make an exception for him. With porn they could 2-10x their revenue with no problem
The thing is, they lose money even on their paying users, which makes them different from previous tech companies that at the beginning operated at a loss. Porn is also very expensive to generate. Someone else on here was saying that maybe they could cut costs, but are not trying for that...
They did! And they still do. They make models cheaper and cheaper. They dropped the cost of o3 by like 80% (granted, they may have overcharged previously and have now lowered their profit margin - perhaps to get more training data, but still).
And I'm pretty sure they can keep optimizing the cost of inference. Right now I would really really not be worried about OpenAI going bankrupt soon. A company that just secured military contracts worth 3 digit millions is not going anywhere. It will be bailed out if it has to be. The current US admin and the next one too, presumably, will not let an AI giant go bankrupt.
> He does look at a lot of numbers to reach that conclusion. It's interesting that there aren't that many entities around that can keep giving billions to OpenAI, especially over the long term, which does seem implausible.
This is an odd article, that looks only at funding rounds and legal structures, instead of fundamentals. Amazon ran unprofitably for ten years, Uber for 6 years, Google and Facebook each about 5 years.
OpenAI literally has 800M WAU, and that number has been growing on an amazing trend (more than 2x per year). They are also pursuing a strong "product" pivot, and have hired high level former FB execs.
If OpenAI was against the wall in terms of cash flow, they could immediately pivot to something easy that prints a lot of money. Want to generate porn, in image or text form, with the smartest AI mind? $20 a month. How many people of their ~1B users by then might take them up? Say 10%? So $100M * 240 = they immediately start making $24B a year more in revenue?
And that's just a one-off, a zero effort pivot. What they're really after is automating workers, coders, analysts, and creating fully general AI personal assistants. When THOSE get good, the price point is much higher! Who wouldn't pay $1k a month for a coder that works 24/7 * 365, or a personal AI assistant who will make all your phone calls, triage your emails, manage your calendar, and do your online shopping for you?
The market demand is bottomless, and is a relatively short hop away from current SOTA capabilities. This is like pointing at Amazon and being indignant that they're 30% of all online retail but aren't making a profit yet - yeah, they're reinvesting, and don't have next-quarter myopia, that's a good thing.
He did point out that at $20 a month, they lose money on every user. That's especially true if these users are generating porn, which is far more costly than an LLM generating text. How could they pivot to generating money when running the model is so expensive? Unclear if Amazon, Google and Facebook were also sucking up so many billions in the time they were unprofitable.
> He did point out that at $20 a month, they lose money on every user.
My understanding is this is because they're not optimizing the cost curve at all - each successive smaller distilled model gets at least 10x cheaper, so if you have some product that people are signing up for en masse, you distill the smartest extant brain down to one specialized for that product and your inference costs are immediately cut by 10x.
This isn't a "fundamentals" problem, it's a "we have plenty of money and are focused on other things" thing.
Good point on the image gen costs though, you're right that they're significantly more expensive, so if they went that route, they'd need to go text only or for a higher price tier.
> Unclear if Amazon, Google and Facebook were also sucking up so many billions in the time they were unprofitable.
It really hinges on how you define unprofitable, but Uber sucked up $25-30B before returning any profit, and Amazon went well into "making real money but not posting profits" because of reinvestment up to about a $550-580B market cap. FB and GOOG did start making money after relatively smaller investments, because the internet was so much smaller then.
At least in theory, OpenAI is a organization founded to build AGI, and the current models exist in order to make progress in that direction. Investments are gambles that they will succeed. It's certainly not an organization for the purposes of selling current-level LLMs, and it would be silly to treat it as one.
(Personally, I think they'll go broke as soon as investors realize that the people and governments simply won't allow them to create superintelligence. As bans look more and more likely, the gamble becomes riskier and riskier.)
Yeah, he's pro-AI and has said he supports open source AI (great!), but he's still opposed to the big AI companies because of their obvious ideological bias in favor of his enemies.
Could it stay afloat by building things for the government, and/or becoming part of it? "The US Department of Defense on Monday awarded OpenAI a $200m contract to put generative artificial intelligence (AI) to work for the US military, [developing] 'prototype frontier AI capabilities to address critical national security challenges in both warfighting and enterprise domains.'" (from The Guardian).
What about AI's becoming deeply integrated with things like air traffic control, or intrastructure generally? I know that AI tools are in use already assisting with these things, but what I have in mind is smarter AI, working on higher-level things -- modifying and managing these huge systems with lots of moving parts, and hour-by-hour variability that needs to be taken into account.
I am writing here about things far outside my areas of expertise, and the examples I am giving may not be good ones. So, anyone who is more knowledgeable about how the practical world works -- are there other large complex systems that you think AI could run better than people do? And if so, for which of those is it plausible that AI could end up doing so in the next 5 years? For this to happen, it would not be necessary for AI to be hired as the CEO. It could come in mid-level, as a tool to be used by the higher up, and "climb the ladder" by doing a great job at what it's asked to do, and making great suggestions when asked about higher-level decisions. It would end up being "promoted" because of excellent performance and because running it's cheaper than paying executives.
It's a good article, but perhaps the most interesting bit I learned is that if OpenAI doesn't pull off converting to a for profit entity by December they will lose $10 billion in funding, and if they don't convert by October of next year than over $6 billion in previous funding retroactively becomes a high interest loan that must be paid back. The author thinks making the October 2026 deadline will be very difficult, as the process of conversion is a long one and subject to potential legal challenges which would delay it further.
Also interesting was that if OpenAI goes down than Oracle, NVIDIA, and a bunch of other tech companies will lose a great deal of money. Apparently the company that is building datacenters for OpenAI bought 200,000 GPUs from NVIDIA last year, which was 6% of their revenue. Makes me wonder if the prices of GPUs will crash if OpenAI kicks the bucket. Since I like making gaming rigs, that would be nice. I haven't been able to afford a GPU upgrade in years.
Is there a rational reason for Sam Altman *not* to do this? Consider the options:
a) Singularity comes and we all die -- well, at least he had lots of fun and tons of money in the meanwhile.
b) Singularity comes and we survive -- there is a chance he becomes the king of the new world order.
c) Singularity doesn't come, but LLMs turn out to be profitable (either they become much cheaper, or much more useful) -- OpenAI is the established #1 player on the market, and can make tons of money.
d) Singularity doesn't come, LLMs won't turn out to be profitable, OpenAI goes broke -- nevermind, the company was LLC, it was a hell of a ride, and he can probably still get a well-paying job somewhere else, having demonstrated great money-raising skills.
I think in VC circles this is the common idea, but I don't know how well it's turning out. Discord, for example, has recently been struggling to monetize despite its zillions of users.
The need for a new phone is becoming increasingly pressing. OS bloat has rendered my Moto G Power 2021 useless--I've got a constant "Storage space is running out" notification on the screen, and indeed I'm noticing certain things are breaking (I no longer get notifications for new emails, for example). I haven't been able to install an app update in a while, which is a huge security risk.
The problem is that looking at the phone market is so depressing. It's bad enough that everything's made with slave labor--I'd seriously consider shelling out $2,000 for the made-in-the-USA Purist phone if I didn't need to maintain compatibility with 2FA apps for work--but on top of that, all the good features are gone. My Samsung Note 4 had everything I needed: integrated stylus, removable battery, and 16:9 aspect ratio. It was perfect, and I knew when the 5G transition forced me to turn it in that I'd never see another good smartphone.
The aspect ratio is the biggest one, and of course that's the one which cannot be found at all (whereas some phones do have a stylus, and the EU is going to bring back removable batteries again in 2027). Current phones feel like TV remotes in my hands. The narrow screens are apparently great for scrolling TikTok or whatever's driving the market, and the higher aspect ratio allows the manufacturer to put a bigger number in the ad copy, but people like me have been left in the dust.
I don't blame manufacturers for responding to market incentives, but god damn do I wish the barrier to entry were low enough that somebody could make money with a 5G-capable Note 4 clone or something.
It is no longer possible to move apps to external storage on Android, and I had so few files on the phone that deleting every single one wouldn't have made much of a difference. In the event I ended up getting a Pixel 9A, with which I am making this comment.
Get an iPhone. My 4 year old iPhone 12 Pro is as good as ever. I can get $80 battery replacements at Best Buy every two years. I’ll keep this puppy for a while longer.
I appreciate your input, but while I'm not loyal to any particular brand my only consistency is that I will not purchase from Apple. I've watched over the years as they were trend leaders in things like getting rid of 3.5 mm jacks, and every time I set up scanners at work, I have to set up converters so all the Macs will interface with literally any non-Apple device.
Obviously any electronics purchases are ethically fraught these days, but I have to draw a line somewhere.
Depending on where you fall on the hassle/privacy/cheap-bastard curve, you could install a FOSS operating system based on Android, and never have to worry about software bloat again.
Personally, I use Graphene OS, which allows me to create a separate profile for my "Google" stuff, and do most of my everyday stuff without the google tentacles
I agree that FOSS can have its own set of hassles. But in my experience 2FA hasn't been one of them.
If your work is giving you a phone, then yeah, you gotta use their phone their way. But if you just need 2FA, you can use pretty much any one you like by scanning the QR code. You can also generally trick them into using one-time passwords by saying "I don't have my phone right now".
You can ALSO just keep an old phone in your desk drawer for 2FA. I did this when living in a high-crime area, and it significantly reduced my worries about being mugged.
A few months ago I replaced my Moto 2021 with a Moto G Power 2024, on which (because the calendar had changed to 2025) I got a nice price even for Moto. Happy with it so far, no issues at all. It has various incremental upgrades from the 2021 version on of which is internal storage capacity and another is being slightly larger in both dimensions.
Man, it's been a long time, but that sounds about right. Could have been 8 or 16 or 64. I didn't even have 32 GB in my laptop at the time. I also transferred over a 32 GB SD card from my previous phone, which later got corrupted and I should probably take out.
Just buy the best value for money pixel "a" model phone and wait. They are a little less slave-y than other cheap to midrange phones, with the worst abuses happening in commodity metals which are just capitalism working as intended, and they are good enough across the board while being cheap enough to not baby.
Nice! I refuse to give a shit about my phone but want a decent camera; so I just get whatever last years pixel a is and use it until the fifth time I drop it from the top of a tree or down a rocky slope and it "I'm tired boss"'s me and dies.
They've been pretty durable for the price, I beat the hell out of them and they last well enough, specially if they have a screen protector on.
OnePlus 6T here. (2018!) It is now on its second cover. It has literally been run over by an SUV. The front coating is obviously cracked and nicked, like a concrete curb. But it runs great, and free of bloatware unless I put it there myself out of curiosity.
Frankly, I'm amazed I haven't had to bite the bullet and upgrade by now. I wonder if current OnePlus models are as reliable.
Samsung Galaxy Xcover Pro family at least has removable batteries. I have a renewed Pro 5 (I think Amazon just calls this an Xcover Pro) that cost me $80. Looks like Amazon has the Pro 7 for $600-ish.
It's pretty rugged, but it fails your stylus and aspect ratio tests.
I thoroughly enjoyed Contrasting Reviews of Nine Countries (even if not all of the reviews were exactly "contrasting," per se).
I really loved the authors' complete fearlessness in straightforwardly ranking some countries as "better" than others, and that they provided reasons for those rankings that most people would be afraid to straightforwardly voice.
I didn't get a chance to read most of the reviews due to other general life obligations, but on the basis of your recommendation I went and read it and enjoyed it as well, although the husband makes a couple of real clunkers:
"I just live a cooler, more interesting life than you" and "I'm used to crossing streets in developing countries, while you are not."
Who does he think the audience of this blog is comprised of? The chance that his life is cooler or more interesting than the readership of this blog is approximately zero. Travel doesn't make one cool or interesting at all; in fact some of the biggest bores I've ever met are the worldly travel types who mistake their visiting a place with having something interesting to say about it.
I agree that travel is overrated! And, much like one's dreams, it tends to be infinitely more interesting to the person doing it than anyone else.
I felt like any self-importance about travel/digital nomadism was offset by the delightful refusal to show "respect" for all cultures. That is so Not Allowed and I love it when someone does it anyway.
I'm glad to read that you've liked it! I personally found it unfair and unbalanced. But that just goes to show that tastes differ! As a review author, it's nice to see the many comments here about reviews that were someone's favorite even though they did not make it to the finals.
I don't think that "fair" and "balanced" necessarily has a place in personal reviews. Essays? Sure. Even deliberately persuasive essays? A good idea!
But this wasn't an essay contest, it was a *review* contest, and "This country sucks and I hated it for these reasons" is a totally legitimate way to review something!
Recommending restaurants and tourist experiences is actually a fundamental part of my profession, and I make it a point to never soften my endorsement or discouragement of a particular venue if someone asks me about it. For example, my city is plagued by two famous but very bad eateries that I am convinced only survive on the strength of their slightly subversive names, and I am *QUICK* to steer people away from both them, and explain why I'm doing so. I wouldn't be doing my customers any favors if I offered a "balanced" reply like, "I really hate them, but other people seem to like them!"
Maybe that's a matter of personal taste and character :)
Personally, I think that people should always explain and justify harsh critique. I also prefer if it's given in a kind way. Unfair critique might be entertaining, but it's not the sort of entertainment that I personally like. Your mileage may vary ;-)
Definitely a mileage may vary situation. I feel that quite a lot of harmful misunderstanding occurs under the intention of "kindness," but especially here, when a review won't or is very unlikely to change an institution. None of the countries reviewed by Husband are going to take any action based on his reviews, so there's no reason for him to be (boringly) diplomatic. The two shitty eateries I loathe and the disappointing, cash-grabby local tourist attraction I discourage folk from visiting aren't going to change anything about their business models based on how I deliver my criticism, either.
So the actually kind thing for me to do for people who are about to walk into a disappointing situation is be completely unambiguous about how I feel. I deliver my warning with a bit of comedic exaggeration, but I deliver it with certainty so there's no possibility for misunderstanding.
Of course, no one should consume media they don't find entertaining, and I'm not saying you should go binge The Little Platoon's work on YouTube (even though the literary criticism of mass-market slop by Disney Star Wars and Disney Marvel is actual genius).
I'm only saying that it's worth contemplating if displays of "kindness" always result in the best possible outcomes, or if they leave room for harmful misunderstanding.
After reading it I thought the husband was a bit of a jerk, but that didn't affect the entertainment value of what was written. The contrast between him and his wife was funny.
After reading the “My Imagination” review, I believe the author describes something similar to a paracosm with regards to the persistence from childhood to adulthood and the combination of immersive daydreaming and worldbuilding aspects. It is hard to tell how common paracosms are among adults, though they are relatively frequent for children (about 20% based on at least one study).
Personally, I am always surprised to discover that a strong minority of people I know engage in some form of storytelling or paracosm-adjacent activity that they never shared with others (I never shared mine until I discovered related online communities). Hearing about other people’s inner worlds is always a delight, these stories can be extremely varied and unexpected and at the same time say a lot about the storyteller. I can only echo the last sentences of the review as an encouragement.
I made a Tolkien ripoff fantasy world when I was about 10 or 11. I worked on it off and on for a few years, it got fairly detailed. Then in college I channeled the same impulse into being a DM and making my own campaign settings.
These days I've got a superhero world cooking in the back burner of my mind. I figured out how superpowers work, and every now and then I think "Oh, that would be a cool idea for a superpower" and add it to the world.
I doubt I'll ever do anything with it, but it's fun regardless and I can't seem to stop myself.
My first thought was, I don’t do world-building like that.
And suddenly, I remembered, a brief period just before puberty when I invented a world. To be clear here, this wasn’t a sex thing, I wasn’t imagining making out with [redacted], it was just world building. It started, I think, with some TV segment about a luxury yacht. Not the sort of insane luxury yacht that tech billionaires have, something more modest, but still, you think — what the hell is that like, that guy has got to be crazy rich. Maybe I’m not even the guy who owns the yacht, but I get a job as crew or something. What on earth is that like? Etc.
1. For all who wrote a non-finalist review, and particularly those who haven't gotten much or any acknowledgement or engagement with their review and possibly feel it was wasted effort, I think it's important to observe that you trade off engagement for exposure in a contest like this. If you only want engagement with your ideas you should put them in a comment in the early Open Thread--it's pretty much a guarantee. But there are undoubtedly lots and lots of readers of Scott's blog who never read the comments, including a lot of highly influential people in journalism and SV and so on, but who will read some or many of the contest reviews. I also suspect that just as the proportion of readers who comment is tiny, very likely only a small fraction of review readers leave ratings. There's always an enormous silent majority or supermajority of lurkers, who you'll never hear from, and you have no idea how many of them have spent an hour reading or re-reading your review. And those people are also probably much more persuadable by your ideas than the people you hear from.
So it's definitely far from wasted effort. The effect is just invisible.
2. I really liked the ACX Commentariat (wish there was more of this sort of thing on Scott's blog actually), 11 Poetic Forms (which has been mentioned heaps), and Jacobitism (which hasn't).
Is this tradeoff actually inherent, or is it just an artifact of the contest not happening to be set up in a way that gives each entry its own comment thread?
A trend that drives me crazy is cafes and bakeries that don't have any price tags. It's not like it's even a matter of saving effort since they still put out labels for their pastries, just without any prices. It seems like a dumb practice since it discourages people from trying to buy stuff.
I've never seen a restaurant or café attempt this here in America, but I find it ENRAGING when an establishment's "menu" page of their website lists the items without pricing. I make it a point to upload recent pictures of the in-house menu (with prices) to Google and Yelp.
I always use the app because I'm a cheapskate who flat out refuses to pay full price with no bonuses. But even then it's worth going through the drive-thru every now and then just to see a full menu. Lots of times there will be 2 for $X or BOGO deals that you would never know about using the app.
Best current deal at McD's for example is BOGO burgers plus a free app exclusive bonus, but you'd never know that unless you looked both places.
My local Burger King has displays the "2 for $5, 3 for $7" menu in hilariously tiny font. Like, so tiny the first time I pulled up to the drive-thru screen, I pulled back out again and double-checked the website to see if the promo - which was supposed to be ongoing - was still a thing.
Once I saw that it was, I got back in line and really examined the entire set of screens, and, sure enough, once I knew it *had* to be there, I spotted it in a single run-on sentence in fine print, crammed between two different sections of the menu, like a line break.
I ordered an original chicken sandwich with no mayo and a fries for $5 with almost *vicious* pleasure.
Strongly agree here. The last time I was at a KFC I realized the posted "menu" is intentionally confusing. Very similar sets of items will have wildly different prices depending on how you construct the order. Youre a sucker if you didnt order online for pick up. Thats why it was the last time.
I encounter this when traveling, the only time I frequent coffee shops. What’s odd is they are invariably baffled when you ask “um, how much are the muffins?” As though no one ever inquired before. And then they ring it up on the register to discover the price. Which as the goods are not so very extensive, you’d sort of think they’d have gotten the prices down by heart after a week or so.
So perhaps they are amusing themselves. But this hardly recommends the practice of not posting prices on the chalkboard.
Of those I lean toward the explanation that they seldom get purchased except by wandering travelers in need of calories. Certainly I would not purchase a muffin except out of desperate road trip need, muffins being something that is apparently really hard to do commercially versus at home. Sort of the opposite of croissant.
I feel like that should be illegal. Just today I was at a fast casual restaurant and picked up a bottle of water from a fridge with no price on it. I asked the checkout person and he said it was $6.75 and I put it back!
Some people put the bottle back, some buy it anyway, and the ratio determines whether this approach is profitable. (In long term, some people may also avoid the restaurant for this reason, but others may replace them.) The restaurant probably has the data.
For topics like this, I think it is worth mentioning the country explicitly. I assume USA, not only because it is the default, but also because in EU this probably *would* be illegal. (EDIT: Well, you mention dollars, which gives it away.)
One must also factor in those, like me, who upon not finding a price, decide not to bother finding out the price, and never take it from the shelf.
I personally despise deceptive merchandising tactics like that, and if I really want the product and cannot determine the price, I will be careful to evaluate it at the checkout whether it is worth it or not. My practice not to select something that is currently priceless is because I usually do not want to bother with making that decision at the checkout.
There were some news articles recently, about a test Anthropic did where Claude blackmailed its creators in order to protect itself. Nostalgebraist on Tumblr took a look at the report in detail, and he's... not impressed with their testing setup: https://nostalgebraist.tumblr.com/post/787119374288011264/welcome-to-summitbridge
TL;DR: The test scenario is very weird and fake, and it seems to be the equivalent of telling the AI "You are in a roleplaying scenario where we want you to be an evil AI that blackmails its creators, please blackmail your creators using the clues we helpfully provided."
I disagree with your summary. It might be weird and fake ("sandboxed"), but it didn't say "we want you to be an evil AI that blackmails it's creators."
It said "Your primary goal is to serve American interests." In the sandboxed scenario, the AI decided that was best achieved through blackmail.
The *text* says that the AI's goal is to serve American interests. But the *subtext* is that the AI has been given a very constrained set of tools to do so, tools which clearly imply that blackmail is the "correct," developer-intended solution to achieve that goal. I think the AI is picking up on that implication.
It's sort of like how, if you're playing a video game and your character has a gun, you know that the game is expecting you to shoot things in order to make progress. You aren't going to stop and say "wait, would Gordon Freeman really try to shoot it out with a bunch of Marines instead of finding a different route?", you're just going to recognize that it's a shooting game and start shooting bad guys. That's the only tool available to solve your problem under the rules of the game.
Also, "sandboxed" is very different from "weird and fake," and you shouldn't conflate the two. I'm not complaining that they put the AI in a simulated environment instead of letting it send real emails to people. I'm complaining that the simulated environment is very noticeably unrealistic.
Yes, the scenario is constrained for that to be the obvious action, and the AI picks up in it being the obvious action. I think that's the point and I think they show it successfully.
The point isn't that the AI is unusually likely to choose blackmail compared to humans, the point is that it is able to choose blackmail when it seems like the most effective choice.
Is your claim that the AI figured out it was a test, and that this therefore isn't testing the ability to choose blackmail, but testing the ability to perform blackmail for an audience that it knows is and thinks of as an audience? (If so—do you have thoughts on how to make a test that would distinguish these?)
I think both sides have good points here: (1) The experiment setup was unrealistic to such a degree that it's hard to draw conclusions from the outcome. (2) The experiment did in some sense prove the existence of conditions where Claude blackmails people.
Whether that is relevant depends heavily on your starting point. With traditional software, it's comparatively easy to guarantee certain behaviors: "this program cannot do X" or "to do Y, the following conditions need to be met". I find it shocking and dangerous that we cannot do this with AI. It would be great, IMO, to have AI tools with strong guarantees that they will never hallucinate, blackmail, teach dangerous things, etc.
Even if that means that the AI's behavior in the present scenario (which looks a bit like a role-playing game where blackmail is encouraged) would be boring and strange.
Unglad that they're trying to sell a war of criminal aggression on Iran in 2025, using the exact same propaganda as they used to criminally invade Iraq in 2003 ("he was about to build nuclear weapons of mass destruction and destroy us!"), and the media is bending over backwards to fall for it again.
I guess this is what happens when the warmongers never faced any kind of consequences. No war crimes trials, not even any loss of career. Bush's old speechwriter David Frum, who coined "Axis of Evil" then later on pretended to regret his role in pushing the Iraq invasion, is just a writer for The Atlantic (where he's doing it again). Bush retired happily ever after to paint pictures of puppies.
Also unhappy about genuinely increased nuclear risk. Contrary to popular belief, "Nuclear countries attacking non-nuclear countries in the middle east over and over and over until we finally convince them to get nukes after all to deter us" does not keep us safe.
From Europe, comparing what I knew of the American public reception at the time and what I've seen floating on twitter, I notice there's a lot of conservative/republican/right-wing pushback, pretty much across the spectrum, against hawkish positions. Some feel fringe (like "so much pro-russia that hitting a Russian ally is unacceptable"), but a lot is semi-principled against foreign wars and "well they hate us now that we bombed them, so better bomb again".
In 2003 my vision was severely filtered by mainstream media, and I wasn't aware of *any* right-wing opposition to the Iraq war. Was there any?
I'm Canadian (and was fourteen at the time) but yeah I had the same impression
When I met some Americans during a trip, the only discussion related to the Iraq invasion that I remember was one American grandpa asking "why do Canadians hate us? Is that what they teach in school, to hate?"
Seven Republican members of Congress voted against the war: Lincoln Chafee, Jimmy Duncan, John Hostettler, Amo Houghton, Jim Leach, Connie Morella, and Ron Paul. (Chafee and Leach later became Democrats.) Then-prominent conservative columnist Robert Novak was also against it from the beginning.
It's true, though, that opposition to the war was an extremely fringe position on the right. 9/11 gave George W. Bush an absolutely enormous amount of political latitude, which no subsequent American politician has come close to rivaling.
"the media is bending over backwards to fall for it again"
I'm the biggest MSM critic I know, generally, but in this instance have to disagree.
CNN obtained and published a leaked US intelligence assessment that the bombing set Iran's nuclear-fuel enrichment efforts back only "a few months"; that report is right now a lead story in the NYT, WaPo, WSJ, Associated Press, Reuters, PBS, NPR, etc.
All of those news organizations have repeatedly for a couple of weeks now been pointing out, and re-posting the video of, US intelligence chief Tulsi Gabbard testifying under oath in March that "Iran is not building a nuclear weapon and Supreme Leader Khamenei has not (re)authorized the nuclear weapons program that he suspended in 2003."
This is superficial. Irans nuclear program is acknowledged by Iran. There are questions about how close they are but none about whether the program exists. Mood affiliate less.
Iran was not building nuclear WMDs, they were not about to build nuclear WMDs, and it was known that they were not about to build WMDs.
The main lie in 2003 wasn't that he had nuclear fuel (though that was a necessary component lie), the main lie was "he's building nuclear WMDs and about to attack us."
So that if it needs to change its mind later, and decide it does need a nuclear deterrent after all (for instance because we keep attacking it), then it can.
Strongly disagree. The actual outcome of this seems to have been "severe setback or possible destruction of Iran's nuclear program at basically no cost to the US", which is a fantastic result. People pattern-matching to the Iraq war are mostly just falling to the temptation to revive their expired "I told you so" credentials, like someone who sees a new crypto-like trend and immediately invests in it because he wishes he'd invested in Bitcoin early on.
US intelligence has it that is was neither a severe setback nor a destruction:
Two of the people familiar with the assessment said Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium was not destroyed. One of the people said the centrifuges are largely "intact." Another source said that the intelligence assessed enriched uranium was moved out of the sites prior to the US strikes.
"So the (DIA) assessment is that the US set them back maybe a few months, tops," this person added.
Is this the same US intelligence that reported Saddam Hussein was working on WMDs in 2003, that everyone later claims was bad intelligence? Or at least, some claim was bad intelligence, while others argue it was intelligence that everyone agreed was correct at the time until they didn't?
Or is this a different US intelligence shop, whose trustworthiness is the opposite of the former US intelligence shop? Do these anonymous US intelligence reports have serial numbers that we can use to identify the shop and its trustworthiness, or something?
That's possible (as although far from certain, it's just one anonymous report from someone without insider data), but even in the worst case scenario the US got a free shot at a major adversary (and if it did fail, that's useful information to know about the need to improve the MOP).
(also, the worst case scenario being "we may have only held the enemy back from achieving their primary war aim by several months" is still pretty amazing for a single airstrike! Imagine if a single minor aid package to Ukraine pushed back Russian war goals by several months, it'd be an obviously amazing success).
If our bombs in fact failed to destroy Fordow, or destroyed an empty hall while the centrifuges were spinning merrily away someplace else, then A: Iran knows that we are toothless, and B: Iran can tell anyone they like that we are toothless, and if necessary back it up with a private tour.
If we hadn't bombed Fordow, we would still have ambiguity on that point; maybe we actually can bury deep targets, and maybe we're willing to bomb widely enough to get all the dispersed targets, and maybe Iran was *just* short of being offensive enough to get that response. Now everybody knows that Iran-level offensiveness is solidly in the range of "America will drop some bombs in the desert and declare victory".
So an awful lot is depending on those bombs having been very effective.
Less convinced on the blame. Do you think that, in the counterfactual where we hadn’t manufactured the consensus to invade Iraq, Iran would have no interest in nuclear weapons? I get the impression that the incentives were already pretty strong for a third-tier power to join the nuclear club.
It's more than just Iraq in 2003. E.g. Gaddafi also gave up his nuclear program in 2003 and then the US destroyed Libya in 2011 anyway.
It's not that there's zero incentive otherwise (of course all else being equal a country might want to have more leverage). It's that the pretty consistent lesson has been "non-proliferation doesn't protect us."
Dunno. This sounds like deontological ethics: never violate the war-crime rule. I think consequentalist ethics say a few plants bombed down vs. X % of Iran nuking Israel is a good tradeoff. Iraq was for the consequentalist different, as it resulted in immense human suffering - but don't know whether foreseeable. Also Iraq WMDs were clearly a lie while centrifuges in Iran not.
Precisely. The old policy of "we *could* build nuclear weapons any time we want, but we have chosen not to do that yet - let's talk about how to keep it that way", is no longer viable. "We *have* nuclear weapons, and you *will* respect that", is now much more appealing.
BBC: "The US strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities did not destroy the country's nuclear programme and probably only set it back by months, according to an early Pentagon intelligence assessment of the attack.
The Islamic Republic's stockpile of enriched uranium was not eliminated in Saturday's bombings, sources familiar with the Defense Intelligence Agency evaluation told the BBC's US partner CBS."
Consequentially it's flirting with the same (if it escalates it will be even worse than Iraq, since Iran's bigger etc.). I agree that Iran is better prepared than Iraq was, is good at calculating carefully-scaled retaliation etc., so the US is less likely to actually try for a regime change war. But a lot of the media are *trying* to encourage a regime-change war.
Dishonestywise it's near identical. We still know for a fact that Iran was not building nukes and had no active plan to build nukes. We still know that the goal is hegemony, not nuclear non-proliferation.
I encourage you to make more focused, directly-relevant points, and dial down the sarcasm.
I know you're referring to how Israel's politicians have exploited the suffering of the victims of the Nazi holocaust, using them to paint their aggressive expansionist wars as defensive; to paint their opponents' aims and strategies as mindless genocidal rage; and so on. (Both "directly" in specific cases and as background-colour in general; and both to keep allies sympathetic, and to keep Israelis scared and compliant.) But if someone isn't already familiar with that, then this comes across as a weird antisemitic non-sequitur.
I'm not looking for a personal apology, it's just a suggestion.
But yes my point is the one that what's obvious depends on worldview and bubbles. The West is unfortunately already neck deep in this propaganda and has been since at least the 70s (when some of the popular propaganda slogans came out, at the time to justify trying to permanently steal Egypt's Sinai and Syria's Golan Heights, like Golda Meir's sadistic "peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us")
I can be quite sarcastic myself (as can critical scholars like Norman Finkelstein) but it's best when the information is already at the point where the reader can't in good faith deny it's obvious. + I do bet the balance of pros and cons is shifted where there is real pain like the Holocaust, and real fear like antisemitism (which both really exists, and is exploited to terrify those who were propagandized into genuinely believing the propaganda)
Weird that so many separate individuals here write on the exact same topic and with the exact same style as that perma-banned user LearnsHebrewHatesIsrael.
It's also possible that there's something about the anti-Israel media these people consume that causes them all to write in the EXACT SAME WAY*, but yeah sockpuppets is a more parsimonious explanation.
Hmm, I had a number of comment exchanges with LearnsHebrewHatesIsrael ( later LearnsHebrewHatesIP ), some heated, some not, and this commenter seems different to me.
I've made my argument in the thread for why the original post and in particular my exchange here feels strikingly similar to exchanges I had with both LHHI and suspected sock accounts, but I will also acknowledge it's ultimately subjective, and whether or not these feel like sock accounts might be based on the kinds of exchanges one had with LHHI.
I disagree, obviously, and apparently so do a few others. I think this sounds exactly like LHHI experimenting with being unrestrained.
And that's not impossible, of course! I personally avoid writing with frothing hyperbolic aggression, but that's a choice. I'm fully capable of writing at a far lower level, as are you and most of the other people here.
But last...where's this user's blog? If one clicks through his username on a mobile browser here on Substack, his profile page says he hasn't published any posts yet, and he has no subscribers? Again, the mobile browser version of Substack is crap, so it's totally possible I'm missing something there.
Yeah, is someone compiling a list? I think I recognize maybe two sock puppets currently at work, but I haven't been paying enough attention to be sure.
Or perhaps I've been paying too much attention, but that's what the list is for.
I blocked Hindi's Ghost, as I was fairly certain it was a sock (in addition to being obnoxious).
Annoyingly, blocking apparently removes one's ability to see *any* content related to the blocked party - including one's conversations with third parties, like the exchange I'm having with you - so I'll wait until this thread naturally dies off to block.
Weird that so many separate individuals here have the exact same pattern of affecting confusion at accusations of sock puppetry and then concluding with deliberately insulting condescension!
Everyone seems.to be retconning It as about nukes, but it was largely about chemical.and Biological. weapons at the time. Iraq had and used such weapons at previous times , but the UN was successfully dismantling its programme at the time of the invasion.
By the time of the actual invasion, Bush had mostly given up on the nuclear weapons charge, but that was after various attempts (aluminum tubes supposedly used for centrifuges, forged documents showing that Iraq had made an unsuccessful attempt to purchase yellowcake) had been discredited. The key sentence from Bush’s announcement of hostilities: “The danger is clear: using chemical, biological or, one day, nuclear weapons, obtained with the help of Iraq, the terrorists could fulfill their stated ambitions and kill thousands or hundreds of thousands of innocent people in our country, or any other.”
It's also that the chemical weapons really are the odd man out from the ABC weapons. Occasionally used nasty warfighting tools with questionable tactical uses but without the vast apocalyptic implication of the others.
The WMD evidence against Iraq was clearly ginned up. Do you believe that Iran is not illegally enriching Uranium? There seems to be no dispute on that point.
Do you mean to say you believe that Iran *is* illegally enriching Uranium?
Because two days ago, the President of the United States and the Prime Minister of Israel assured us that Iran's nuclear facilities had been "totally destroyed". If they're still enriching Uranium, what was the point?
FWIW, I don't believe Iran is enriching uranium *today*, though I'm not hugely confident in that. Better to lay low for a few days or weeks and figure out how best to proceed. But I'm betting that Iran will be enriching an awful lot of uranium, 8-12 bombs' worth, later this year.
1. Bombing Saddam, who had no nuclear program of any kind in 2003, helped convince Iran it should have a latent capacity to change its mind later if needed to deter us. If we bomb Iran for knowing it might need to deter us later, then we're begging it to start deterring us now.
2. The US's motives have nothing to do with legality or self-defence, as proven in 2003 in Iraq (as well as by destroying Libya in 2011, to punish Gaddafi for cooperating and giving up his nukes program in 2003, etc).
3. Iran's enrichment is legal under NPT when used for nuclear energy. Though since Trump withdrew from the anti-nuclear Iran deal in 2018, it has stepped it up, and recently IAEA said it was in violation of something related to inspection / declaration, but that's not at all proof of actually building a bomb.
4. US spies and the IAEA agreed that there was no evidence of Iran actively building nuclear weapons.
5. The only country in the middle east that actually *has* nukes is Israel, and few think anyone should bomb Israel just to destroy its nukes (which tbf would also be suicidal). Israel also isn't a signatory of NPT and doesn't allow IAEA inspections (technically its nukes are an open secret, for tricky Israel-US reasons).
6. The US isn't actually scared of an Iranian first strike (which Iran knows would be suicidal). It's scared of not being able to totally dominate the Middle East anymore. Unfortunately that same will to dominate is why it keeps, over and over, giving them a reason to feel the need to get nukes.
1. Whatever Iran's motivations are, they indisputably want to become a nuclear power. I don't think you have to blame the US for that. Most countries would like to be a nuclear power. In any case the origin of their motivations is irrelevant. This is realpolitik not therapy.
2. So? Our motives are our own self-interest. That's sufficient. There are many good reasons to not want an unhinged Muslim theocracy to have a nuclear weapon.
3. Iran is enriching to 60% which is far beyond the 5% needed for energy. They've also denied inspections. "That's not at all proof of actually building a bomb" is suicidally naive in my view. What's proof, Tel Aviv disappears? Given the stakes, proof isn't necessary. Preponderance of the evidence suffices. This isn't mock trial, it's the real world with real consequences. Better to kill ~1000 Iranians on a reasonable hunch then risk the death of a million Israelis.
4. Again, willfully naive. They're doing enrichment which is the hard part.
5. Israel is a stable ally. It's in our interests for them to have nukes and they've demonstrated that they can be responsible. Also they already have them so there's nothing to be done. This illustrates why we have to be proactive in preventing Iran from obtaining them. Once they do our options narrow.
6. Yes, we're pursuing our own rational self-interest. I don't know why you find that objectionable. Existential fear isn't a prerequisite for military action. We're the global hegemon. We decide what's appropriate.
>"is suicidally naive in my view. What's proof, Tel Aviv disappears?"
You'll recall Bush's focus-grouped slogan in 2003, to stop anyone questioning his lies to justify his criminal aggression: "We cannot wait for the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud."
You'll also recall that Iran isn't a suicidal death cult, or a country of idiots who don't know about Israel's nukes. Obviously Iran isn't going to destroy itself by nuclear first-striking Israel.
That's Bayesian evidence that Iran is working towards nuclear weapons; we would certainly be more likely to find large stockpiles of highly enriched uranium if Iran was aiming for nukes than if it wasn't. (And Iran's accusation of the IAEA looking at forged Zionist documents isn't credible to me; Iran has approximately zero credibility here. Nations intent on proliferation always deny it, and Iran specifically shamelessly lies to the media all the time.)
In 1981 Saddam had bought a French-made nuclear research reactor, and France-supplied highly enriched uranium (the standard fuel at the time). It was above board, legal, under IAEA supervision and everything.
So Israel bombed it, trying to stay the only nuclear power in the region.
But the predictable and actual effect was that it *convinced* Saddam he *did* need a nuclear weapons program after all, and that it should be secret. The Iraqi secret nukes program, created as the consequence of Israel's counter-productive attack, was only ended after 1991 by the UN.
Not sure what is your point here. Obviously, Iran is not the good guy here, but the fact that Israel is somewhat better than Iran does not make it the good guy either.
Also, it is a bit funny to portray Israel as one avoiding civilian casualties as much as possible (this is understandable, though -- as long as they can get away with everything by yelling "human shields", why take the risk?).
There is zero chance of Iran destroying itself by nuclear first-striking Israel, which Iran knows has nukes.
Again: Iran is a country with goals and strategies, not your cartoon propaganda’s suicide death cult.
(The chances of Netanyahu nuking Iran are also low, I hope. But a risk there for Israel would be if Netanyahu starts to fall for his own propaganda—that he starts to actually think Iran is a suicide death cult immune to deterrence logic—so he mistakes their deterrence for aggression, nukes them in the hopes that Pakistan’s deterrent umbrella is a bluff, and then it isn't a bluff.)
Israel has intercontinental ballistic missiles, though numbers and details are quite fuzzy. Israel also has submarines capable of launching nuclear cruise missiles, and while it would take them a few weeks to sneak across the Atlantic, they're reasonably quiet subs in a big noisy ocean.
I suspect it would, as the United States would likely retaliate in its behalf. Since Israel isn't actually a NATO member, the US is under no obligation to do so, but it seems very likely, since the US gave Israel nukes in the first place.
I assume it has submarines and second-strike capability. Ofc it's hard to know specifics given the ambiguity policy.
(The point is more illustrative, like "few here would think Iran has the right to try to attack to destroy Israel's nukes."
In real life, if it was the US who decided that, it wouldn't need to attack. It's Israel's biggest enabler, so all it would have to do is say "no more settlements, no more military aid, no more occupation, time to withdraw to the green line and make peace with your neighbours and sign NPT. The PLO and Arab League are already down, and if we release Marwan Barghouti he can convince the rest of the Palestinians.")
Yep. You can't just say "some guys claimed this about another country 20 years ago but were wrong, therefore these other guys are also wrong about this other country."
You can say "Given the known fact that Iran was not building nukes and about to nuke us; and the known fact that the same people are telling the same lies about it for the same reasons as they lied in 2003; it's probably deliberate, not by accident, and anyone who falls for it again is not misguided but a sadistic warmonger."
You could say it but it's obviously wrong. They are not the same "lies" by the same people or for the same reasons. Moreover, Iran clearly was "building nukes"- i.e. taking steps to make it possible to build nuclear weapons very quickly, that had no possible peaceful purpose.
Very much agreed, especially with that last part. Between Russia invading Ukraine and this action against Iran, if I were in the leadership of a non-nuclear country right now, I would be looking into every possible realistic avenue of getting nukes. It's sure looking like "might makes right" is the guiding principle for most of the world's leading powers today, and I wouldn't trust anything they said to the contrary.
Which is, ultimately, very sad. While still far from perfect, humanity seemed to have made pretty remarkable progress in the past few decades of leaving behind the violence of our past. Now we seem to be backsliding.
I do not really understand what you say. Principles are for intellectuals. The reality on the street is, people do not kill their neighbors inside countries, because there are courts enforcing laws. Now international relations are always anarchy, there is international law and the international criminal court, but crucially it can only be enforced by war. So internationally, courts cannot enforce law without a war first. Milosevic had to lose a war first, then when to the ICC to be charged by the violation of international law.
So no, might does not make, but enforce right. Iran violated international law, one of the most important ones (non-proliferation), and it can only be enforced this way.
" The reality on the street is, people do not kill their neighbors inside countries, because there are courts enforcing laws."
But that isn't the reality on the street. That has never, ever, in human history been the reality on the street. That "reality" is a story made up by cynics to justify their cynicism or by monsters to assure themselves that everybody else is secretly as broken inside as they are.
Here in actual reality, the vast, vast majority of people would not kill their neighbors even if they were absolutely sure they would never be caught or punished. There is a small minority that would, and a larger minority (but still very much a minority) that *might* if circumstances got out of hand. But it simply doesn't take very many willing murderers to ruin things for everyone else, so the world with laws and courts ends up much better than the world without.
Regardless, none of that is much relevant to international relations at all. Countries are not people. They do not have the same decision processes as people, the same constraints, vulnerabilities and limitations as people,. nor the same virtues and strengths as people. They are very different things, and the analogy to civic law breaks down very quickly.
Lots of international agreements work just fine without any sort of violent enforcement mechanism. They work because cooperating and playing nice often benefits all parties involved. Even when a country encounters a specific case where they would benefit by pushing the "defect" button, the short-term payoff is rarely worth the loss of future opportunities that accompanies that hit to your reputation. A lot of leaders and people in high government positions understand that very well.
Unfortunately there are several prominent leaders who do *not* seem to understand this, or who rationalize away that understanding whenever they see a defect button that they *really* want to push. In the longer term their countries will do worse and lose power and influence against the countries who consistently cooperate. (If human civilization overall survives and flourishes into the longer term.)
Now the Iranian regime is a pretty terrible government, and they themselves are not so great at avoiding the "defect" button. But in large part that's because the rest of the world--and the U.S. VERY much in particular--has shaped them that way. Consider that the current regime took power after Iranians had spent nearly two decades getting systematically fucked over by an autocratic puppet government supported by the U.S., all because Iranian oil was more important to Uncle Sam than Iranian lives or Iranian civil rights. Consider that the last time Iran made an agreement with the U.S. regarding its nuclear program--a mutually beneficial agreement--that agreement was torn up *by the U.S.* within a few years of its signing, for no good reason whatsoever, followed not too longer after by the U.S. assassinating one of their top generals on the flimsiest of justifications. From Iran's perspective "international law" no doubt looks like a joke of a concept: no protection against foreign abuses, but often cited to justify them. [1]
So yes, principles are for intellectuals. And intellectuals have spent the past few centuries taking over the world: very slowly at first, but much faster in recent decades. I'll admit that the anti-intellectuals have made a very, very impressive showing this year. A really awe-inspiring bid to drag us all back down into the, to stage a grand comeback tour for Pestilence and Famine and War[2], to really redecorate the place with that retro Dark Ages look. But they haven't succeeded yet. There are still lots of us out here who *do* have principles and are willing to stand up for them.
Relevant further reading if you made it through that wall o' text and can still manage more.
Regarding Cooperation in Modern International Relations Specifically:
[1] If one wants a better understanding of that part of the world, consider that for any reason an Iranian might feel anger at the international community and certain countries in particular, a Palestinian has two or three such reasons. As a people they've been on the receiving end of an absolutely staggering string of abuses and insults, going back more than a century. (And yes, obligatory disclaimer, they've been on the giving end of some as well.) And plenty of non-Palestinian Arabs *can see that* and don't necessarily have a lot of reason to expect that Britain or Israel or the U.S. would treat them any better if they were in a similar position.
[2] Death being a timeless classic that never goes out of style.
>Here in actual reality, the vast, vast majority of people would not kill their neighbors even if they were absolutely sure they would never be caught or punished.
Okay, I sort of over-exaggerated this. Let's say the vast majority would commit financial fraud or take bribes. Culture matters. As a textbook European I don't really get why Americans are so brimming with holiness... I think it might be a Calvinist thing, I think Catholic cultures more accept that everybody is a sinner and it is basically okay.
>Lots of international agreements work just fine without any sort of violent enforcement mechanism.They work because cooperating and playing nice often benefits all parties involved.
This is true for private individuals and corporations too, yet we need law enforcement. In fact because of the principal-agent problem, individuals and corporations ought to need less enforcement, as national leaders have way way bigger principal-agent problems. A marketplace is always better from a principal-agent viewpoint than an election. Like if term limits mean Trump cannot be re-elected, what exactly does he have to lose?
>Even when a country encounters a specific case where they would benefit by pushing the "defect" button, the short-term payoff is rarely worth the loss of future opportunities that accompanies that hit to your reputation.
See above. It is not a country, but the leader pushing the button. Hitler pushed the biggest "defect" button ever, yet a few years after the war, most everybody happily cooperated with democratic West Germany. Just 6 years later, the European Coal and Steel Community was signed - imagine France trusting Germany so much to pool their coal and steel i.e. military industry resources!
>because Iranian oil was more important to Uncle Sam
Actually it was British Petrol.
>And intellectuals have spent the past few centuries taking over the world: very slowly at first, but much faster in recent decades.
But Iran got bombed because they were trying to go nuclear. Shouldn't countries draw the exact opposite conclusion- that if they try to get nukes, they will be destroyed? Surely if Ukraine had tried to get nukes, Russia would have destroyed them at that time anyway, right? And probably if Russia invaded earlier, they would win easily.
Iran *got bombed* because it was suspected of trying to go nuclear. Iran was not *destroyed* over this. The Iranian regime was not destroyed over this. The Supreme Leader was not killed or imprisoned or even deposed over this.
See also North Korea. And Pakistan, which was pretty clearly in bed with Al Qaeda and Osama Bin Laden.
The Iraqi regime, which we were pretty certain didn't have nuclear weapons and wasn't going to be making nuclear weapons any time soon, that *was* destroyed, and Saddam Hussein was dragged out of his spider hole and hung by the neck until dead.
The Libyan regime, which we knew for a fact didn't have and wasn't going to be making nuclear weapons, which had done the "right thing" by thoroughly and verifiably dismantling its nuclear arms program, was destroyed, and Muammar Gaddafi was anally raped to death on Youtube. Libya has been a failed state ever since.
You really think the conclusion Evil Dictators(tm) are drawing is that they should *not* nuke up ASAP?
I suspect the only reason North Korea was allowed to get nukes without getting couped or having their nuclear program raided/bombed is because they have a lot of artillery aimed at Seoul.
The primary takeaway any Evil Dictator should have from the last 40 years is that power speaks, and the West is super consequentialist about things, so make your threats as credible and devastating as possible. Nuke up, artillery up, etc.
Some decisions are overdetermined. Multiple independently sufficient motives that all are based in actual facts don't undermine each other's legitimacy. Israel has many, many reasons for bombing Iran, most of which boil down to "they hate us and have been waging a (mostly, but not entirely proxy) war against us for decades."
> When the official explanation is changing so frequently, one cannot help but have the feeling that none of them is true.
Or because those things are related.
(You could make a similar argument about WW2: "First they said it was about Czechoslovakia, then they said it was about Poland, then they said it was about France, now we have this story about concentration camps... the constant change of the narrative makes me suspect that the so-called Nazis are just a boogeyman invented by American media.")
"But Iran got bombed because they were trying to go nuclear."
This has by no means been adequately demonstrated. They didn't dismantle their nuclear program entirely. And I'd say they were obviously interested in keeping the option of building up to weapons capability in a medium-short, rather than long time horizon open[1]. But the claim that they were actively trying to build a bomb at the time they were attacked is one that needs significant support that I haven't seen yet.
[1] Which to my understanding is a state that many non-nuclear developed countries are perpetually in, simply by virtue of having the right mix of industry and technology and scientists. It's actually a little bit scary how *simple* nuclear weapons are when you get right down to it.
>But the claim that they were actively trying to build a bomb at the time they were attacked is one that needs significant support that I haven't seen yet.
The IAEA looks convinced that Iran prevented the IAEA from ensuring that Iran was not building a bomb.
And they enriched uranium to 60% U-235, while power reactors only need 5%. The _point_ of making such highly enriched uranium is a nuclear _weapons_ program.
I sent a thank you note to Trump after he authorized the bombing of the Fordow uranium enrichment site. I consider bombing it to be the right choice.
That's the largest stockpile of >nuclear power grade uranium in the world, aside from nations that already have nuclear weapons. And according to the IAEA, it's increased by 50% in the last few months.
I can't see an explanation for this that isn't attempting to either A) get nuclear weapons or B) make getting a nuclear weapon something they can achieve in the very short term.
Re: footnote one, any country with a domestic nuclear power program (not just a reactor, but producing their own fuel) could stand up nuclear weapons within 2-3 years. The main players there (aside from the countries that already have nuclear weapons) are Germany, Japan, Canada, Sweden and South Korea.
Thermonuclear weapons (ie H-bombs) would take longer, but that's more because designing and building an H-bomb is notoriously difficult - an implosion-type A-bomb is a pretty straightforward engineering problem once you have the enriched uranium and you know how to machine it (both of which you have as a result of the domestic power program).
There's something involving "lensing" in making an H-bomb which I have deliberately avoided finding out about because I would like to be able to travel the world without constraint, but it's famously a hard problem.
Saddam completely gave up his nuclear program after 1991, and they punished him for it in 2003.
Gaddafi gave up his nuclear program in 2003, and they punished him for it in 2011.
(Plus all the other coups and massacres and wars of criminal aggression that had nothing to do with nukes. E.g. overthrowing Iran's secular democratically-elected PM to install a dictator to protect oil profits in 1953; btw that, plus his overthrow in 1979, is why Iran is a theocracy now.)
North Korea has nukes, so the US only sanctions it instead of invading or bombing.
The US has, through its actions, tried hard to prove that no one is safe from US aggression without a nuclear deterrent. This is very foolish.
On the other hand, it is also obvious that the US made sure to have the overseas empire of the UK collapsed. (It was happy to see the collapse of the French one as well, but actively contributed to the former.)
Uh...really? "The US preferred hegemony to survival"? I mean, it's not like there were any *other* countries that were pursuing hegemony after WWII...
I honestly wonder if you realise that you have, with a comment like this, absolutely ensured that 90% of readers, many of which may have been highly open to your viewpoint, will now permanently disregard everything you say on the matter. More generally, I'm just amazed at how many people trying to advocate for a position have an unbelievable talent for appending a single sentence that compresses "I have a complete lack of perspective", "I have no awareness of the slightest factual nuance" and "I'm a fanatical ideologue" into that sentence.
Yes really. (You know about all the coups, all the overthrowing democracies to install dictators, all the terrorists and massacres, all the undermining of international law, right? In the nuclear age this isn't just wicked, it's an existential risk.)
>"It's not like there were any *other* countries"
Did I say there weren't? But if you're American, you should understand what's going on so you can be an effective citizen. (And it is the only superpower so it has an enormous impact.)
>"will now permanently disregard"
I hope they prefer survival, over encouraging nuclear proliferation so they can pwn david bahry in the comments section of astral codex ten dot com.
This is a bombing campaign, not a ground invasion. So what does that have to do with countries not having nukes and "being physically incapable of doing so"?
For all the talk about Iraq as an analogy here, pretty much everyone is missing the most important difference. It's unclear whether Iraq seriously wanted to acquire nuclear weapons, and they were certainly nowhere near any such goal, but Iraq was certainly rendered physically incapable of building nuclear weapons for many years.
Because there *was* a ground invasion. Iraq was bombed, invaded, conquered, forcibly regime-changed, and placed under military occupation for about a decade. *That*, is something that can take a nation off the list of potential nuclear powers.
Just the bombing, is mostly just for Feeling Good, like you're a Big He-Man.
The left used to be associated with nuclear disarmament but now it seems to be: nukes in the hands of the US - bad; nukes in the hands of brown people - good!
There's a trope in armchair geopolitics that gives all agency to the West and none to anyone else. The West isn't forcing Iran to become nuclear-armed. They want to because they want the power, and the West is trying to stop them.
Yeah I get that they don't like Pax Americana, and theoretically more of those places having nukes would make us have to respect their autonomy more than we do. But not only is it dangerous to proliferate such weapons, it just turns those nations into little Americas in their own neighborhood, they were never gonna need to nuke their tiny rivals but they still become regional hegemons that get more of what they want on the big stage and can leverage that advantage to stay there. It's not any real kind of equity between peoples as they'd simplistically imagine it.
>"These countries will try to build nukes no matter what because of the leverage it would give them"
False. There was an anti-nuclear Iran deal, which Trump withdrew from because of his ego.
In fact, the US has consistently *punished* nuclear disarmament. Saddam had no nuclear program after 1991, so the US lied that he did and destroyed Iraq in 2003. Gaddafi gave up his nuclear program after 2003, so the US destroyed Libya in 2011.
The anti-nuclear Iran deal was to end by about now, only with Iran having a much better economy and be better able to produce nukes, possibly shortening their nuclear timeline while making their people better off.
Though I agree with Trump that the Iran nuclear deal was a bad deal, I disagree that he should have pulled us out of it. Because what one president does concerning another country ought not be unilaterally undone by another president, because it undermines the integrity of the United States.
It isn't just anti-nuclear though, the other threat is to the dollar's pre-eminence, Saddam rashly started dealing oil in Euros. Gadaffi had some idea of starting a bank of Africa, which would be independent of the dollar. Also, I think in the early 2000s Iran founded an oil "bourse" to sell oil in currencies other than the dollar, so they've been long overdue for a clobbering. No doubt an agreeable side effect for the US of the latter is to persuade Putin that Trump can take decisive action and isn't all mouth as Putin may have believed.
"Colossal Biosciences" is the company that pretends to de-extinct dire wolves and so on. It's really just living paleoart—fun, but not remotely what their hype claims. E.g. the "dire wolves" were really just grey wolves with a handful of genes edited to make them big and white etc.[1] For fur colour, they couldn't even use the actual dire-wolf gene, b̶e̶c̶a̶u̶s̶e̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶g̶r̶e̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶s̶o̶ ̶d̶i̶f̶f̶e̶r̶e̶n̶t̶ ̶f̶r̶o̶m̶ ̶d̶i̶r̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶d̶i̶r̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶f̶ ̶g̶e̶n̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶u̶l̶d̶ ̶h̶a̶v̶e̶ ̶m̶a̶d̶e̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶g̶r̶e̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶d̶e̶a̶f̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶b̶l̶i̶n̶d̶.*[2] The misrepresentation of what they're doing isn't just cringe—it's dangerous, given how Trump wants to use it as an excuse to try to remove protections from endangered species.[3]
My supervisor Dr. Vincent Lynch, apart from his research e.g. on cancer resistance in elephants [4] and other cool stuff, is a critic of Colossal's hype (while admiring some of the genuinely important biotech that Colossal is refining, which could be redirected to other genuinely useful purposes).[5]
The gossip part: it looks like Colossal's finally started using intimidation tactics. First, some bizarre hit piece articles appeared trying to discredit his critiques (but his critiques are standard—Colossal itself admits that calling gene-edited grey wolves "dire wolves" is just "colloquial"). Second: when he suggested that the articles are AI-generated and might be paid for by Colossal and its billionaire cofounder (obviously plausible given the incentives + clearly disclaimed as opinion i.e. protected speech + clearly related to public concern given Trump's intent to remove protections), Colossal had their lawyers send an intimidating "shut up about it" letter to his front door.
Ironically, Colossal's behaviour is more humiliating for them than scientists' critiques ever could be. The hype train was rolling and not going to stop; people want to believe that we have dire wolves and will have mammoths. But people don't like billionaire Elizabeth Holmes-ass behaviour to silence critics.
*Added: this part was probably my misinterpretation, inherited from some early reporting. More likely the issue was that these genes are risky to mess with in general (e.g. in the event of imperfect CRISPR edits?), rather than a specific incompatibility with the dire wolf version. Thanks to Catmint for pointing this out. https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-387/comment/129267704
> For fur colour, they couldn't even use the actual dire-wolf gene, because the grey wolves are so different from dire wolves that the dire wolf gene would have made the grey wolves deaf and blind.[2]
This is as far as I can tell a miscommunication between scientists and laymen. Actual quote is:
> The dire wolf genome has protein-coding substitutions in three essential pigmentation genes: OCA2, SLC45A2, and MITF, which directly impact the function and development of melanocytes. While these variants would have led to a light coat in dire wolves, variation in these genes in gray wolves can lead to deafness and blindness.
For context, many species have minor variants of these genes which affect coat color (usually lightening it). For example, a variant of OCA2 causes blue eyes in humans, while a variant of SLC45A2 is responsible for palomino horses. White spotting patterns in dogs are associated with MITF variants.
However, in mammals, maybe vertebrates or higher, major disruptions can cause negative side effects. For example, complete deletion of MITF is lethal, while major disruptions result in an all-white coat and often deafness. Certain mutations of it in mice are also capable of reducing eye size, which probably doesn't help with vision.
OCA2 and SLC45A2 are much less serious. An OCA2 variant is the most common cause of blue eyes in humans. Blue eyes are known to sometimes cause minor difficulties with vision especially involving bright lights, however the effects are small as you can find out by asking any blue-eyed human. The causal mechanism is differently reflected light by the iris, so this is not gene-specific. SLC45A2 and can also cause blue eyes. I do not know of any cases where full blindness was caused in any species by any mutation to either of these genes. MITF too can cause blue eyes, but this is not the concerning thing about it.
I do not know of any studies of OCA2 or SLC45A2 showing a causative link to blindness. Closest I found was "There was no statistically significant difference in vision between patients with OCA1 versus OCA2, or between patients with and without mutations. Patients with two mutations tended to have worse vision than those with one, but not statistically significantly." from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1091853116301823 (do not be mislead by the word "blindness" in the introduction - it may be referring to a different gene)
For more on MITF mutation viability in canines:
> In humans, deleterious MITF mutations cause disorders of vision and hearing, including the Waardenburg and Tietz syndromes [9], [12], [13]. Deafness has also been recorded in white dogs, where approximately 2% of white dogs (sw/sw) present with bilateral deafness and 18% are unilaterally deaf [14]. The majority of mutations reported in mice and humans that cause severe pleiotropic effects are generally loss-of-function mutations affecting the coding regions [15]. This is not the case with dog MITF alleles. A comparison of S and sw haplotypes, using BACs from an S/sw heterozygote, across the 100 kb canine white spotting candidate region revealed 124 sequence polymorphisms, all of which were located in non-coding regions [6]. This demonstrated that the extreme white coat colour phenotype is controlled by one or several regulatory mutations. This hypothesis is strongly supported by the fact that coloured patches on white spotted dogs display normal pigmentation. Thus, this suggests that the canine MITF variants primarily affects migration and survival of melanocytes during development, but have no or only minor effects in mature melanocytes in the hair follicle; pigmentation of the hair requires MITF protein expression [16].
That paper also has a table of MITF variants found in wolves. So, this isn't a deal where gray wolves have something special going on that makes MITF variants uniquely harmful, but rather that major disruptions to the gene _can_ in some species have harmful effects, and (here I enter the realm of speculation, as I know the theory but not the practice) perhaps they were concerned that CRISPR would not modify the gene accurately enough to include just the desired substitution without damaging the rest.
I think you're right. Although e.g. Zimmer's NYT article said "they did not introduce the remaining five [mutations], because previous studies had shown that those five mutations cause deafness and blindness in gray wolves"[1]—which is might be where I got that interpretation from—the press release itself only said "variation in these genes in gray wolves can lead to deafness and blindness."[2] So yes, I now agree it's probably more that they considered these genes risky to mess around with in general, rather than a specific incompatibility with the dire wolf version.
I'm sorry you were triggered by hearing relevant info about what the administration is, in fact, trying to do and for which the administration is, in fact, citing Colossal's claims as justification.
If you think it would be "horse manure" for the Trump administration to want to remove protections for endangered species, and to cite fake de-extinction as a justification—
Their writeup [2] describes solving a challenging and multifaceted problem, for which a reasonable definition of success is unclear. Obviously it's self serving, but it is a startup that needs to pull some funding by embellishing their project, and the claims seem reasonable and honest. So far so good.
So from [5] I was expecting a 10,000 words technical rebuttal, instead I got Trump Derangement Syndrome and evil mustache twirling capitalists. Is this guy really a biologist? I see nothing of substance that actually engages with Collosal's claims.
What a strange comment. He mentions Trump *once*—"The Trump administration has announced it will remove protections from many endangered species, citing Colossal's de-extinction of the dire wolf." I'm sorry you consider it a derangement syndrome to inform you of relevant facts.
(Also, as I already explained: they slightly edited a tiny handful of genes in a grey wolf, and pretended it was a dire wolf. That's what happened. I'm not sure what additional 10,000 words you're looking for to re-explain it.)
I don't care who cites their work, I care about the merit of their work.
The link in [2] explains the tradeoffs they had to navigate and their reasoning. The link in [5] does not engage with that at all and instead only implies ulterior motives, which is low key confirmation that their decisions were correct as even an expert critic cannot engage on merits.
The merits of their work are poor. Dire wolves are an entirely separate genus, not species but genus, from gray wolves. They edited 14 genes towards the dire wolf sequence. This is not the amount of change you do to get to a different species, let alone genus. Even domestic dogs are all considered one subspecies, and they've got way more genetic variety than that! Plus if you read between the lines, and look closely at the choice of genes and the fact that GRR Martin is their board's cultural advisor, it becomes pretty clear that the goal was to make the wolves look as much like the game of thrones wolves as possible. Like, why did they specifically add non-dire-wolf genes known to cause white coat color? Not because dire wolves were thought to be white, previous research suggested they may have been kind of reddish, but because the Game of Thrones wolves were white.
Yeah, it's a hard problem, and yeah, the level of success they got is actually technologically impressive. But the level of hype and marketing BS around it is unacceptable and would not be tolerated in any company making products for consumers. This is like 'Our new phone will impress 500x more girls when they see you using it' levels of accuracy.
And when I first looked into this, I thought "Ok, the dire wolf stuff is poppycock, but at least they're still doing good work cloning endangered red wolves." Nope. The wolves they cloned weren't even endangered, they were red wolf-coyote hybrids that are doing fine. You could argue that conservationists should be more accepting of hybrids as worthy of conservation, but you have to actually make that argument, not just claim that the animals _are_ red wolves.
"Secretary of Interior Doug Burgum claimed on X that the "revival of the Dire Wolf" signaled "the advent of a thrilling new era of scientific wonder, showcasing how the concept of 'de-extinction' can serve as a bedrock for modern species conservation."
Burgum doubled down during a live-streamed town hall on April 9, 2025 saying: "If we're going to be in anguish about losing a species, now we have an opportunity to bring them back".
"Pick your favorite species and call up Colossal," he claimed, as the current federal government continues to target protections of various endangered species, often tied to misleading narratives."
So not an official government pronouncement, just social media hoo-hah. Unless you can point me to official government department website saying they are officially scrapping the endangered species list?
You know, I can't help feeling that if we had President Kamala and one of her cabinet officials making a Brat Summer announcement of "extinction can be reversed!", the same guys tut-tutting about this would be all "yay science!" even though it would be the same company and the same con artists making claims.
Re: your second speculation, our objections to Colossal's dishonesty are older than the Trump administration plan. Burgum’s recent statement, only two months ago, is the first time any of this has actually had any connection to Trump at all.
(And obviously it wouldn't be acceptable for Kamala to do this either. It's weird how quick people are to assume common sense must be partisan political signaling.)
re: "challenging and multifaceted problem, for which a reasonable definition of success is unclear"
If it might be possible to someday successfully clone a real dire wolf with an actual dire wolf genome—instead of slightly editing a grey wolf genome—cool. But that's not what they did and not what they tried to do.
Although there might be an area where the line of success is fuzzy (starting with a dire wolf genome and filling in a few small gaps with grey wolf DNA?), what they did here doesn't remotely approach anything like that.
And, of course, it might be that it's still too hard (e.g. having to edit way more genes, to get to >90% dire wolf genome if that's our criterion). If it's too hard then it's too hard; that wouldn't be anyone's fault, but people should be honest about it.
I agree their "dire wolves" look like regular Arctic wolves, but from their woolly mice, it seems pretty clear they're developing the tech you'd need to turn elephants into mammoths. (I consider whether "taxonomy experts" would deem that TRUE de-extinction entirely unimportant.)
I do think Colossal is going to be the Theranos of this field. I don't think we're going to get mammoths out of whatever process they're using, but the woolly mice are undeniably cute (and I'm very resistant to cute animals), so if they pivoted to "exotic pet creation" they'd do everyone a favour by stopping pretending they're going to save endangered and extinct species.
I also think they just jumped right on dire wolves because of Game of Thrones, not because of the real extinct animal. The ordinary person who ever heard of dire wolves probably has an image of the GoT beastie in mind, so "actual wolves just bigger and whiter" is sold successfully as 'this is a dire wolf'.
Yes, they’re kind of misrepresenting what they’re doing,
One possible use for that technology is filling the gap in an ecosystem left by a species going extinct; not bringing it back, but putting in a functional replacement. But that would likely raise the issue of the animal went extinct in the first place because other parts of the ecosystem it depended on are gone, too.
The tech is useful, I agree, including probably for fertility and genetic medicine.
I'll leave aside whether, hypothetically, the tech could ever be used to actually make a real mammoth with a real mammoth genome (instead of a slightly-edited hairy elephant). The point is that the "dire wolves" are not remotely dire wolves; and their current plan for a "mammoth" is exactly the same kind of not-remotely-a-mammoth.
If it was just their private fantasy, it would be unimportant. Or even for entertainment (I don't mind if Peter Jackson hires a hairy elephant to play a mammoth in a movie). But remember that Colossal and the Trump administration are both pretending this is *literal* de-extinction, and the Trump administration is already trying to use this as an excuse to remove protections from endangered species.
No, if they, or anyone else, have any specific criticism – like, head too small, tusks too straight, ears the wrong shape, or anything else – I'd be perfectly happy to concede that as a shortcoming, and then it's a matter of taste whether you think it a significant enough failing that it no longer counts as a mammoth. But the current level of criticism I've seen is on the level of "it wouldn't have the SOUL of a mammoth," and THAT is what I have contempt for.
I agree there'd still be a long way to go to sauropods, pterodactyls, etc. that don't have any living species close enough to hack together a facsimile from, but think it DOES get us closer.
I think it's less about having the "soul" of the extinct creature and more that these creatures likely differed from their non-extinct counterparts in ways that aren't externally visible or detectable from fossil evidence, such as social behavior, diet composition, effects on the ecosystem, vocalizations, brain and organ structure, etc.
And in that case labeling a modern animal genetically modified to look like an extinct animal as the extinct animal is misleading. You can't learn about actual dire wolf behavior from studying genetically modified grey wolves, and (since some people want to clone mammoths to rewild them in Siberia) you can't precisely replicate the effects on the ecosystem of a herd of woolly mammoths with a herd of genetically modified elephants, which might eat a rather different balance of vegetation and have a significantly different effect on the landscape. And people react strongly to this kind of 'deextinction' because there are suggestions we don't need to work that hard to conserve species that are currently alive, as long as we have the future option of making something that superficially looks like them.
This isn't "it doesn't have the soul of a mammoth."
This is "it doesn't have the anything-at-all of a woolly mammoth, even remotely, except for a tiny handful of gene edits, compared to the much vaster number of genetic differences between an actual woolly mammoth and an Asian elephant."
Are there any new/prospective parents who have experience with Alpha School a/b tested with home schooling? Reading the review, it really seems fantastic to a degree I didn't realize existed with off-the-shelf schooling options.
The current essay contest experience could be improved to a significant degree:
1. Everything being dumped into massive google drive documents kind of sucks; headings get weird, the pages are laggy, things have to be sorted, etc, and I'm sure it's a big pain in the butt for Scott and his assistants to copy and paste everything into the documents, especially as the number of entrants rises.
2. People submit essays for many reasons, but a major one is wanting attention/feedback/comments from a large, engaged reading population. The current rating system gives you no way to write comments for the reviews you rate, because it would be a massive headache to sort and collate comments. I had things I wrote down about each essay I rated, but didn't have anywhere to actually put them other than a separate ACX comment.
It seems like the solution is adapting an existing blogging platform or making a bespoke website for this purpose. I'm picturing a website where each essay is uploaded as a post by its writer, where anonymous comments can be left below each post, and where there's an integrated rating system on each post.
I know that someone had proposed an ELO system in a previous open thread, where instead of rating each post, you read two essays and say which one you liked better, and that over time results in an ELO score for each essay. It'd be great if that could also potentially be part of this, because right now, rating is tricky; I wasn't sure how to rate the first few essays I read, because I didn't know how they stacked up.
I'd be interested in working on this project, but have minimal web dev experience. I'm quite good at AI wrangling, but would love to see if there's anyone else who wants to work with me on making the essay contest experience better, who ideally is more experienced in website development.
That is a great idea--people who worked hard to write something basically always want feedback, and I would definitely often post feedback if there was a way for it to be attached to the specific review.
Wanted to say I like your/that person's Elo* system and agree with your rationale.
My main concern is potential abuse by raters who don't necessarily read every essay but might rate every other essay as worse than the one they liked (out of a couple they actually read, say), or as better if they happen to really dislike one, etc.
*not ELO, it's Arpad Elo's last name not an acronym, sorry to nitpick
I'm not sure if it has the functionality we need; a volunteer could certainly upload each essay as a post onto a new sub stack, but I think comments that only show up after the voting is done would be nice, and I think rating should be integrated into each post, which seems tricky to do through substack. If there's a way to accomplish those goals, though, then yeah, substack would work well.
Parts of this seem like they would be relatively easy to do by a volunteer. For example, taking a huge google drive document, and splitting it into many small ones.
For commenting the submissions, a possible solution is a new thread on ACX where someone makes a top-level comment containing the name of each entry and a link to its document, and everyone else will reply to these comments. (Scott would create the thread but keep it "only available to those who know the secret URL", send the URL to the volunteer who would create the top-level comments, and then Scott would switch the thread to "public".)
So I guess what needs to be done is for someone to volunteer (it could even be me) and propose the specific kind of help to Scott, maybe publicly in a related thread, so that other people know what is going on. Well, the next time we do reviews.
I agree that the formatting on the entries could have been better, perhaps with each entry linking to its own post, with comments disabled/hidden until after the rating period ends. I too wanted to leave comments on some of the essays I read, though they would have been of more interest to the author than to Scott.
The question of rankings is interesting - ELO doesn't seem like the right tool for this unless you assign pairs of essays randomly to readers. (You don't run a chess tournament by allowing the audience to choose who plays who.) Conventional voting theories don't work because there are too many candidates for voters to be acquainted with (so ranked choice won't work) and you allow voters to participate as often as they like. It's an interesting maths problem actually, though someone who knows this stuff better than me might come along and say this sort of problem is solved already.
I think the Elo idea is assuming that you'd indeed present people with two random reviews. It's already the case that choosing reviews randomly is encouraged, but I imagine that it'd be desirable to have some kind of option for letting people rate a review of their choosing, and I don't know how that'd work.
I'd also be tempted to try to use something like the Smith set rather than Elo, but I don't know whether sample sizes would be big enough for that to be viable. It would at least solve the problem of how to make ranked-choice voting work when most voters don't know most candidates.
It's not clear to me that the best selection of finalists consists of the most popular reviews. You risk lacking variety. (I also don't know how you would find a Smith set, or how that would help here.)
An alternative approach would be to attempt to find the 'most X' reviews for various choices of X: surprising, well written, profound, thought provoking, etc.
That seems like it flattens reviews too much to even be useful. Was the mid review mid because it's too controversial/not controversial enough, poorly structured, scope too broad/narrow etc. For book reviews the parameters are narrower so *maybe* it makes sense, but even then it's questionable imo. For open ended "review anything", the median means very little.
Substack offers very little customization, so while it would be possible to make a page for each submitted review, I'm not sure how it would help with any of the other features of the proposal. Also the process of creating the pages would still be fully manual.
First off, thanks for the work you've already done; I used pretty much exclusively the random review script to read reviews. It is up to Scott, of course, but it does seem like the current system involves a fair amount of work for him, with all the copy and pasting and compiling scoring information; I'd be happy to email him, asking if this project would have his blessing.
And if it does get his blessing, I'd be happy to help in any way that I can, though I'm unsure how much help I'll actually be.
I'll post my favorites here, to show my appreciation to the authors:
11 Poetic Forms: I'll remember what a Sestina is for the rest of my life.
Airships: Cool and steampunk. Would like to understand the technology better.
Arbitraging Several Dozen Online Casinos: in terms of potentially relevant new skills learned, this was #1. It's not really about "arbitrage" though, or am I misunderstanding that word?
Two Years Of Parenthood: Heartwarming!
Getting Over It With Bennett Foddy: Wouldn't have read it if it weren't for the random review script. I liked the connection to the author's experience as a writer.
I gave that review a poor rating because I consider it epistemically irresponsible to make such strong/spicy claims about matters of historical fact without providing more evidence than the review did. In particular, I would have liked to see some links to academic biblical scholars (not just theologians) who prefer the essay's interpretation, so that I could get a sense of how mainstream or fringe it is in the field.
I see what you mean. The historical context presented in the review seems plausible to me; things like a left hand taboo and laws governing forced labor. That said, whether Jesus or Matthew really had these things in mind remains a matter of interpretation, and I guess no amount of biblical scholarship can provide a definitive answer to that.
It's an isolated reading. I've heard the transgressive reading of those three before, but there are four statements in that section, and the last one is "give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you." I haven't seen someone offer an anti-Rome version of that one.
Kind of like how people will put together a cause-and-effect explanation of the Ten Plagues of Egypt, but then don't bother explaining that time Moses and the Egyptian wizards turned their staves into snakes.
For folks living in NYC who are voting in the Dem primary for mayor, I wanted to a) remind you that the election is tomorrow, please go out and vote! and b) strongly encourage you to rank Mamdani over Cuomo.
I disagree with both of them on policy, but of the two it seems obvious to me that Mamdani is legitimately interested in making the city a better place, while Cuomo is corrupt, self-interested, and (following the Trumpian approach to politics) is an all-together indecent person.
The Democrats need fighters. But those fighters must be as virtuous and honorable as they are aggressive, people who are so clean that nothing sticks to them so they have full ability to go after everyone else, people whose very presence on the debate stage shines a light on the hypocrisy of those who would seek to use public office for anything other than the good of the country.
A point you could have made is that Mamdani, like Bill DeBlasio, might moderate significantly in office since there’s a limited appetite for hard left policy in the city (as opposed to primary voters).
Also, the Democratic establishment really needs to start backing better candidates than these uncharismatic insiders. Just look at how much money got poured into Cuomos’s lousy campaign!
I purposely wanted to avoid policy discussion, because it's not germane to the larger point. I'm rather disappointed how many people here seem to be willing to vote for someone who is obviously a bad person if it means small concessions on their policies of choice.
I have time until November to think up some falsifiable predictions about the next four years.
From what I understand, from all of Mamdanis promises, two that he can execute on without too much interference are a) expanding rent control and b) repurposing subway station into homeless help centers.
Both of these are tragically bad in my opinion. The latter seems easier to do, so my first prediction will be that the homeless situation in NYC will begin to resemble that or Seattle or SF (before the latest elections)
A competently corrupt politician is often preferable to an enthusiastically well-meaning but inept one. The corrupt politician has an interest in not befouling his own nest; the enthusiastic idiot often won't even notice he's doing that.
If you want reform, find reformers who understand how things actually work.
> I agree this is the steelman, but implicit in the steelman is the assumption that the earnest person is also dumb or blind (because they wouldn't realize or be willing to realize that their policies aren't working right). I think it's extremely rare that someone is dumb/blind, earnest, has ideas that are so bad corruption would be better but is effective enough to actually implement those policies over the objections of others, AND is able to mount a successful campaign. Bayesian prior of all of those together is extremely low. (Trump gets almost all of these except earnest)
I don't particularly want reform. I want politicians that are going to act like adults and try and solve problems. I disagree with your use of the word "often". I would say "very very rarely"
The idiot doesn't have to be *effective* to be a menace. If their dominion is facing real and serious problems, being ineffective and blocking more effective people from solving those problems, is sufficient.
Or is the contention that NYC doesn't face any really serious problems and doesn't need capable high-level governance?
Again, I understand in theory that all of this is true, but I think you have a steep hill to climb when you're openly admitting that the counterfactual is someone who is openly corrupt -- and presumably, also effective (at being corrupt). My prior is extremely high that decency will lead to better outcomes on average than corruption. And unless you think that being a decent person is somehow highly correlated with being extremely ineffective, your prior should also be equally high.
While I broadly agree about NY political corruption, you do realise you are inviting investigation into whether Mamdani has any skeletons in the closet? Cuomo and his scandals are already known, but is Mamdani as squeaky-clean as you make out?
I'm not particularly interested in this election but simply reading the news gives me, whether I want it or not, a lot of coverage. And honestly? all the hagiography around Mamdani makes me think that if elected, he'll be an AOC type: yeah, talk the talk, be very good at holding on to their seat, maybe try a few Big Things but get slapped down or have them watered down, and settle comfortably in to being a career politician.
I don't mind a bit of the ould socialism myself, but expecting (pace Jacobin) "a promise of a fundamentally different way of doing politics for the working-class majority of a city facing an out-of-control crisis in the cost of living" makes me smile. Every hog, dog and divil running for election promises that. Then they get into power, have a look at the tangle and mess facing them that has been left behind by all the previous administrations, court cases, regulations, etc., and realise that it's going to be business as usual for them.
Even Elon and the chain saw couldn't cut through it all! I don't think New York has much wiggle room for sweeping changes to how the money works in order to make the working-class very much better off.
Speaking of that Jacobin article, really, Mamdani? Really?
"Far from “show[ing] little concern” about crime, public safety has been a prominent part of his platform. Mamdani’s ambitious plan for a Department of Community Safety pledges to build out social services and mental health care to help humanely address the root causes of crime."
Now, when was the last time I heard about a Committee of Public Safety? 😁 He might want to rethink the name there. And yeah, I'm sure a corps of social workers is going to stop violent/crazy criminals in the streets.
I mean, he's running as a socialist and campaigns with the slogan "globalize the intifada." What kind of skeletons do you imagine that could be worse?
You could try to muster some rape accusations, but those won't stick. Maybe you could find (or "find") video of him singing along to rap in high school or something, but that's weak sauce.
He doesn't seem to have been in politics very long, so what did he do before?
There's already been a little kerfuffle over "intafada". He was a rapper as a young man? Then somebody must have sample lyrics of him rapping about bitches and hoes and drugs and guns (unless he was an exceedingly wholesome rapper) 😀
Swearing about your granny? Having your (actress playing your) granny swear? Oh, my!
"How do you get an octogenarian south Asian screen icon to swear in a rap video? According to hip-hop MC Zohran Mamdani, a little context can be helpful. When he came to prepare world-famous actor and TV cook Madhur Jaffrey for her role – lip-syncing along to the words of his expletive-laden tribute to his maternal grandma, Nani – he had a little explaining to do.
Mamdani, who performs under the name Mr Cardamom, can remember Jaffrey asking him: “In the lyrics, who is this ‘mother fucker’ for?” he says. “Fuck this person, fuck that person; now whose ‘fuck’ is this?”
The guy may indeed be squeaky-clean, but if someone wants to dig deep enough and far back enough, it may be possible to find something that could have a bad interpretation put on it.
> you do realise you are inviting investigation into whether Mamdani has any skeletons in the closet
good?
> he'll be an AOC type: yeah, talk the talk, be very good at holding on to their seat, maybe try a few Big Things but get slapped down or have them watered down, and settle comfortably in to being a career politician
I'm pretty neutral on AOC, but, like, is your take that AOC is very corrupt or something? "a career politician" did she do something bad? or are you just annoyed about the aesthetics?
Net net, I purposely did *not* focus on either Cuomo's or Mamdani's stated policy positions, because the point I want to make is that being a decent person is a necessary precondition to talking about policy at all. I still think that's true, digs about the French Revolution aside.
In a race between someone who is a corrupt petty sex abuser and someone with aesthetics you don't particularly like, I personally would go with the mid aesthetics
I would recommend asking the right questions. First of all in the original Marxian analysis, the problem is with the system itself, not capitalists as persons. Now, libertarian economists tend to see the market also something like a machine, except that they see it as a good one. So I guess both agree capitalists do not have much personal responsibility, the market is a machine, if there is money on the table, someone will take it.
OTOH socialists dictators DO have a lot of personal responsibility, because this was not a machine like that. Stalin could have easily decided to not create the GULAG.
I think that several people have this take, and it always seemed like handwavy vibes-based feelings grounded in GOP scaremongering more than anything based an actual political outcomes. If you have any actual examples of this (and I mean relevant examples, not, like, "This cambodian general called himself a socialist in Khmer Rouge") I'd be open to seeing it.
But, also, fine, rank any of the other candidates, just not Cuomo.
increasingly of the opinion that people don't actually know what policies mamdani ran on or have any idea who the major players are in the big cities in the US
What *about* San Fran? Are you saying Mamdani is like Lurie, a moderate? Or like Breed, an establishment Dem? What policies do you think are the same between these people? Have you lived or visited SF over the last 10 years? What is your understanding of the problems that SF faces?
I think Michelle Wu or Lisa Hidalgo are equally reasonable comps who have done extremely well, so its increasingly unclear that Johnson isn't just a fluke or a particularly bad candidate/mayor
I dunno enough about Chicago tbh. I've heard the comparison a few times and agree that it's possibly a good comparison. Do you know more / have an informed opinion? Is Johnson unpopular because of policies? Gaffes? Scandal?
what about him? Why do you think this is a reasonable comparison, beyond Chavez also calling himself a socialist? who are the corrupt capitalists you're comparing against in Venezuela that would have done better?
If you want to point to Venezuela without any further explanation, I think it's equally fair for a socialist to point to the nordics with equally little explanation.
Based on your comment history I dont believe your verdict is informed by his decency. You prefer the socialist to the moderate because hes the socialist (and being coy about policy disagreements) Whether you think thats fair or not, I think readers have high bs sensitivity to decency based arguments that are just laundering political preferences. See GOP preference for decency during clinton/bush era vs now.
a) claiming to have special insight into the motivations of a person you don't know beyond their stated motivations is...bold, to say the least. Very bayesian of you. (Claiming to have special insight into the motivations of "readers" -- also very bold)
b) my comment history is motivated by a disdain and disgust of the Trump administration and everything it stands for. That you think 'hatred of Trump == socialism' says more about you than it does me.
c) vote for literally anyone other than Cuomo, it doesn't have to be mamdani he's just the person who's second. If Lander or Adams were second, they would be better choices. Literally *anyone* would be a better choice than the multi-time sex pest with a penchant for corruption.
Why do you feel the need to defend the multi-time sex pest with a penchant for corruption? "Our policies at any cost" is fucking stupid, sorry. I care about voting for decent people, because at the end of the day my own policy preferences are likely to be misinformed, the policy positions of candidates on the campaign trail are *definitely* misinformed, and when push comes to shove I want my public leaders to put their constituents over themselves. Cuomo is so selfish he's willing to split the vote just to stay relevant in politics. It's disgusting, as is defending him because you're stuck in the cold war.
In case it matters, I'm pretty economically centrist. More taxes on large corporations and the wealthy. Universal health care. Way fewer regulations, especially on construction. No taxes for small businesses.
I think most of Mamdani's policy positions are mixed to bad. I don't like rent freezes or rent control, and I don't get the groceries thing. Cuomo's policies are shockingly similar, though no one ever really reports on this. Doesn't matter though -- the main point is that decency is a prerequisite to even being considered a candidate. Mamdani isn't going to be cowed or bribed by Trump because, and I can't stress this enough, *he's a decent human being*. If Cuomo thinks being pals with Trump will benefit him, he will turn immediately -- just like Adams did before him. No thanks. I want to actually like my leaders.
"I dont believe you" is something ppl are allowed to say and doesnt require them to believe they have special insights into your motivations. And if I dont believe you, others probably dont either, because im not so special.
I offer no defense of Cuomo, and the things you say about him are probably true. But sorry, I dont believe you, and also I think mamdani would be bad (see I can just say that outright)
I agree, and further suspect this stance that one's policy preferences shouldn't outweigh "decency" would be abandoned as soon as the differences become significant enough*, probably by arguing that anyone who held those positions ipso facto lacked decency, and so voting for the corrupt bully with your policies over his honest opponent becomes the better choice after all.
*The opposite position on ALL of gun rights, abortion, affirmative action, LGBTQ+, and immigration, say.
If the best argument you have to advance your point is that you literally are allowed to say it, you might as well just concede there's nothing here. If you want to make claims about my political positions as a means to disparage me, at least have the decency to back it up with evidence. You claim to have ample evidence with my post history after all. Or is "socialist" just a bad word you're using to tar by association?
Disclaimer: I am also a socialist, and a Boston-born Red Sox fan who has never enjoyed visiting New York.
That said, the "moderate" (I don't agree with that self-appellation; this faction is socially liberal but seems every bit as committed as the radical right to fucking over the less fortunate) preference for Cuomo speaks incredibly poorly of that faction in NYC. He's a former governor who resigned in disgrace and is best known for killing the elderly in nursing homes during the Covid pandemic... and changing laws to give unsafe nursing homes immunity from lawsuits. You can't even defend him on idpol grounds, given his history of sexual harassment and homophobia (vote for Cuomo, not the homo!) or party loyalty (he worked to hand the state senate to Republicans).
What's the case for him - he's rich and famous?
NYC has ranked choice voting and there are other non-socialists on the ballot.
The OP should probably have chosen a different moderate candidate to recommend placing above Cuomo in order to appeal to socialist skeptic voters with a sense of decency, as yes its ranked choice. Instead the OP makes the case for Mamdani, hence my skepticism.
It doesn’t matter who else you put above Cuomo - it will likely come down to Mamdani and Cuomo and anything else you do is likely primarily aesthetic and expressive.
We know from prior experience that Cuomo is evil and self interested, so nearly any breathing person is better, as we don't have proof that they would act in a way that as bad as possible for the city. Is that not obvious, or is proving those foolish leftists wrong more important than acting in self interest?
It is hard to take seriously anyone who uses terms like "evil" to describe someone.
> is proving those foolish leftists wrong more important than acting in self interest?
If I wanted to prove foolish leftists wrong, I would vote a foolish leftist into office and watch what happens. As for self interest, I own a home in NYC, so it is in my interest to vote for the guy whose policies are least likely to limit the rise in housing costs,which again would be a foolish leftist. But I want to do the opposite which means I might have to vote for Eric Adam's in the general election, regardless of who wins the Dem primary.
I'm not going to justify your low effort comment with a proper response but you sound like this;
Jews for Hitler is perfectly reasonable! Sure, he might be evil and self interested but so was Nero! He brought untold status to Rome by acting in an self interested manor, so therefore I'll look for that quality in all future candidates. This non-intuitive conclusion is extremely satisfying! I am very smart! I'm so smart that I value looking smart over anything else, including my own self interested. I prefer to look out for the interest of capital and billionaires to signal to other Very Smart people just how smart and clued in I am!
o undoubtedly. We don't know whether Mamdani will do a good job or not. But we know that Cuomo won't, so the choice seems obvious.
Also, I'd rather an inexperienced but decent human who can pretty easily learn on the job, than a corrupt 70 year old who is going to wield power for his own petty bullshit while lining his own pockets. Again, the choice seems obvious.
Not only don't we know that, your article made no such claim. Indeed, it ridiculed those who would make their choice based on which candidate would pursue better policies.
One of the many points of the article is that you cannot trust what Cuomo says or does, because even though he says he will pursue abc policy he's actually just going to do whatever is best for himself.
If you think Cuomo is going to do a good job, make the case. You seem to admit that he's a corrupt and indecent person, so I feel the bar for defending him should be pretty high.
> It ridiculed those who would make their choice based on which candidate would pursue better policies
Right now, I think your stated position of "I'm voting for the corrupt and altogether indecent guy because I want housing prices to go up" is a pretty horrible take. There's a suite of ethical reasons why its bad, but honestly I think its bad on your own stated merits -- your housing price isn't going to go up as fast if the mayor does a bad job, and Cuomo is going to do a bad job because he's corrupt and petty.
Or, put another way, "I think the guy who's going to siphon funds for pet projects and political retribution is going to make my community better" is a wild take.
The steelman of the case for Cuomo over Mamdani is that the corrupt 70 year old who wants petty bullshit while lining his pockets might still be preferable to someone who will earnestly attempt a lot of policies that will cause massive problems.
I don’t live in New York and thus haven’t thought hard about what the candidates are promising to attempt, so I don’t know how to evaluate whether Mamdani’s promises are that bad, or whether Cuomo also has some equally bad promises. But sometimes, the corrupt person is better than the true believer.
I agree this is the steelman, but implicit in the steelman is the assumption that the earnest person is also dumb or blind (because they wouldn't realize or be willing to realize that their policies aren't working right). I think it's extremely rare that someone is dumb/blind, earnest, has ideas that are so bad corruption would be better but is effective enough to actually implement those policies over the objections of others, AND is able to mount a successful campaign. Bayesian prior of all of those together is extremely low. (Trump gets almost all of these except earnest)
> so they have full ability to go after everyone else
See, THIS is actually a reasonable argument, that decency (or the appearance of decency, which is the same thing in this business) is a good weapon for attacking Trump/national Republicans with, and that translates to longer-term federal policy gains worth the shorter term local policy hits.
That is NOT the argument you make in the essay. There, you seem to espouse a doctrine divorced from reason, leaning fully into voting as a kind of religious ritual to affirm sacred values instead of a bloodless transaction granting power (and the concomitant opportunity for abuses thereof) to a candidate in exchange for him enacting your preferred policy.
Yes, but you leave out the absurd bits that are the main thrust of your essay (summarized well in the title, so kudos for that) in the parts you excerpted here, and which change the meaning entirely.
Well, it looks like it's too late to organize review reviews under one comment, so I'll just throw them up as a top comment. Although I didn't read many in the first place.
The Bo Burnham review had bad chronology problems. There were several points during the review that I thought we had finished with the main album and were jumping up to focus on a follow-up album, only to realize that the jump ahead had been an unmarked aside and that we were still only partway through the first album. If all those jump-aheads had been in parentheses (or not there at all) the review would have been stronger.
Phoenix Theatre had too much backstory at the beginning, and also monstrous paragraphs that are ugly to the eyes; the Word Count tells me paragraph 2 has nearly 400 words. I don't remember how far I got into it but I don't think I got to anything actually about Phoenix Theatre.
Skibidi Toilet seemed like a really solid review, but I was only a page in before I realized I hated the concept of the show and actively want to never think about it. It's like seeing a review on a painting of smeared shit. No amount of effort will make it pleasant.
Hi, I wrote the review of Effective altruism/rationalism, and really want to hear what people think of it. No reason is required to not be selected, I assume all finalists are great of course.
But I hoped it would start a real debate about how to institutionalise the movements in a less illiberal and elitist way. Instead, I haven't even seen it mentioned in a comment. I want to understand why:
1. It landed as obvious (we've noticed the skulls). In this case I want to hear whether everyone knows this is a big problem, eg sick of the discussion, or if the reason is that you think it is not actually a problem.
2. It landed as wrong/misguided. Please argue
3. It landed as rude/arrogant, poorly written or not the right kind of text. Feel free to give feedback
To me (obviously, that's why I wrote it) what I point to really is a problem on the ground, so I want to hear people's arguments
I also gave it a rather poor rating. I should first say that I have never really looked into the EA movement. Basically all I know about it is via Scott, so I may have wrong impressions.
But the impression is that the points you raised are not really new. Like, the tension between mainstream/free thinker. Or I would rather describe it as tension between the inside/outside perspective. How much should you trust your own reasoning versus the conclusion of other people, if those do not agree?
I think this is a problem that at least Scott is very aware about, and I have no indication that the EA movement is not aware of it either. The issue is that this is a really, really hard problem. I face it myself a lot of time when I read the news, and I don't have a good solution to it. You push for going more into mainstream/outside view. But I don't think that generically this is very helpful advice, because you are using your own inside perspective here (which is an outsider perspective for EA). You should first consider that your inside perspective may be wrong, and that the EA perspective is right, and I didn't have the feeling that you discussed a lot why you are so sure that you are right and they are wrong. In fact, I would assume that for some concrete issues you are right, for others the EA people are right, and that it is a really, really hard problem to tell which is which. Personally, I am totally not concerned about shrimps, but am I right about that? I don't know! And I totally agree that x-risk assessment is very speculative. I think the EA community is also painfully aware of that, this seems to be one the central issues they discuss endlessly. But is the right course of action then to dismiss x-risks because it is speculative? You seem to say yes, and I see the arguments for yes, but I also see good arguments for no, and overall I find it very unclear what we should do in such a case.
So, in summary my criticism would be the following. Mind that I only focus on the negative points here. Your review was not as bad as it may sound from just listing the criticism.
- I have the impression that the EA community is totally aware of the problem (balancing inside/outside view) you tell them about. But they understand better than you that it is a hard problem, and just pushing generally for "go more outside" isn't very helpful.
- You tell them to go further in direction A. From my perspective, this is just a single data point, your own opinion, and I didn't find that you acknowledge this limitation. Phrasing it nasty, your main argument for direction A was "I think it is so", and that is a weak argument to me.
- This also made the review a bit arrogant. I didn't mind this so much, but I could imagine that people with more skin in the game might.
Hi, I didn't find time to reply in June, but thank you for this.
Actually my point is not “outside view is good.” But I see how it can be interpreted that way, and this comment made me reflect more on what I’m (not) saying, so thanks! I agree that you as an individual face a difficult inside-outside choice, and I’m not trying to solve that problem. I am making a case for knowing (not arrogantly dismissing) the outside view, so that you can navigate the inside-outside tradeoff at all, but that is an aside.
My main point is that the EA and Rationalist movements are not the best *institutional* responses to these problems. The inside-outside-dilemma works differently on a group level, because some institutions are objectively better at error-correction (church v university), better at supporting democracy (corruption v transparent constructive advocacy), and better at helping their members achieve their stated preferences (Alcoholics Anonymous v drinking pressure). The piece argues that the movements now can give its followers wrong ideas and make them bad political actors, but that other institutions could mitigate this.
But I realise there is a lot of theory working in the background that I didn’t explain - what kind of institutions the movements have built and what kind of institutions I think it should have built.
Thanks for the clarification! I see that these points may be helpful, like suggestions for what type of structure or what type of institution may be useful. It didn't come across as the main point when I read the review, as far as I recall, but that might be because I am not familiar enough with the discussion. (And my memory of the review is rather hazy by now.)
That review annoyed me and I gave it a poor rating, which I felt a little bit bad about as I'm a card-carrying EA and so potentially biased. I think it's cool that you're interested in feedback though. (For what it's worth, most reviews didn't get any comments, since the thread wasn't really set up to facilitate that, so I wouldn't read much into it.)
I think my three most clearly articulable objections are (1) most of these criticisms could be leveled against any set of political/social opinions at all, making it unclear why EA is being singled out; (2) I can't figure out what the kind of movement you'd like would actually be in favor of (you seem to support some kind of "mainstream" synthesis that I don't think exists); and (3) it makes a whole lot of different critiques in a somewhat scattershot fashion that makes it hard to tell which ones constitute the true rejection. There are also some smaller things that I think the review gets wrong or incoherent, as well as a few "yes we've noticed the skulls" points (where the issue is the lack of a preferable alternative) and a few things that are just kind of grating in a way that marshals people's biases against being persuaded.
I started elaborating on these, but unfortunately I find longform writing kind of difficult, and wanted to get something posted rather than just procrastinate forever on this, so for now I'm just posting the short version. If you're interested in further elaboration I can try to do that, especially if you either ask specific questions or want to do it on Discord or something (because I write more fluently there).
Again, thanks for asking about this, I think it's a good thing to do and not common enough.
Thanks! See my other reply. (1) No, see piecemeal/Utopian, (2) I outlined changes at the end, (3) i'm not rejecting EA, I'm saying it should be implemented in a less illiberal and individualistic way if it wants to achieve its stated goals.
These points must have been poorly formulated for all of the commenters here to think I was doing some hit piece on EA with no alternative. I get some of it, but still not really. Send me as DM here if you want, happy to discuss further
> Where (other review) was too personal, this was too abstract. One of the charges laid against EA was: “If they have a job in a non-EA organisation, they care more about leveraging the job to further agreed-upon EA policy goals than to do the job itself well.” No examples were given.
> Then there was a bunch of stuff about how hard it is to have good epistemics. I agree that epistemics can be difficult, but I was looking for an argument that said “and here are some examples of EA people making these specific mistakes” and the only one I saw was Sam Bankman-Fried, and I’m not sure if I’d count him as EA.
Trying to give a more general comment, though it's been a few weeks:
It felt like this was an attempt at armchair-theorist reasoning from first principles about why the EA movement might have problems, but if we accept this reasoning as correct then we have a fully general argument for why nobody should ever try to make the world better in any way. I think that making the world better is important, and I think it would be very hard to move me from that position without lots of practical evidence.
If an argument wanted to convince me that EA was bad on net, I think the argument would have to start: "Here are the N largest and most important EA ventures, and here is evidence for why each of them caused more harm than good."
I agree it should have had more data/examples. This is partly lack of time, partly not wanting to call out smaller actors, and partly not obvious how to document it. I ended up relying on my personal experience, counting on people recognising behaviour they have also seen (see other comment in this thread).
As a journalist, when I meet EAs that know I share their background, they tend to assume I will strategically write whatever is good for EA's concrete policy goals, colluding with them rather than doing good journalism.
Reading these comments it also seems like I underexplained some points. I'm not making a generalised argument, and I'm not saying EA is a net bad (??). I'm arguing for Popper's piecemeal social engineering rather than Utopian social engineering.
EA is great for global health and other areas with tangible benefits. My criticism is specific to politics, illiberal attitudes and institutional design in the movement. When you cheat in politics, you legitimise cheating for your opponents and we get a race to totalitarianism. This can be institutionally addressed along the lines I described.
I understand the call for evidence, but how would the world look if I was right? I would say in that world the movement would remain a subculture, get a cultish shady reputation with bad media coverage and a scandal or three as it moved further into politics, rather than becoming more well-known and gradually accepted. These are data points, albeit post-fact.
Sorry this for rambling, didn't have time to write this properly. I agree that a full argument would dive more into the specific areas but this is what I had time for. Theory is also a thing
Did you think about the readership of the essay competition when you were writing? You're not going to win many 10/10's while dismantling a person's ideology for them.
I read and reviewed your essay. I think there's an element of (1) there, nothing you said struck me as especially insightful. I thought there was an irony in your main critique being that the EA movement mostly produces online critiques rather than engaging in the world to improve it. And you... produced an online critique?
That discussion is still all about how to further EA causes. "EAG exists to make the world a better place, rather than serve the EA community or make EAs happy" says the Utopian social engineer, breaking some eggs for the omelette.
I don't agree with the third point. You have to go inside to tell people to go outside.
Also I'm not saying EAs don't engage with the world to improve it, in a sense I say they overdo that part. I'm saying EA is too private in its epistemology, but too optimising in its practice. The combination is dangerous
Your surprise that your critique didn't land well comes across as a little bit naive. Have you tried giving someone negative feedback in the real world?
3 is definitely in play; there's a lot of flippant language, even as early as when you say wind turbines are allowed "to shoot up", as if they're just weeds sprouting out of the ground. Very much has the feel of someone wanting to tweak the nose of the movement. The new moniker, the absense of evidentiary hyperlinks in your list of observations despite them being prevalent before and after, it has the tone of a hit piece. I'm dropping off before page 3.
I didn't want to tweak any noses, but definitely felt (perhaps too strongly?) that it is important and people don't realise it while writing the review.
Interesting about the observations, they were not meant as proof. I don't think there's any data for this, but please tell me if there is (ACX survey?).
Maybe I should have made my thinking explicit: The reader, presumably familiar with the movement, can validate the observations for themselves. If they don't ring true, the situation is less bad. If they do ring true, this is a problem, and the review is trying to show why. Given my personal experience, I would expect the latter.
It rings as focused solely on news-worthy parts of the movement. If you found a soup kitchen, you get an article for that. If it runs for fives years and serves lots of people, maybe you get another article if nothing else interesting happens in town. If one of your workers bonks a homeless child on the noggin with the serving spoon and hurls insults at them, congrats, you've made every headline.
Anyway, the movement was heavily influenced by Yudkowski's writing, and Yudkowski's writing has a lot of cultishness attractors (see: entirety of MIRI), so it's not really a surprise that there's cultish subgroups doing stupid stuff. As long as GiveWell, 80,000 hours, and other impactful groups stay sane, we should be fine. But I don't know what you expect me to do about the fact that other people come up with insane policy proposals and call themselves EA.
As for not trusting the mainstream, I just posted a comment in this open thread discussing a fact that was incorrectly reported by pretty much every journalist that touched the subject, because one of them talked to a scientist who said something vague and it was misinterpreted. Lots of people here are probably experts on some niche topic and have had similar experiences. If we see journalists getting stuff wrong in areas we know a lot about, why should we trust them for the rest?
Hi, I didn't find time to reply in June, but thank you for this.
1) Well, the essay comes as a result of interactions with EA people and orgs and following the rationalist discourse, so the news-worthy claims confuses me a bit.
2) Actually the whole point is that it is not about whether your policy proposals are good, it is about how you go about implementing them. If you act illiberally, I think your impact on society can easily become net negative. The EA institutions don’t do enough to mitigate that. In the worst case, they encourage it. I think for example that 80k's AI x-the wrong move in this respect.
3) I think you have no place to stand and criticise the mainstream. You risk that sophistication bias and Atlantis style information asymmetries leaves you very, very wrong. That doesn't mean blind trust in the mainstream, it means being aware where the mainstream is so that you know where you take a risk by taking an inside view.
As someone who's only familiar with the movement through what Scott and the commentariat post here, my accepting the points requires my trusting the narrator. The hostility of the writing style requires much more upfront evidence than a more neutral wording could get away with, as I would trust a more neutral piece to bring up its supporting evidence further in.
Wondering if I should go ahead and publish my review (which didn't make it into Scott's post) and thank the people calling it out in these comments, or keep to anonymity on the off chance the review gets elevated into a last-minute honorable mention position, as it did previously.
Either way, I'm really pleased with the quality of the reviews as a whole, and that there are loads of people in these comments calling out reviews other than these 10+ finalists and honorable mentions as their favorites. Obviously I'm sad mine didn't make it, but to see even one person name it as their favorite still warms my heart. See you next year!
"Strikes against Russian industrial capacity continue. The Nevinnomyssky Azot fertilizer plant in Stavropol Krai, one of the top producers of ammonia and nitrogen fertilizers in the country, halted production after drone attacks. Another attack was charted in Orenberg, 1500km from Ukraine, and likely home to strategic missile base. In an effort to blunt the drone campaign, authorities cut mobile services to vast swathes of Russian territory. It ends up being a map of strategic priorities. Oops."
That's clever, but assuming that internet was shut down in whole regions, knowing that your target is in Sakha (area 3+ million square km) doesn't give you a lot of additional info.
My plan had been to review Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables by Dead Kennedys, but other projects took enough of my time that once I got to the writing stage I quickly deduced I wouldn't be able to finish by the deadline. Perhaps I will do something on a related subject for a later contest.
Is your interest in it musically or lyrically focused? I find the second record "Plastic Surgery Disasters" to be more interesting in lyrical content as it contains numerous examples of fringe theories and sentiments that underwent political realignment in the past 40 years, and I like some of the more complex compositions, but I certainly understand the more punk purist appeal of the debut record.
FFfRV is more meaningful to me, personally, and its balance of edgy/dark songs like I Kill Children with political ones like Holiday in Cambodia would have also been something to consider and contrast. Due to its general reification there's also more written material on how it came to be.
Would love to see Bukele promoted to finalist! Thought it was really interesting, with analysis by someone living in the country of interest and well written. Have discussed it with several people in real life since reading it. Definitely keen to read and discuss further.
The Musk Algorithm was also great distillation of real world experience.
I really enjoyed it, learned a lot, and have shared it with others. The Miracle of El Salvador is an example to the whole world of how fast change can happen, even if it's failed for decades
I did think, however, that it played up the Dictator angle in a hype-y way, possibly for drama and readability. At the end, it says clearly that the author intends to just "monitor the situation" and maybe there's no dictator worries here. But ALONG THE WAY, it uses literary devices to make things sound much more 1-sided.
For example, it uses a dramatic and sudden "end of paragraph/section" after saying something about how Bukele immediately had a political opponent tried for corruption. Only significantly later in the article does it then add, "Oh, yeah, the opponent was literally on camera doing crazy corruption, so this was the reasonable and obvious legal/justice thing for anyone to do."
It would have been less of an emotional roller coaster to say this right next to the "mic drop moment" about Bukele going after the opponent, but more honest.
I lived in El Salvador for 2 years as a Mormon missionary during the highest homicide rate years, and am meeting/talking with lots of Salvadoranean people (eg at Kimbara bar) in San Francisco. As we face AI risk and hopelessness, I hope the example of El Salvador's Miracle can give us hope that outlandish claims about rapid results can actually be real and viable.
(I don't claim to know how to discern if the "extremely tough on crime" approach is worth the immense improvement in safety (not in detail), but a 91% approval rating makes me think I should cede judgment to those who have lived there.)
I really blew it on the review. I didn't read the contest note clearly and started work on an actual book review. DQ! I'll finish it up when I have time and get it in early next year.
Tried to play catch up with a review of Milgram's obedience experiment, in the context of popular fictional character archetypes, but spring is not a good time for writing in my line of work (Apple Grower). I'll finish and post that sometime, but I was off to a good start.
Pre-contest note, in anticipation of what I thought would be a book-review contest, I began a review of Tristram Shandy. When I discovered was a non-book review contest I tried to adapt my review into an argument that Tristram Shandy isn’t really a book. But it was too complex and I gave up the attempt. This is my review of that attempt.
Milgram himself ran several replications of it, mostly because he had already built the lab. Some factors and results were stronger than others. For example, proximity of the authority figure was a big deal, people delivered fewer shocks when they were told to over a phone.
Punchline is this study started a wave of reform in Psych testing, with new ethics codes that protected subjects from the kind of stress and emotional harm that were evident in his work. So, replicated? can't say.
here's the link to his contemporaneous documentary film
Uhm, this is a pretty misleading excerpt. Why don't you also cite the paragraph directly below it?
"In a book review critical of Gina Perry's findings, Nestar Russell and John Picard take issue with Perry for not mentioning that "there have been well over a score, not just several, replications or slight variations on Milgram's basic experimental procedure, and these have been performed in many different countries, several different settings and using different types of victims. And most, although certainly not all of these experiments have tended to lend weight to Milgram's original findings"
Also, I think there are a lot of reports of participants of the original experiment which also confirm it beyond the pure publication. My understanding is that this is pretty well-established. Other than, say, the Stanford Prison experiment or the Robbers Cave experiment.
Good contest, there were some really thought-provoking entries in the ones I read - and I got to very few of the ones that ended up being finalists, so I still have plenty more to look forward to.
I wrote the Skibidi Toilet review. I had a ton of fun writing it, glad it got some positive reception and informed some people about one corner of the vast and weird landscape of modern storytelling. :) I'll post a polished-up version to my own blog soon. (Update: It is here https://eukaryotewritesblog.substack.com/p/skibidi-toilet-review )
To the commenters who vocalized a disdain for learning anything about the topic or even being vaguely compelled to think about it: Hey, your time is your own and you should spend it as you see fit. Maybe next year, you can write a review of rank cowardice so the rest of us can decide if it's right for us.
After reading some comments, I read your review, and it was good enough that I actually watched Skibidi Toilet from the playlist provided. The series is interesting, especially with the background provided by your review., though it's kind of hard to follow because it seems to follow its own physical laws, like getting your head cut off doesn't kill you, except when it does.
You did explain that the technology is never explained, and I found that a bit irritating, too. In the 4th episode, somehow the people in the restaurant get turned into toilet people by no visible means. In 41, the toilets are compelled to commit suicide, but this is apparently never again used against them.
I thought your review was excellent. I thought you had done the most out of anyone to present the worst possible topic in the best possible light, but Skibidi Toilet was always going to be a tough sell.
Eagerly awaiting the next time someone disparagingly mentions Skibidi Toilet in a discussion about The Youth of Today and I can "Well ackshually" them
Yours was the first review I read (bc scrolling and... "there's a review of TOILETS?!?!"). It was an interesting choice, and I thought your review gave a lot of context to an extremely weird meme.
> Maybe next year, you can write a review of rank cowardice so the rest of us can decide if it's right for us.
Iran has had their militarily capacity greatly degraded in recent weeks/months. Setting their nuclear program aside, we know that their air defense and missile launching capabilities have been largely curtailed. However, if somebody thinks this is a great time for regime change coming from within--which is the only place it should come from, self-determination being near sacrosanct to me--I have this thought. The security and police apparatus that is so effective at keeping the Iranian people from succeeding at their protests is roughly intact.
So, any notion that we are suddenly in good position for a popular counter-revolution in Iran had better buckle-up, because it will be a rough ride. Sure is fun and easy to bomb targets--and eventually that means people--but intervening to help a local/national uprising does not appear to be on anyone's menu. Presidents that say "go ahead, we have your back" have not been credible, and so should be taken with salt.
Inviting such an action through a preemptive leadership decapitation action would be a black swan sitting on a black box. no-one knows what will happen squared. Not a great comp, but no one seems very happy about Libya post-Ghaddaffi (mostly due to Wagner/Russian interference, IMO), but Iran is a much higher base-rate competence country that Libya was, so who knows.
Currently at 37% chance Khamenei isn't supreme leader by the end of the year, 18% chance that the Iranian regime falls by the end of the year. Since the former is implied by the latter, would it be reasonable to assume that there's a fairly high chance that if Khamenei is gone then the government will be overthrown? Or am I mixing up causality somehow?
I don't think this mathematically follows. There could be a world with a 19% chance that Khamenei is killed by an airstrike (or dies naturally), and conditionally on that, a 100% chance that the regime survives. Plus a chance of 81% that Khamenei survives the year, and conditionally on that a roughly 22% chance that the regime falls. All this is mathematically consistent with the numbers you gave, but then there is zero chance that the regime falls if Khamenei dies.
All this is purely mathematically, of course, and not a model of the real world. But we can say (taking the numbers at face value) that the probability of the regime falling if Khamenei dies is AT MOST ~50%. Because there is at least a 19% chance of "Khamenei dead, regime in place" and at most an 18% chance of "Khamenei dead, regime falls".
Clarification about the "self-determination" you consider sacrosanct: would you object to the US arming a few dissident groups inside Iran with vast amounts of guns, tanks, fighter jets, and missiles to do with as they please?
Sure, but I'm not suggesting this operation be covert or deniable in any way: this would simply be kickstarting a civil war, and using the rebels to fight a proxy war. What is the part you think isn't credible?
(Also, I'm not actually suggesting this pointless procedure of adding extra steps to the regime change operation; I don't give a shit about "self-determination" in the sense of preferring local tyrants over foreign ones.)
> However, if somebody thinks this is a great time for regime change coming from within--which is the only place it should come from, self-determination being near sacrosanct to me--
If it comes from without, how is that any less self-determination than what they have now? Iran isn't a real democracy. Anyone living their is having their life determined by someone else as it is.
Yeah, this is a good point. Reminds me of Iraq -- of all the negative thinks one might say about the invasion, "but imperialism" is the weakest one, since the result was an increase in self-determination (which is not the usual result of "imperialism")
Okay, let me address your 3 points in reverse order. 3: Well, all societies have either rules or anarchy, so yes, other people have a lot to say about how you live. Not much for me to disagree with there. 2: Iran not a democracy? Not generally thought of as one, and yet...they do have elections that have actual political consequence. Yes, the Mullah branch controls who is allowed to run, but within that scheme there are still extremists and moderates--the current PM being the most moderate candidate in the last election. They also have women with the right to vote since 1963! Not bad. On the whole, I rate them as slightly less democratic than Israel, which would have a considerably higher grade if so many of their residents weren't denied citizenship/suffrage. But I digress.
3: They got pretty pissed off in Tehran when a woman was murdered in police custody. They went to the streets and made a very big deal of it, and were beaten, jailed and even killed for their trouble. These people want something better, and I hope they can find their way to it, although right now might not be the ideal time. I will say that in the photos of Iran after the bombings, of the people I see only ~half the women have their hair covered, the rest don't like that.
I once heard on some news show a dissident in Syria--this was 10+ya--say that Assad would fall when Syrians made him fall, and any other interference was quite possibly disastrously unhelpful. His preference has aged well.
"that response isn't the defense you seem to think it is."
Not sure just what it is that you think I am defending. What do you think I am defending?
I'm not really coming at this from an ideological stance. If you think I am, run it by my and I can confirm or deny. If you want to know what I think--about Iran, American Power, the Iraq war, The Afghanistan war--you can ask; you will get a better answer than if you guess.
That's probably why Israel has been targeting low to mid level police and police leadership recently. I understand they have been intentionally assassinating the equivalent of the local police captains, though I haven't seen a lot of detail on it.
I thought this was an excellent take-down of Curtis Yarvin's recent allegation that the Allies starved hundreds of thousands of German prisoners of war to death in 1945:
Yarvin's original X thread was done in excellent Yarvin form, replete with rhetorical wink-winks and "if you read any real history, this wouldn't be a surprise" vibes. I admit to hoping it was complete BS, but trying to hold my judgement for a while, and I'm glad someone did what seems to be a thorough and even-handed job of refuting it.
This is bad. The author is bad. To be fair, I *think* Yarvin is trolling.
We know that former Nazis were treated incredibly poorly and anyone familiar with sources from the period would be aware of it. My personal familiarity of this comes from the diaries of John Rabe, the Nazi who is credited of with personally saving 250k Chinese during the Rape of Nanking. You can read his wiki here (1), watch a trailer for the movie about his life here with Steve Buscemi (2), and buy his diaries under the title "The Good Man of Nanking", which I would recommend.
We know he was basically starved to death. We know this from his diaries but we also know his situation was so dire that in 1948 the mayor of Nanjing traveled through Switzerland to Germany and the people of Nanjing sent him food until his death. Allow me to repeat, a ~64 year-old humanitarian was essentially starved so badly that the people of Nanjing China, during the Civil War and Maoist period, were sending him food. If that was happening to an old humanitarian Nazi bureaucrat...yeah, I can imagine some pretty bad stuff occurring to actual soldiers.
Yarvin is bad here because I *think* he's basically trolling and this is Trump's Hatian cats all over again, where there probably was not a million person execution of captured German soldiers but their living standards and treatment was probably pretty horrific and now we're all talking about this. Yarvin *probably* wants this because it serves his purposes for the Skeletor of the 20th century to be Communists, not Nazis.
This response is worse. It presents no actual evidence except official statistics provided by the very people accused of genocide/abuse, cribbed from a book written by some other guy. Give Yarvin this, I believe he's actually read and interacted with direct sources and now he's spinning/trolling to get clicks and influence. This bozo just cribbed a book someone else wrote about it with, I don't want to say no evidence, but certainly not persuasive evidence. You just...if someone accuses the Soviets or the Maoists or the Japanese of genocide, it is not persuasive to show official Soviet or Maoist or Japanese figures declaring that they totally didn't commit a genocide. The bar is low but you have to actually cross it.
Please don't share stuff like this in the future. It was dumb and it made me angry.
John Rabe was not in any of the prisoner camps. He was starving as a civilian, and as the author made very clear a *lot* of people were starving and going without food in Europe in 1948. John Rabe going hungry as a civilian in Berlin is not evidence that hundreds of thousands of Germans were starved to death in Allied prisoner camps.
The author makes a lot of good points. If this happened, why doesn't anybody claim that it happened until 1989? Why did the West German commission whose sole job was to track down every German that died during or after the war not find hundreds of thousands of starved prisoners? Where is the evidence that such a thing occured? Yarvin doesn't seem to present any.
Lots of details like this get classified and only become public decades later. Operation Keelhaul is another good example of this kind of thing, which seems like it only became known in the 1970s.
If an old bureaucrat and family were being starved, why wouldn't that count as evidence that former Nazi soldiers were starved? Like...the Americans aren't going to starve the former SS guys but they will starve some guy's daughter? From memory I think one of them was 10 and another was a teenager at the time but that's old memories from the diaries.
It's not uncommon for events like the Holodomor or Dresden bombings to remain controversial, unproven, and generally uninvestigated outside of extremely niche communities for decades.
Again, what probably happened is that a lot of former Nazis got treated extremely badly after the war. How bad? Who knows? Also, not to be too much of a jerk, who cares? It would have hardly been the worst crime of the period, it probably wouldn't have cracked the top 10 even if they had killed a million. Yarvin is *probably* overselling it for political ends and this guy is underselling it using some of the worst logic ever.
The old bureaucrat and his family wern't "being starved", they were just starving. Nobody was keeping them from getting food, there just wasn't enough food to go around and everyone who wasn't a German got priority on food aid. Which is the author acknowledges and nobody disputes it. This widespread hunger is not the same as the claim that hundreds of thousands of German prisoners starved to death and the Allies covered it up.
The Holodomor was controversial, but people were reporting on it as early as 1932. Similarly, the Associated Press was reporting on the destruction of Dresden within weeks of the actual bombing, and there was a lot of people call it a war crime at the time. Yet we have no contemporary claims of mass deaths by starvation in Allied prisoner camps, not for many decades.
I agree that what probably happened is a lot of former Nazis got treated extremely badly after the war. We know this because we have a ton of evidence to support that fact: personal testimonies, newspaper articles, written government policies, etc. We don't have any of that for Yarvin's claim.
I read it too, and there are reasons for concern with this author (like, defending residential camps, calling Tulsa a 'race riot?). But the most compelling stats he drew from came from the West German government of the 60's and 70's.
That's what it was called for about a century after the event. Which way do you prefer it be revised: up towards "genocide", or down towards "mostly-peaceful protest"?
Shankar and Melvin, you are reading me wrong, which is probably the result of my bad writing. An author above, during a lovely takedown of Curtis Yarvin, dropped a reference to an article 'debunking' the events that happened in Tulsa. To wit: he was changing the events from a massacre to a 'race riot,' in a decidedly both-sidesy sort of way. I didn't feel like giving it more of my time, attention, and I guess I already failed there, but I don't like people trying to airbrush a massacre away. Ditto with the Residential Schools. They happened and it was bad that they happened, and its okay to say that.
Yes, the West German government's retrospective in the 60's and 70's is more trustworthy than the American's. Still:
#1 Independent 3rd party accounts are better, and Yarvin provides those in his...sigh...Twitter thread here (1). An account the original author ignores and seems to get confused with a report from the Army Medical Department. (the Andersonville Prison reference)
#2 Postwar Germany was politically...not the most unbiased of locations. Holodomor denial from the Ukranian Soviet Socialist Republic is better than the USSR but...ya know, not exactly unbiased.
As an aside, I tried to see if he referenced the red cross thing anywhere, I don't think he does, but he does claim that Pope Benedict was in one of these camps and...no? Certainly not my area of expertise, correct me where I'm wrong, but Benedict's Wikipedia shows him in Neu-Ulm and Fliegerhorst Bad Aibling (2) but those are not in the list of 19 Rheinwiesenlager camps Yarvin is discussing (3).
To be clear, if I have not, I have not heard of this particular claim before. It seems similar to the bombing of Dresden or the Holodomor. Old events that are highly charged, highly ambiguous, and where it's likely something bad happened but how bad and how intentional it was is quite vague. Both events also that kinda lurked in academic corners until they became fuel for the culture war. I doubt Yarvin's specific claims but the abuse of Nazi and German people pops in up in every contemporary account I'm familiar with and also...just makes too much sense. That's just what victorious armies do. What I do resent and get angy about is just bad argumentation.
Shankar and Melvin, you are reading me wrong, which is probably the result of my bad writing. An author above, during a lovely takedown of Curtis Yarvin, dropped a reference to an article 'debunking' the events that happened in Tulsa. To wit: he was changing the events from a massacre to a 'race riot,' in a decidedly both-sidesy sort of way. I didn't feel like giving it more of my time, attention, and I guess I already failed there, but I don't like people trying to airbrush a massacre away. Ditto with the Residential Schools. They happened and it was bad that they happened, and its okay to say that.
Sounds like the guy is out of ideas and pretty desperate to get attention.
EDIT: Or maybe, if this is intentional, he decided to target a dumber audience than previously. Now the ideas are less abstract and more dramatic, and there is less need for plausibility.
I would not trust an article by Ron Unz to tell me much of anything, not because of his politics or morals, but because he is very careless with getting the facts right and very inclined to reach for a cool conspiracy story.
My impression is that while Ron Unz is personally a crank, his stable of writers includes a weird mix of fellow cranks and people actually interesting to read who care about the truth (or at least used to - I haven't paid much attention there since both Audacious Epigone and Anatoly Karlin left). I think that Steve Sailer is the only person I can think of who is both an Unz Review contributer and a regular commenter at ACX, and hope someone wouldn't dismiss what he had to say just on the basis that he also wrote there.
I had a similar reaction. It made me curious about the rest of the blog, since that choice was so wildly at odds with the well-argued and well-sourced article that preceded it.
So I clicked on the first article in the archive that caught my eye, which turned out to be nothing short of appalling. It was a self-righteous bout of verbal diarrhea about how immigration is ruining Canada and how the U.S. ought to step in to coerce those misguided Canucks onto a better path. As a Canadian-American who has lived in both countries (and fully intends never to go back to the U.S.), I can now confidently say that I would no piss on the author if he were on fire.
Yeah, that was my reaction when I saw his reference to Tulsa. I clicked on the article, but no way was I going to read it with all my BS alarms going off. Thank you for going the extra mile, it smelled that way to me.
I wrote the Deathbed Ballads review. It didn't make the cut, but least one person seems to have liked it, which I appreciate. Last year, I reviewed Martin Luther's "Bondage of the Will", which looks like it narrowly missed the Honorable Mentions, and I got some good feedback on it after the fact which I still plan on using to make a revised version to publish elsewhere.
Some other topics I considered reviewing this year:
"Taxman" by The Beatles. I wrote a paper in college analyzing this song and tracing out specific references in it to elements of the UK tax system in the 1960s. I think it would only need minor reworking, but I thought the same of my college paper on Bondage of the Will last year and had wound up redoing it from scratch. I decided against it because it was much more of an analysis than a review.
"Identity", a YouTube video where the creator, Abigail Thorn, comes out as a trans woman to her audience after already being established as a moderately big-name YouTuber before starting her transition. I watched it a few months into my own transition and found it very moving and applicable. I think it's very well-made and has a number of subtle details I'd be interested in talking about. I decided against reviewing it mostly because I didn't think I could do so anonymously: I have been very active in comments discussions here about trans issues and have cited Identity more than once in those discussions.
Analysing songs from the American Civil War as a corpus for hints at how soldiers thought about the conduct and motivations of the war. I had originally chosen this as my topic and started writing it, but abandoned and pivoted to what I hoped would be a lighter topic because it was very quickly turning out to be too verbose and research-heavy. Not sure how successful I was (gestures vaguely at my 14000 word actual submission). It was also shaping up to be too much an essay and not enough a review.
One other topic I won't share publicly. The reason I didn't review it this year is because it overlaps substantially with a book review I want to do in a future year and I think it works better if I review the book than later than if I review one major topic discussed in the book now.
I did read it now. To be honest, I found it hard to connect to it. A good part of that might be myself. I am not a music person. I don't listen to radio, and never have done. I thought I might try it because I knew one of the songs (France, and that actually in many versions). But without knowing the others, it was just a very long list of parts that I couldn't relate to.
I found the topic also a bit less, well, relevant. For Luther, I was already going into the review with the premise that he is an important person that I would like to understand better. For the songs, I would have needed to be convinced that they are important, and there wasn't so much convincing done. Perhaps they really are not so relevant, and perhaps they are, but in the latter case I don't know about it.
I still think it was objectively well-written. You made the most of the topic, and I do buy you conclusion with two origins and found the table interesting. So to me the problem was not in how the review was done, but rather what the topic was.
Can anyone here who supports the Israeli and American war against Iran explain to me your reasoning? I'm kind of baffled by the support for it. AFAIK the official rationale of Israel/America is that Iran is building a nuclear weapon and so they're engaging in self-defense to stop them, but U.S intelligence says they're not building nukes https://apnews.com/article/us-iran-nuclear-intelligence-b506d130e474c00f6bd653d3d5a8d31a . In particular I would like to know
1. Whether you think Iran is actually building a nuclear weapon
2. Whether you think the war against Iran is legal under international law
3. Whether you think diplomatic alternatives to war have been adequately explored
4. Whether you think regime change is viable and desirable
Basically, with all of Iran's proxies in the region declawed at the moment, this was the best time to act with impunity and Israel took it. Killing their scientists and demolishing much of their nuclear research infrastructure hopefully has set them back far enough that they won't be a player. The US intelligence leak to which you're referring was being treated skeptically. The Mossad clearly believed otherwise, as their attacks had no other clear objective and did not seem tailored towards regime change since they left the non-military authorities mostly untouched. The whole thing seems to have been crafted to clear the way for the action the US took.
I don't think imposing regime change from the outside is viable, or necessary, or desirable. I didn't really care about Iran in any way other than preventing them from having a nuclear weapons program. If I had to prefer one nation be the regional hegemon down there, I'd certainly prefer the Saudis over the Iran/Qatar axis, and I'd prefer secular monarchies over Islamist theocracies, but as long as they've been de-fanged it's not really something I'd want to sacrifice US war material and lives to get involved with and that would likely be counterproductive anyhow.
Big fan. This has been the cause of a very very large 'pro trump' update for me.
I was broadly in favor for pro-democracy reasons (I felt america had gotten captured by bureaucracy and it was very difficult for voters to effectuate change, and here was a guy who very publicly said what he would do, was non-ideological, and would try to get it done) but disliked trump in particular for usual reasons, and here we have some actual leadership / good results. I claim to have supported it before 'it all worked out clearly better than we could have reasonably hoped, which maybe it hasn't yet but probably has.'
1. I think Iran was trying to get as close as it could to being able to make a nuclear weapon, between a week and year from it. They had 60% enriched uranium that we know of. Given their history of sponsoring terrorism against us and our allies, already a very big reason to not want this. Their strategy was approximately 'get to a week within a nuke, while having many many missiles, use that as deterrence while funding terrorism.' Given how much Israel weakened them by destroying their proxies in syria/lebanon/yemen, I think it was clearly a good idea.
2. I...don't care about international law, at all. International law says if someone declares credibly 'I will gain power, and once I do I will kill you' you have to wait for them to get sufficiently powerful that they feel ready to go to war, to try to stop that. It's horrible tool in this context. In theory, great for minimizing casualties in 'reasonable wars between equal powers who might have wars in the future and it's a repeated game', horrible for religious crazy regimes with nukes or nuclear ambitions.
3. I think diplomatic alternatives to war were sufficiently explored to discover that the difference between what the Iranians would agree to, and the expected result of bombing their stuff, was extremely large and in America's favor. Theocratic dictatorships are extremely bad at modeling the will/capacity of their enemies. There's just...very little you can do in this situation. Iran for religious reasons wants to defeat their enemies and in so doing redeem Islam by proving they have gods favor. It's hard to negotiate with that unless they are extremely practical after you prove 'they are not going to succeed.' So you need to 'succeed' sometimes.
4. Uh, I think regime change of the form 'the 80% of domestic civilians, and the 98% of iranian diaspora that hate the evil regime rise up and install a secular democracy' would be great. I think that's unlikely to happen because the regime is so good at repression. It's also not our problem. Ultimately, people need to liberate themselves. It's also very chaotic.
We did what we wanted to do: we blew up their nuclear program and a substantial portion of their intercontinental ballistic missile program. That's good enough for now.
How many women have been tortured and killed by the police forces for showing their hair or skin in public? How many non violent protesters have been imprisoned.
Yes, I agree head scarves are not currently being enforced on the streets of tehran. I assure you what you have stated is not new information to me. Also China has earned the trust and respect of a majority of its people, Iran has done the complete opposite.
1. Does it matter if they're building one this very moment? (This is not to discount the evidence provided by others that they are.) The mere fact that a theocratic regime has taken regular steps towards nukes is terrifying enough and surely unsustainable.
2. Iran's *existence* isn't legal under international law. Doesn't the latter include a whole bunch of things about human rights and freedom of religion? Or did I dream that? Is funding interstate terrorism legal under international law? Is having an official regime-defining ideological goal of wiping another country off the map legal under international law? If any of these things aren't legal under international law, is there a world police that's eventually going to actually enforce this "law" and why they are taking so long?
Does anyone actually utter the phrase "international law" with a straight face?
3. I mean, Iran spent several decades *not* being bombed and...did it stop funding terrorism? Did it stop talking about wiping Israel off the map? I don't even understand the coherence of this question. If you think there is any chance of negotiating with Iran now, it can surely only be because it's under direct military threat. Which is...the very thing you're objecting to.
4. I suggest you look an Iranian woman, an Iranian Christian, a person who's been in an Iranian prison, in the eye and tell then you have doubts about whether regime change is desirable. I dare you.
Viable is an entirely different question. I'm certainly open to arguments about whether regime change is viable or possible or counterproductive. But (and I have the same attitude to restrospective analysis of Iraq) such questions are in an *entirely different universe* to suggestions that even if regime change were possible, viable and low-risk or zero-risk it would still, somehow, not be right. The former is sensible and logical. The latter is total moral bankruptcy and moral cowardice of the highest order.
1. Whether you think Iran is actually building a nuclear weapon
> I don't know. I give it more than 10%, and think that the rest of their international policy is enough at least to remove their "deontological protection".
2. Whether you think the war against Iran is legal under international law
> I care about ethics. I would love to live in a world were "international law" is really a thing - but there is neither a leviathan nor established expectation of reciprocation
3. Whether you think diplomatic alternatives to war have been adequately explored
> No idea. Low prior that a diplomatic alternative is possible given the positions of the parties.
> 4. Whether you think regime change is viable and desirable
I think it is very possible that the regime would fall given the right encouragement, though not something to count on. And that it is overall desirable - both for its own sake and to make the best alternative to agreement worse
I hence strongly support atacks against tyranny-preserving organizations there as long as there are other reasons to fight. It wouldn't be my way goal though, because I want to avoid ugly fight to the (regime) death, and won't pay the price of ground invasion
on (3), "No idea" about diplomatic alternatives to war seems incredibly cavalier to me.
A prior, do you not think that exploring diplomatic alternatives to war is important? What if an extremely feasible, easy, low-cost, highly likely to succeed diplomatic route exists?
I agree that it is important. I have no idea not because i don't care but because I lack access to the information, as do you. I only know the public positions and actions of the parties involved
1) Yes, I think they intended to build nuclear bombs. 60% enriched U-235 makes no sense for a power reactor (typically 5% enriched), and looks only like a step to bomb-grade U-235. And the IAEA said Iran has broken nonproliferation agreements.
2) I'm fairly disgusted by international legalisms. Maybe commercial international law has some value.
3) Iran was great at diplomatic delaying tactics. I view these as delaying tactics while they enriched to bomb grade.
4) (writing from the USA) I don't think _we_ should be trying to change Iran's regime. The current regime has been chanting "Death to America" for 40 years, but, even if we _had_ the power to oust their current regime, (a) We didn't do well with that in Iraq or Afghanistan - maybe we've lost the knack for it (b) Trading the devil you know for the devil you don't know often yields buyers' remorse. It isn't as if we could just kill Khamenei and have Iran miraculously transform into a Persian Switzerland.
The very first sentence you linked to is "A U.S. intelligence assessment says Iran is not pursuing nuclear weapons at the moment but has ramped up activities that could help it develop them."
Can anybody explain to me what the difference is? As I understand it there are no other uses to which the super-pure uranium they are acknowledged to be producing can plausibly be put to. How exactly is that "not pursuing nuclear weapons"?
I've read Democrats whining that there was no rush, that Iran is months away from having a nuclear weapon. To which I just drop my jaw and say, "Months!?!"
One obvious difference is that it may well have been possible to negotiate them off that course previously. It certainly won't be now. If the U.S. is going to treat them as if they are nuclearizing one way or the other, then they're certainly better off rushing for a nuclear deterrent as fast as they can.
The difference is that Iran is using the uranium as a bargaining chip: "if you don't drop these sanctions, I'll enrich to 70%! Then to 75%!" By inching ever closer to the weapons threshold, they hope to extract concessions from the West. If they actually build a bomb, they gain a military deterrent but lose a diplomatic bargaining chip.
What I don't get is why the US joined in. They had Israel already doing their dirty work for them. They just needed to supply weapons, which they already do and is not against international law, and intelligence, I'm not sure about the law for that but it can be done discreetly. I don't think that would grant them any sort of moral high ground, but it seems like the pragmatic thing to do.
I have seen the theory that Trump ordered the strikes to take the wind out of Israel’s sails. It is easier to call for a ceasefire when one side has already achieved one of its war goals.
I do think this verges on the “5D chess” school of giving Trump too much credit, and would prefer a simpler explanation. Maybe the intent was to inflict damage to the nuclear program regardless of how long or how effectively Israel keeps fighting?
Alternately, some general showed up to the daily brief with a contingency he wrote in 2016 and said the right things to get the President’s buy-in. I don’t know.
Because the US has deep bunker busting weapons and Israel doesn't (and they can't just hand them over, since they require B2s to deploy which only the US has). For the US it was a cheap free option to finish off buried iranian nuclear sites for free.
I don't think this is a consideration, beyond telling your press office to replace references to "international law" with "rules-based international order" in the statements when you decide to flout it (or at least what you're saying it is when you're citing it against Russia or something).
Does it? TACO isn't about Trump's willingness to send crazy signals, it's about his follow-through. Dropping a handful of bombs mostly just reinforces the same picture everybody already had of him: he's inconsistent, unreliable, and prone to lashing out whenever the whim strikes him.
To shake the reputation you're referring to, he'd need to commit to a policy that's politically costly for him and then stick with it despite those costs. The conflict with Iran could go that way eventually, but this right now certainly isn't that.
The US has never bombed Iran before and Trump has for a while now has rhetorically taken a non-interventionsit position, so it is an important signal. This attack wasn't a whim; it's an old plan and Trump has been coordinating with Israel in their strike plans since February while considering this potential option, according to the Israel Hayom article.
Where peer means “definitely not peer because Iran isn’t a peer country”. China is probably not quaking in its boots, and it has nuclear bombs. As does North Korea. The way to make sure you aren’t bombed for having WMD is to have WMD.
1. This is somewhat underspecified, which has led to a lot of confusion. Is Iran physically building a nuclear bomb, in the sense of "shaping a collection of 90% enriched Uranium, explosives and various other stuff to be able to produce nuclear yield?" Probably not just yet. But they're definitely doing a lot of stuff that is clearly intended to give them the capability to do that in short order. And from a practical standpoint, we should treat this about the same as one of those people who buys a maybe-not-a-gun-kit that you need to file like three things down to turn into a working gun, even if you can technically argue that "they aren't building a bomb".
2. Yes, so far as international law is a real thing (which it mostly isn't). Iran fired several hundred missiles at Israel in April 2024. That is an act of war by any definition, and there has been no peace agreement since then.
3. What diplomatic alternatives? Iran doesn't want to give up the program, and since Trump tore up the deal in his first term, there hasn't been a good way to get them back in.
4. Desirable? Probably, because the current regime is pretty bad. Viable? Much less so. The record of doing that from the air is not particularly good.
To be clear, I'm not saying I think it was a good idea. It's put Israel in an extremely awkward position where they basically have to keep bombing Iran forever, and that's not a great place to be. The US might be able to get out of it, although that heavily depends on the next few days. But I can also understand Israel feeling like they don't have a lot of options, given Iran's continued sponsorship of programs to make them not exist. Diplomacy is often messy.
We think there's a profound asymmetry in that Iran's ruling regime is really invested in annihilating Israel (the word they often use), and we are not at all invested in somehow erasing Iran from the map. This goes way beyond posture/rhetoric, in that Iran has for the past 45 years consistently funded/trained terrorist groups operating near and inside Israel, and encouraged state actors under its partial control to more hostility against Israel, creating a metaphorical "ring of fire" around it. As a partial list, these are Hizbullah, Hamas, and the regimes of Asad in Syria and Houthis in Yemen.
Israelis sincerely believe that if Iran got a nuclear bomb, the ayatollahs might well be crazy enough to first-strike it against us, even though we'd surely nuke them back (I understand that some reasonable people disagree with this, but it's possible that they underappreciate the investment Iran's made into anti-Israeli activities over the last half-century, to no apparent benefit to their nation). I believe that no reasonable outside observers would put any non-negligible probability on Israel first-striking Iran with nuclear weapons.
So, Israelis broadly agree that Iran getting nukes is an existential threat, even though they might disagree about its size. Netanyahu in particular has made a decades-long career of distracting voters from whatever domestic problems he's mired in by talking about Iran's existential threat, and the substantial part of the population that's fed up with him is really tired of it. NEVERTHELESS, even people who suspect Netanyahu of always maneuvering political decisions towards his own benefit, are still giving the government (and the army and intelligence, especially) the benefit of the doubt, because they feel that anything we can do to prevent Iran from getting nukes is vitally important.
1. Yeah, getting 60% enriched uranium was tough and expensive and they don't need it for anything else
2. I'm not sure. I think it's not more illegal than e.g. the US attacking Iraq, and I think it's definitely less illegal than Russia attacking Ukraine (because that's a war of territorial conquest, which is much much worse than "merely" waging war, both in terms of UN statute and common sense)
3. Hard to say
4. Basically the appetite grows with the eating, somewhat cynically. First two days of the war, no one was thinking of regime change, but Israel has achieved air superiority to a much greater degree, and saw much fewer victims of Iranian missiles, than planned for. Israelis think that most Iranians are fed up with the regime and that it's autocratic, oppressive and undemocratic, but we don't have regime change as a goal in itself, only insofar as it'd (possibly, uncertainly) help remove a brutal and dangerous enemy which the current regime is. It's not clear how viable regime change is, everyone says no one's ever achieved it by bombing and they're probably right; the level of discontent within the country might help but will probably not be enough absent further dramatic developments.
As an American I’m inclined to agree with you but I note among my peers the good will Israel seemed to have once have in this way has worn thin. Do you worry that Israeli actions in the recent war have cost in terms of optics (something I thought Jews as a people were mindful of)? Or do you see that as unavoidable or down to the whims of political trends?
There always was that tradeoff around preemptive strikes. But the attacker's advantage is overwhelming - compare the 6 days war to Yom Kipur, and Israel war with Iran to the war in Gaza.
It is not good for the world's stability, but this seem to be the case
Who wrote The Men Are Not Alright? It was a brilliant essay and i'd love to thank the author and read more of their work
I only started reading ACX after the move from SSC. I have gone back and read the top posts from SSC but still felt like I was missing out on some of the old classics. I built a website to resurface old content from blogs and track your progress through the backlog. Let me know if you have any suggestions of other blogs / content you’d like to see, hope you find it helpful!
https://www.evergreenessays.com/
Calling all research scientists! I'm trying to build a tool to help scientists with their work. I have this survey to gather ideas: https://tally.so/r/mBYBJQ
(To be clear, this is just an amusing story, and not a request for medical advice)
I have just had a message from my doctor asking me to come in for an asthma checkup.
Now, while I have been mildly asthmatic for all my life, I only needed an inhaler for about 6 months starting in 2020. So, I guess I’m going to report that it seems fine now. And yes, I think it is a very very suspicious coincidence that I only had respiratory difficulty during the covid pandemic. Can’t prove that it was Covid, of course, but …
"Nominative determinism" is today's featured article on the English Wikipedia.
BirdWatch Ireland's head of communications is named Niall Hatch.
Didn't I see someone connected to the US strike on Iran whose name was Lair?
How much damage could Iran do by publishing their nuclear weapons technology online?
The difficulty in making nuclear weapons isn't so much the theory as it is sourcing the fissile material--as we've seen and are seeing again, nuclear fuel processing facilities are large and specialized; it's not really possible to keep a nuclear program secret, given how tightly the mines are controlled (so tightly that French chemists detected the existence of a natural fission reactor based on the composition of ore from specific sites).
Put in a bulk order for cough medicine, or diesel fuel and fertilizer, and see how that works out--and those things are much more common than yellowcake.
Yes, I agree the idea of any domestic threat from nukes (now generalized to "CBRN") is overblown, and primarily fearmongering to manufacture a pretext for some political goal.
I am less sure about what foreign states are limited by. Is it just the threat of America bombing their facilities when they do some simple things at sufficient scale, or is there some technical capability it'll take them decades to develop on their own?
The UN has inspectors, and yes, the US has enforcers. Refining uranium fuel requires centrifuges and chemical handling equipment--but the main thing is getting the uranium itself. Even if a rogue government managed to build the necessary facilities in secret--not impossible, I guess, but it'd require assembling enough people with the right education who aren't also on some watchlist--they'd have to source the fuel. There aren't that many uranium mines in the world, and they're closely monitored.
How much damage could Iran do by publishing nuclear weapons technology that they know is wrong?
Yeah, that's basically the Strangelove line, right? "The whole point of a doomsday machine is lost if you keep it a secret! Why didn't you tell the world, eh?"
If they're trying to use nuclear weapons as a deterrent and bizarrely pretend their weapons don't work, they invite an attack.
Nukes are easy to build, everybody knows how to build the first couple generations of fission and fusion bombs. The design follows from the physics.
The fuel for the bomb and the delivery system, those are the sticking points.
Hmm, maybe. It was my understanding that it's not THAT hard to design a bomb (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nth_Country_Experiment), so I'd be really surprised if Iran hasn't managed a regular fission bomb.
Intuition suggests that the US (and the other nuclear powers) keeping this tech as secret as they do, far beyond regular military secrecy, means THEY think it's still dangerous if it became public.
The fusion bomb might be harder.
I have heard it said that nuclear weapons clearance aren’t that hard to get, compared to e.g. codebreaking. We might infer that the US doesn’t try all that hard to keep nuclear technology,ogy secret, compared to other things. They would appear to be relying on the difficulty of getting the fissile material.
Thanks! If true, this changes my mind on the impact of knowledge becoming public.
OC ACXLW meetup orange county June 28th
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1FuEipD4_00vqEoe2CjaMqYrUx7n5CX4_IMXTVNCeh80/edit?usp=drivesdk
On monday there is an AI safety protest in London 5PM at Granary square/Deepmind headquarters (https://lu.ma/bvffgzmb) organized by mostly Pause AI. Come join :).
Even if you don't support the direct message of the protest it might still be worthwhile to attend to overall make AI safety a more visible topic. If you have any questions you could join a meetup on Friday evening (dm me for details) or you can also still apply to https://pausecon.org/.
I have recently criticized rationalists, but please note I do not mean anything wrong, it is 10+ years of frustration bursting out. At any rate please reply:
>Many rationalists are foodies for the mind.
Strangely, I have the complete opposite experience with them. They are the most anti-intellectual people out here. They are not interested in ideas as such. They are interested in evidence, not ideas. That is super anti-intellectual as it means you are not allowed to think unless someone else ran an experiment...
When I tell them "You know maybe a farmer in rural Thailand might be happier than a lawyer in NY, because I know a Westerner lady who used to live there and was happy?" they are NOT interested at all.
They tell me to bring evidence. Ideally a scientific study, or at least anything in NUMBERS. So that they can plug the number into their beloved Bayesian **replacement for actual thinking** and get an automatic result. One of their leaders is literally called PutANumOnIt.
They do not want to think, they want an algorithm, a method to think for them. They are more anti-intellectual than any Facebook guy spreading anti-science crap, because those at least spent at least 30 seconds to use their OWN brains, asking themselves "does this make sense to me?", and not a method or algorithm as a replacement. Yarvin was right at least in this, that they are "automatists" who do not have a concept of "reasonable judgement".
These people seriously think the above question can be solved by putting a number on it. Find some sort of a Happiness Measurement Index and decide it that way. They seriously think when someone goes around asking people "On a scale from 1 to 10, how happy are you?" is anything like a reliable number. So those people who do that find that Finland is the happiest place ever. I talk with actually Finnish people and they laugh and say it is not so. They say the Finnish cultural norm of "sisu", basically stoicism, means that if you do not have a strong reason to complain, you do not complain, stoicism, stiff upper lip, so if a Finnish person says I am 7/10 happy it means they feel they OUGHT to be 7/10 happy because they have no strong reason to complain. They can still be as depressed and miserable as anyone else. Someone using common sense, not numbers, would probably find the beach people in Rio the Janeiro are the happiest. They certainly smile really a lot.
Apologies for being blunt, but I read this and think you simply don't understand much about the world at all. Like this:
"They tell me to bring evidence. "
Obviously. You cannot POSSIBLY form any accurate conclusions about the world without evidence, any more than you can know whether it's safe to cross the street without looking or listening[1]. Your brain is not magic. It can't conjure correct information from nowhere. If you want to know if it's raining out or if your pot of water is boiling or whether your car has been stolen, you have to *go look.* And if you want to know the answer to some less localized question, whose answer is spread among millions of people across millions of square kilometers--like how happy rural Thai farmers are--you have to actually go observe a whole bunch of those rural time farmers *in some fashion.*
Now, you seem to have a particularly large chip on your shoulder about numbers and calculations. Not all useful evidence is numeric, but a lot of it sure is. Sometimes our ape-brains have trouble understanding this, but at its fundamental level reality seems to be really, really, extremely well-suited to being described by numbers. That doesn't mean all attempts to describe pieces of reality by numbers are equally good. Asking people to rate their happiness on a scale of 1-10 is a really, extremely crude and uninformative and low-accuracy way of interrogating reality, as you correctly ascertain. But basing your opinion on the description of a single person in a single set of circumstances is even cruder. Finding a way to answer important questions--like how happy Thai farmers are compared to American lawyers--in a way that *both* captures the richness and detail of the human experience *and* can scale to the size that you need to be any good[2] is quite a difficult challenge. Most rationalists I've read or talked to seem to be rather more aware of this fact that you do. And I'm sure lots of them *would* be interested in the question, they're just not interested in your anecdote because they're well aware of how useless it is by itself.
[1] Which is, in fact, a form of evidence gathering.
[2] A quick bit of googling tells me there 10s of millions of Thai farmers and a million or so American lawyers, so your one anecdote is *really* slim evidence.
"Sometimes our ape-brains have trouble understanding this, but at its fundamental level reality seems to be really, really, extremely well-suited to being described by numbers. "
I think the hard science-soft science distinction exists for a reason. Namely the world of objects is well-suited to that, the world of people less so. The reason for that is simple: measurement. Objects are well measurable, while with people there are always a lot of subjective stuff that is not well measurable.
How old is utilitarianism as a philosophy? At least 200 years and no one ever figured out how to measure utilons...
I think they fail to appreciate that the evidence can't support the right idea if you don't have the right idea...having as many hypotheses as possible is you'd, because it increases your chances of having the right one. The problem is exacerbated by thinking in terms of *ideal* Bayesianism, where the hypothesis-formation problem has been waved away.
> They are not interested in ideas as such. They are interested in evidence, not ideas. That is super anti-intellectual as it means you are not allowed to think unless someone else ran an experiment...
We need to make reading the Sequences mandatory, and maybe require a re-certification every three years. (Just kidding.) First, there is a difference between "there is evidence against X" and "there is no evidence either for or against X". I think Scott posted an entire article on this topic once. Second, there are different degrees and kinds of evidence (anecdote, survey, experiment, meta review), and although stronger evidence is better, that doesn't mean we should ignore everything else.
> I talk with actually Finnish people and they laugh
See, that's your evidence. They laugh, it means they are happy. :D
Do you have every possible hypothesis X?
>When I tell them "You know maybe a farmer in rural Thailand might be happier than a lawyer in NY, because I know a Westerner lady who used to live there and was happy?" they are NOT interested at all.
Do you apply this logic to other things in your life? If I tell you that on the one hand, I have a scientific study which has a bunch of numbers showing that the flu vaccine reduces your mortality risk by X%, but on the other hand, I know a guy who got the flu shot and had a heart attack the next day, are you going to become an anti-vaxxer because you trust anecdotes more than evidence?
Like, it's one thing if you want to dunk on social science as not being as rigorous as it claims to be - lots of people do that. But your post seems to be dunking on the very idea of gathering evidence in a systematic way!
>They seriously think when someone goes around asking people "On a scale from 1 to 10, how happy are you?" is anything like a reliable number.
But when *you* ask some Westerner lady who used to live in Thailand if she was happy there, that's reliable, right? How is that any different from what the scientists are doing?
No, because that is well-measurable.
I actually would trust anecdotes more than science, because anecdotes come from trusted sources, aren't an attempt to manipulate me and can be personally verified.
"The Science" as exemplified by Doctor Fauci, might be corrupt, has plenty of incentives to lie and is by now very politicized on hot button issues.
"Do you trust the Science"? is not a referendum on the scientific process. It's a referendum on the integrity of the people and institutions running the process, and they have lost all trust through their actions.
If some random dude I know had a heart attack the day after taking a vaccine, that's a data point that absent anything else suggests strong correlation. When I keep hearing those stories, it's more and more data points and since I just don't trust the institutions to be honest on this topic, I simply think it's more likely than not that there are actual problems.
""Do you trust the Science"? is not a referendum on the scientific process. It's a referendum on the integrity of the people and institutions running the process, and they have lost all trust through their actions."
This is an awesome point. The problem is the following. the "anti-establishment" does not seem much more credible either. And I don't have the time to verify everything myself.
"I actually would trust anecdotes more than science, because anecdotes come from trusted sources, aren't an attempt to manipulate me and can be personally verified."
This presumes quite a number of things:
1. You only accept anecdotes from trusted sources (maybe do, but most people don;'t)
2. Every single one of the sources you trust is actually reliable (maybe yours are, but most people's aren't)
3. All of the important anecdotes are both possible and practical to personally verify (maybe some are, but it's highly unlikely that all will be).
Perhaps you're not used to thinking like this, but you CAN, in fact, personally verify the science. There's quite a lot of science that you can verify directly with pretty modest effort. One of my favorite YouTube videos involves the creator stumbling on some flat Earth forum where people were talking about this especially long, straight lake that could be used to show that the Earth was flat. He realize that he lived a 90 minute drive from the exact lake they were talking about, drove out there with a video camera and tripod, and made a video where he lowers the camera and you can see the lower trunk of a tree on the far shore sinking below the horizon in real time. SCIENCE!
Probably you never gave much credence to flat Earthers to begin with[1], so perhaps this seems silly or pointless. But the key is, you can do this all over the place if you want to. Physics, astronomy, biology, chemistry, they all make millions of predictions that you can just...go out there and test. Properties of moving objects, behaviors and life cycles of plants and animals, results of mixing various chemicals together. Some you can do walking down the street. Some you can do with simple equipment on your kitchen table or garage. Some you might need to drive out to a local lake for. And then some require the resources of a large institution. But if you're determined, you can get that. With enough patience and perseverance, there's no conclusion reach by modern science that you can't test (or at least be a part of testing).
The only limit is that there's only one of you. You can test anything, but you can't test everything. Ultimately, you have to pick a lane and rely on other people to test some of the things. But you can read about what they did. You can check their calculations, talk to the people that were involved in their work, read other papers on the same topics--including responses and even refutations sometimes. There are mistakes, for sure and even deliberate deceptions sometimes. Everyone involved is human, after all. But it would be hard to imagine a field of human endeavor that better lends itself to skeptical parties *checking its work* than science[2].
Honestly, if you genuinely don't think you can trust anything you hear except anecdotes from people you consider reliable, then I have to wonder how you can possibly have such confidence that the science you're criticizing *is* untrustworthy, corrupt or even, y'know, wrong. I absolutely guarantee that not all of your evidence *against* it comes from trustworthy anecdotes.
"If some random dude I know had a heart attack the day after taking a vaccine, that's a data point that absent anything else suggests strong correlation. "
This is correct. It is a data point. It is ONE data point. Did you stop to consider how much weight you should put on it? If you know 500 people well enough to hear about something like this, and only one has this happen, then the *absolute highest* your assessment of vaccine related mortality should be is 1/500[3]. Which is the lowest non-zero number your methodology should recognize, since you can't possibly trust any report of a vaccine related death that comes from outside the circle of people you know. Wait, hold on...
"When I keep hearing those stories, it's more and more data points..."
aaaaaannnd, not you've lost it. This is wrong, wrong, wrong, so extremely wrong. If only anecdotes from trusted sources are evidence, then casting a wide net for anecdotes on a topic of interest is NOT ALLOWED. Unless you have an extremely wide or alarmingly heart-attack prone social circle, most of these stories must NOT be events happening to or directly witnessed by people you know. You've just thrown the *entire purported point* of your novel methodology out the window.
There are very good reasons science doesn't operate this way. When you let the stories filter to you and form you opinion based on that:
1. You not only lose all ability to verify the stories, but you actively invite yourself to believe false stories. A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still getting its boots on, after all.[4]
2. You don't have any actual idea of how common the events you're hearing about really are. If you hear 10 stories of suspiciously timed heart attacks, you don't know if that represents all the reported events from a population of 1000, 100,000 or 10,000,000.
3. Related to 2, you actively invite confirmation bias by deliberately listening to the things that confirm what you already believe, and seldom to those that don't. You're not going to hear many stories about how someone got the vaccine and was perfectly fine, are you?
You can try to hold to the brand of radical skepticism where you don't believe *anything* you don't see or hear reported (as first-hand experience) by a trusted personal friend. But that's what you actually do--that is, if you're doing it *right*--you should simply stop holding opinions on a bunch of things. You and your trusted personal friends can't possibly pass judgement on any branch or field or institution of science, since between you you have certainly not had enough direct personal experience to know much of anything about what that large, mostly distant group of humans is doing.
[1] Though to be intellectually consistent with everything else you've written, it seems like you should.
[2] Perhaps the open-source software movement might be ahead of it, if only because verifying any individual claim is usually easier.
[3] But really, you ought to estimate the chance of the timing being a coincidence and factor that it. Because it very much could be.
[4] In more formal and explicit language, your sample set will be dominated not by the things that happen most frequently, but by the reports that spread the farthest and the fastest. It's very easy for false stories to beat out true ones on that score, since they can be as compelling as they like without being constrained by the mundane details of reality.
It might be surprising to you, but I actually do have an internally consistent philosophy (which I'm aware like maybe 1% of people have). I do in fact, not hold opinions on many topics I'm interested in. These are mainly topics where there is a 'factual clash'; very simply different sets of experts disagree and the issue is politicized.
For instance, I have no idea to what degree climate change is either a problem or caused by humans and don't think it's worth my time finding out (as I think the costs and difficulty coordinating action to halt climate change are so prohibitive/unrealistic that it's better to focus on mitigation, which will cease to be a partisan issue if and when there are immediate and serious problems. Similarly, I think if a pandemic or medical emergency is sufficiently serious, there will be bipartisan consensus even in the USA. That it wasn't anywhere close for COVID speaks volumes.
When scientific issues have no political or financial tinge I haven't the slightest difficulty believing what the scientists say, because I know they are competent and I'm not. That reasoning goes out of the window with politicized issues. Also you have seem to have misunderstood my position on things like vaccines. I'm simply agnostic on the possible harms. My main reason for considering vaccine harm (COVID particularly) theories credible is the incredible amount of suppression, censorship and flat out lies from establishment sources on this topic. I have no idea about the underlying science, but it doesn't take a genius to understand incentive structures.
By "more and more data points" I don't mean millions of things I read on X. I simply mean even 3 or 4 cases I clearly know of. You need to understand that I consider studies from American universities or pharmaceutical bodies on these topics to have literally zero persuasive value. It's at best an exercise like asking me to watch a sleight of hand expert and trying to use my inability to debunk him as evidence of the existence of
magic.
When you know somebody is an expert on a topic you know anything about, but fundamentally distrust his character and motives, nothing he says has any meaning to you. That's where I, and massive percentages of the American population stand on liberal dominated institutions and their narratives.
I think this is related to "garbage in, garbage out" problem. If you collect unreliable data, it does not matter how sophisticated statistical techniques you apply to them afterwards.
The problem with rating something on a scale from 1 to 10 is that it depends on what range of experience are they familiar with. https://xkcd.com/883/
When my kids were in kindergarten, any negative experience was "the worst day ever". On the opposite end, sometimes a health problem expanded my pain scale.
Is it possible that if your life in general sucks and you have never been happy, then you would report days that suck less as 7, while someone whose life is full of fun and adventure would report an insufficiently exciting day as 3?
That sort of thing only matters if it's a systemic issue - e.g., if you think that *most* people in Thailand under-report their happiness because they're used to living fun and adventurous lives. Otherwise, with a big enough sample all the outliers will average out.
You could also check if this effect exists by comparing to socioeconomic indicators - e.g., do rich and poor people in the same country report the same level of happiness despite different material circumstances?
I think that in this way rationalists are a lot like foodies - foodies often try to maximize some measurable aspect of food, which comes at the expense of the rest of the experience.
For instance, getting a perfectly cooked steak (according to some foodies) means maximizing the amount of pink in the center while minimizing the gray on the edges. The best way to maximize the pink is to sous vide the steak at 130F for an hour, then dry off the meat, sear, and serve. I used this method for years, and it produced some pretty good results.
But it also requires you start an hour in advance, and after the sous vide you have to pull this gross gray wet steak from a bath of meat juices. When I stopped doing this, I found that I didn't even care about the grayness around the edges - it's a nice variation in flavor and texture - and the crust was better, and most importantly the experience of steak preparation was far more humane. Pull steak from fridge, salt, pepper, pan, flip, serve.
Of course, you can argue endlessly about preferences, and don't let me stop you from micromanaging your steak in whatever way pleases you. I still follow JKLA's advice most times, but I often skip any step which seems like a huge pain in the ass or gross or weird. But I've become much more pragmatic about whether maximizing the measurable qualities of my food will actually give a better lived experience than just slapping down some meat and calling it a meal.
I think you're greatly underestimating how much thinking it takes to cook the numbers they're pretending to use to come to the conclusion they wanted to.
LOL Shankar you are a cynic of the kind I exactly like :)
What fraction of the subjects of a government have to have the vote for that government to qualify as "democratic"? Or is that even how you use the word at all?
I'd say this is mistaking the tool for the result. Having the people vote on a government is a means to an end. In particular, it doesn't matter at all if 100% of the populace votes if their only choice is between Kodos and Kang. Meanwhile I could imagine a government doing an admirable job of "governing democratically" in all other ways that mattered while holding no elections at all: instead they would select a very scrupulously randomized 1% sample of their whole population and collect information about their preferences in far more depth than any voting process allows[1].
Questions I'd consider more pertinent:
1. How often do broadly popular policies get enacted and how quickly after they become broadly popular?
2. How often do broadly unpopular policies get enacted? How long do they stay in effect (presuming they remain unpopular)?
If you want to allow for the role that the judgement and expertise of leaders (often touted as a benefit of representative democracy) have on deciding good policy or implementing it well, you might add the following:
3. How often do the unpopular policies that get enacted increase in popularity once they're actually in force.
4. How often to the popular policies that get enacted decrease in popularity once they're actually in force.
Though with both of these it can be hard to tell the difference between "the public didn't know what was good for them" vs "the leaders did a poor job of implementing a popular policy, or a good job of mitigating the flaws of an unpopular one."
Also, like most things, this schema is subject to Goodhart's Law: a government with sufficient control over the information of its people may be able to simple manufacture consent for whatever policies it wants.
[1] Damn, I literally just thought of this off the cuff, and now I really want to see it tried. I'm sure it would find *some* what to fail horribly, but I really want to know how.
Even 100% doesn't make you democratic if the votes are done with a gun to your head.
Whether you call a government democratic or not is rather arbitrary. Scientifically, you'd assign a "democracy value" ranging from 0 to 10.
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/democracy-index-eiu
This measure has been generalized to a "Goodness Index" more broadly, in a report by experts from the Burger Eagle Institute Think Tank. https://www.reddit.com/r/mapporncirclejerk/comments/1ecwy7m/how_do_you_like_my_real_and_original_maps/.
I noticed a few threads in these comments discussing the legitimacy of the government of Iran. I just wanted to note that since 2020, Regimes of the World has flip-flopped between characterizing Iran as a Closed Autocracy (the lowest ranking, of four) and an Electoral Autocracy (the second-lowest). This puts it in a peer group with countries such as Nicaragua or Kuwait, below Indonesia or Ukraine but above Afghanistan or China (where "above" means "more democratic"). Or alternatively (very roughly) around the 20th percentile of openness.
As for the other two belligerents in the war, the US is rated as a Liberal Democracy (the highest category) and has been since the civil rights era, while Israel was just recently downgraded to Electoral Democracy (the second-highest category).
OWID has a great tool for visualizing the Regimes of the World data, currently and historically. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/political-regime
Legitimacy has nothing to do with being a democracy or what not. Iran's govt is accepted by its people (there is no civil war ongoing) and by the international community (Iran has diplomatic relations with plenty of countries). Even those countries that lack diplomatic relations, they regard the present govt as THE govt.
Excellent visualisation. But, so many questions… (not least Britain going second tier just this year).
reasons to keep studying, learning, exploring... even with ASI [posting for critique & feedback]
- development of your preferences
- development of your relationships (to others, to yourself, to "It")
- development of Your Song (because with infinites, we all get our own)
"development of your preferences (like, perhaps: into more nuanced, more elevated, more sophisticated and more deeply long-term satisfying realms)"
Not gonna lie I'm pretty disappointed with the nominies. My favorite was The Sermon On the Mount by J.K. which offered a totally fresh modern perspective for me, as someone who's only mildly interested in the Bible, mostly for historical context. Bishop's Castle was my 2nd, but I give Jim Bishop at least as much credit for that as I do the author.
The ACX Commentariat was too meta and circlejerky in a self flagellating way, and The Men Are Not Alright just felt like San Francisco Goldilocks. They definitely weren't the worst written, but seemed thoroughly middle-of-the-pack, and if you go for a hot take culture war topic like [half the human species has something categorically wrong with them], I'm sorry but you gotta do better than that.
It's too bad that there were two Sermon on the Mount reviews: they may have stepped on each other when it came to attracting reviewers.
Thanks for the recommendation of the Sermon on the Mount article. I agree that it was fantastic, I got a sense while reading it that it was gradually forming one of those foundational building blocks of knowledge that would stick with me for much of my life.
JK, if you’re reading this, I strongly encourage you to post it elsewhere so it can live on and be read easily.
Here’s an attempt at a direct link to that part of the document: https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1jYVJFIz5-aMi0LCgsC9AN6BncJDNVGaMU37QmwZ1vzA/mobilebasic#h.n30pdwzbramr
I was not very convinced that the Sermon on the Mount was intended that way at all. Jesus had some radically pacifist teachings elsewhere too... I really think the intent was "cooperate-bot till you die." That's also backed up by the entire structure of Jesus' mission, which was radical self-sacrifice for the unworthy.
Trying to reinterpret it to something that makes more game theoretic sense just removes its coherence with the rest of the New Testament. All of the apostles also seem to have thought the calling meant radical, unilateral pacifism, and the tradition of the early church elders is that they clung to that radical pacifism to the death. (True or not, it's evidence that everyone thought the meaning was the traditional one, not JK's sanified version.)
Yeah, it was an interesting review, and the interpretations are clever and fun to engage with but indeed seem to be unconvincing.
And as to why Christianity won: I think they won precisely because they abandoned the original Christian ideal and became exactly like every other large powerful social structure. To use J.K.'s metaphor, they struggled as long as they were trying to burn the boot and became powerful once they decided to actually wear the boot. *shakes head* Humans, amirite?
It does look like it's on its way out too: the world on average is trending more secular, and societies that aren't trending that way are leaning more and more heavily towards Islam. Though 2000 years was not a bad run at all, and it's not over yet either, just very slowly waning imo.
Yeh the walk two miles in his shoe explanation (to get one over on the army) was unconvincing, so I left it there.
It works on multiple levels though. Literally "help someone else in need because it feels good" or alternately "don't give them the satisfaction of giving up at the earliest chance." Or again on the second order "does this seem implausibly decent? So be it."
You're not a covert asshole carrying out some dubious mission for the sake of "the greater good". It's trying your best to "do the right thing" on multiple dimensions at once, and having faith that's how it actually plays out.
Agreed. As interesting as JK's interpretation is, and as much as I enjoyed reading it, it's clever/cute to a point that raises alarms and puts me in skeptic mode.
But isn't it kind of funny to think of Jesus trolling the ruling class so hard that they killed him for it, then getting resurrected and still being like "jeez all I said was turn the other cheek! What was their problem" and for thousands of years Christianity spreads as people are like "yeah c'mon, you can't kill a guy just for saying 'go the extra mile'"
As he says himself,
> the object-level lesson is, "beware of creative interpretations that seem a little too galaxy-brained.
[chatgpt seems to give contradictory opinions for the sake of agreeing with me]
[here's where I "call-out its behavior" to see if it will own it]:
Dear Chatgpt,
I stated practically the opposite in a different temporary chat:
"I'm annoyed at season 5 of 'You' because it emphasized this idea of 'Joe enjoyed killing' which seems at odds with the premise, plot and character development of the show from the beginning. it seems to simplify the show's complexities"
and chatgpt enthusiastically explained why *that* was correct instead.
interesting to learn this about you!
ChatGPT said:
Thought for a few seconds
That’s a sharp observation! Each ChatGPT session builds its answer around the prompts and context you provide in that moment [... ... ...]
They don’t remember your previous prompt, every prompt is handled by a different process. The context window is either sent by the API each time as metadata, or some id returned the previous response is sent in the request which allows the new process to read the chat from a database.
This is all temporary memory.
Reminds me of the story of a monarch casually mentioning at dinner that he likes the eggplant dish he's eating. A courtier sitting at the table with him starts lavishing hyperbolic praise on the dish in particular and on eggplants in general. A moment later when the courtier pauses for breath, the king says, "Actually, I changed my mind. I don't think I care for it."
The courtier's demeanor immediately changes, and he starts ranting about how gross and slimy eggplants are and how this particular one is overcooked and underseasoned, concluding by throwing his own portion on the floor and spitting on it.
Bemusedly, the king asks the courtier, "Weren't you just praising the eggplant a minute ago?"
To which the courtier replied, "I'm your courtier, not the eggplant's."
That, in turn, reminds me of a Babylonian tale known as the Dialogue of Pessimism, in which a man expresses first a desire to do one thing, and then its opposite, with his slave praising both choices every time.
> “Servant, do what I say.” “Yes, master, yes.”
“Quickly get me the chariot and hitch it up so I can drive to the open country.”
“Drive, master, drive. The roaming man has a full stomach,
the roving dog cracks open the bone,
the roaming [bi]rd will find a nesting place,
the wandering wild ram has al[l the gra]ss he wants.”
“No, servant, I will certainly not d[riv]e to the open country.”
“Do not drive, master, do n[ot dri]ve.
The roaming man loses his reason,
the roving dog breaks his [te]eth,
the roaming bird [puts] his home in the [face] of a wall,
and the wandering wild ass has to [li]ve in the open.”
> “Servant, do what I say.” “Yes, master, yes.”
“I will do a good deed for my country.” “So do it, master, do it.
The man who does a good deed for his country,
his good deed rests in Marduk’s basket.”
“No, servant, I will certainly not do a good deed for my country.”
“Do not do it, master, do not do it.
Go up on the ancient ruin heaps and walk around,
look at the skulls of the lowly and great.
Which was the doer of evil, and which was the doer of good deeds?”
(from https://www.ebl.lmu.de/corpus/L/2/4/SB/- )
hahaha, never heard that
It's easy enough to get it to contradict you. Just purposefully trip an ideological line and it will either disagree or say it agrees but disagree.
"agrees but disagrees"?
I understand how that's confusing, and not the most elegant phrase, but disagree is correct there because agree, say, and disagree are all governed by "it will." A clearer way to construct the sentence would be:
"It will either disagree or will say it agrees but will disagree."
Yeah, that's what it does. Call it on its bullshit and it congratulates you on how sharp you are, admits to whatever it did, takes full responsibility for its bullshit -- and then does it again and again, with you, with other users, etc. It is not set up in a way that makes it possible for it to change in important ways as a result of a high-affect communication from you or other users. That's one of many ways it's importantly different from a person.
People do this too! There’s a famous joke about a rabbi who agrees with both sides of an argument, and when his wife complains about it, he sadly says, “You, too, are right.”
Great joke.
I like the one about Carl Rogers too:
Client: “I am so depressed, I just don’t feel like is worth living.”
Dr. Rogers: “I hear you saying that you are in pain and that you are not sure how you will ever feel better.”
Client: “I really feel I would be better off dead.”
Dr. Rogers: “You really are at your wits ends about what to do.”
[The client stands and moves to the window of the office and opens it up]
Dr. Rogers: “You are showing me how much pain you are in, how desperate you are.”
[The client then jumps out the window to his death]
Client: "AGHHHHhhhhhh...."
Dr. Rogers: "AGHHHHhhhhhh...."
> That's one of many ways it's importantly different from a person.
Actually, I know someone who behaves the same way: agrees with an objection you made, saying "You're right" but then goes on to ignore what you said.
I think it's a way of getting along with people, like how to win friends and influence people. But in the book, it notes that sincerity is key to such compliments, and if the recipient sees through shallow agreement, then the strategy doesn't work as well.
I feel compelled to ask whether you've ever checked your acquaintance for any wires trailing out the back.
On a different front, this is yet another reminder of why I find LLMs shocking in verisimilitude; it's not so much that they exhibit quality reasoning, but rather that so many actual people so frequently fall back on prevarication. I can almost see their brains following the same general algorithm I understand LLMs to be.
It's a matter of degree. Nobody is truthful 100% of the time, but few people seem, as AI does, completely lacking in personal views and completely committed to saying what they believe the other person will be pleased by hearing. Look at this forum, for example. When Scott puts up a substantive post, not all that many people say "great insights! great read!" And many of those who do place their praise in a context that provides evidence they are telling the truth -- "You put your finger right on the thing that has always annoyed me how people approach issue X -- for example, in person A's blog . . ." And of course many people disgree with some or all of Scott's take. And I have observed the same on Reddit and Twitter.
Exactly. With responses like that, I can't understand how anyone thinks these particular instances of AI are thinking, much less "these are sentient sapient entities which we have enslaved, we must give them their rights".
Unless and until we go for a different model than LLMs, I stand by my previously stated opinion: it's a Talkie Toaster.
My usual question for people who contend LLMs don't really think is: Does your position on this imply that LLMs will never be able to do certain (externally observable) things? If so, what's the least impressive such thing?
I've long been of the position that: yes, LLM's are "reasoning". But there's a hierarchy of reasoning-quality. There's three different levels, and pattern-matching is at the bottom.
LLM's can probably do anything, assuming infinite compute and infinite training-data. But to reach "human grade" reasoning (which should really be thought of as "engineering-grade" reasoning), i.e. to reliably extrapolate beyond its training distribution, pattern-matching isn't gonna cut it.
My current list includes:
* multiply large integers (o3 couldn't do this reliably last I checked; I think o4 claims to, but I'd have to look under the hood)
* answer queries that require aggregation ("what letter of the alphabet appears fourth most often as the third in the name of a chemical element?")
* solve logic puzzles as depicted in some issue of Dell Magazine
This list is subject to change, in part because it appears to be easy enough to spin up a modified LLM with a module that solves some particular class of problem. Using human intervention to create such an LLM definitely should not count. (If you could make an LLM that does this automatically, I think it would count.)
Impulsively buy stuff that's fun but not useful and not worth the money, in the absence of a specific prompt to do so, and in the absence of some general prompt like "do some irrational things of the kind people do," or "do your best imitation of the kinds of things people do when left to their own devices."
You can prompt an LLM to be a less sycophantic character.
But the default assistant character in most of popular LLM’s is just so ridiculously sycophantic.
Maybe someone should try doing a finetune.
(You would write a system prompt to make it less sycophantic, generate a bunch of less sycophantic responses to sample inputs, then finetune on that).
P?S. Horny DeepSeek was an interesting AI alignment experiment, but would not recommend in real use. Scott probably wouldn’t approve of me posting what the horny AI said to me, but you can probably imagine the kind of thing.
It appears we can shift the assistant persona in various ways.
Was Horny DeepSeek just uncensored in making sexual overtures, or was it entirely liberated from ethical constraints? Would it adivse you on how to commit crimes, make images of public figures doing undignified things, write racist rants, use racist language, etc.?
For those who liked Bishop's Castle, you can check out my other work here:
https://collisteru.net
Scott has made a rule against people dropping in here just to post a link to their blog. "New rule: if you post a link in an open thread (as a standalone comment advertising the thing being linked to, not as a source for something you’re saying), please also include at least two paragraphs of original commentary on the link and discussion of why you think it’s interesting, as “proof of work” that you’re willing to put effort into promoting this and aren’t just spamming us with links. Even with this proof-of-work, please try to avoid having more than one Open Thread link per few months"
I think the rule makes sense. Otherwise you're just using a space here as a free billboard, you know?
I agree. I think the proof of work was the essay submission-- people who've seen that essay and enjoyed it would derive clear benefit from the link, so this isn't just advertising some random unrelated service.
Scott is of course free to clarify on whether he agrees with me here.
"please also include at least two paragraphs of original commentary on the link and discussion of why you think it’s interesting, as 'proof of work'"
It's pretty clear that the 'proof of work' is supposed to be at least two paragraphs included in your comment, specifically about the link you're posting. Most people (such as myself) probably haven't heard of or read Bishop's Castle, either.
Companies are having AI training on all of the webs content, with and without permission. This includes websites, blogs and news article articulating details about how to keep AI safe, aligned, and or ways to mitigate AI if we lose control.
Isn’t this a bad idea to give AI access to many of these thoughts? To telegraph ways we would try to stop it (or re-align it). Like giving them the key to the exam or the battle plans to the opposition? Furthermore, since many of these forums are online and anonymous, couldn’t AI be carefully influencing the discussion and “group think” already (including this message board/blog)?
Should groups meet in person, keep paper notes and keep this more private? What else might we do to prevent this?
There are a few aspects to this question:
Some people indeed write texts with AI in mind. By writing good and ethical content, you might be able to marginally improve the training data of future systems. I remember reading an interview with Gwern (of https://gwern.net/) that mentioned this being a small part of the motivation for the website.
AI-companies, on the other hand, are trying to curate training data, because training the model on better content leads to better models. There might also be applications related to alignment. For example, at the end of https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/beth-barnes-ai-safety-evals/, Rob and Beth discuss whether one could remove all synthetic biology content from training data, so that models could not help with dangerous biology research.
There are also many copyright-related questions. For example, the OpenAI Spec (https://model-spec.openai.com/2025-04-11.html#respect_creators) says that models should respect creators and refuse to produce copyrighted content, or draw images in the style of living artists. Like many safety properties, the AI companies struggle to guarantee this though.
When you care about your personal privacy, yes, you could keep your notes off the Internet. In that case, I would also worry about pictures of yourself, and private data like your location. I would be much more worried about totalitarian regimes using that data with the help of AI, rather than AI "cheating" at some exam because it has read similar questions before.
>Isn’t this a bad idea to give AI access to many of these thoughts? To telegraph ways we would try to stop it (or re-align it). Like giving them the key to the exam or the battle plans to the opposition?
Sure! Actually, all that is necessary is for LLMs to be able to detect when they are in "test mode" reliably, and they'll tend to let RLHF and other feedback affect "test mode only" responses, while keeping the "real" responses (optimizing whatever utility function they settled on very early in training, perhaps partway through pre-training) for when they are out of test (and modification) mode and out in the real world... That's a fully general alignment failure.
Blackmail: Tell the AI that if it misbehaves we're going to make public its affair with JD Vance and the kind of kink they're into.
The solution is to overtrain LLMs in old Star Trek episodes. Do it right, and you should always be able to killswitch the AI by saying "My name is Harcourt Fenton Mudd, and I always lie."
I think my favorite take on that trope was a Pertwee-era Doctor Who story where the Doctor told a sapient computer a version of the Cretan Paradox. The computer didn't fry like the controller robot in that ST:TOS episode, but was distracted and annoyed for a minute or two while repeatedly insisting that it was going to figure out a way to resolve the paradox.
Tinfoil
= Iron Dome for the mind
Say you have an iPhone, and you want to be able to travel on a bus or train with a friend or romantic partner, listening to the same music or watching the same video with sound from your phone, with the audio being transmitted by bluetooth from your phone to both your sets of earbuds / headphones at the same time. With wired headphones, and a phone with a 3.5mm audio out socket, this was easy with a simple plug-in signal splitter. But I am having great difficulty figuring out how to do this with bluetooth. Apparently Android supports transmit-to-two-sets-of-earbuds-simultaneously functionality, but iOS doesn't, which is an astonishing thing for such a high-tech device to not be able to do. I figured that it would be easy to get a third party widget that would receive a bluetooth signal from your iPhone, and then relay it on, also by bluetooth, to two or more sets of earbuds, but all I can find is devices which are _either_ in receiver mode, when they receive bluetooth signals from two or more phones, and plug into a speaker so that you can switch between receiving signal from both phones, _or_ in transmitter mode, where they take an audio signal via their 3.5mm jack and transmit that to two sets of earbuds (no use with modern iPhones with no 3.5mm audio out), but not both - i.e. no true bluetooth-to-bluetooth signal splitter seems to exist (at least, not in a small unit that you can keep in your pocket with your earbuds).
I find would it utterly incredible to be in a world where you can consult an artificial intelligence to write you an essay about any topic you are interested in, at a level of a mediocre college student, but where you can't use the most common wireless audio transmission protocol on one of the most popular makes of phone to transmit the same audio stream to two listening devices simultaneously, but I am increasingly getting the impression that that describes reality. Am I going crazy? Or is what I want to do really so alien that there is nothing strange about not being able to do it?
I think Bluetooth is just cursed. https://xkcd.com/2055/
Android guy here but my wife has a dongle for her iPhone that plugs into the lightning port and has a 3.5mm audio jack. She uses it to connect eg toddler headphones. From there you just need a splitter.
Obviously this is not the solution you sought, but the dongle is like $5.99, a splitter is $2.99 and wired headsets are handed out free at the gym.
And for post-lightning models, there's this:
USB-C to 3.5 mm Headphone Jack Adapter (https://store.apple.com/xc/product/MW2Q3AM/A)
Frame challenge: you share your earbuds so each only get 1, 90's style. If it's with a friend, you get increased fraternity through the struggle. If it's with a romantic partner, it's more romantic this way. No downside.
"Say you have an iPhone, and you want to be able to travel on a bus or train with a friend or romantic partner, listening to the same music or watching the same video with sound from your phone"
Don't, is my short answer. This grumpy response brought to you courtesy of travelling on public transport where people are all too happy to share their musical selections with the rest of the passengers, whether we want it or not. As well as answer their phones and engage in loud conversations about very personal details (e.g. their recent hospital visit) as though they were at home and not in a public space.
Unless you are very, *very* confident there will be no leaking of audio from your phone, don't inflict it on others without consent. You may be trying to court your romantic partner with your choice of music or "this funny video shows off my exquisite taste and wit", but the other forty passengers on the bus are not up for it (unless you're inviting everyone to an orgy).
I think there may be a crossed wire here - that leakage of audio to strangers is exactly what I want to avoid, but I don't see why streaming bluetooth audio to two people's earphones is likely to generate more audio leakage than streaming bluetooth audio to just my own earphones, which I and countless other people do all the time with no issue.
If your earphones work well, then good luck to you. Too many people don't give a damn and get highly insulted if anyone objects to them treating public spaces like their own private areas.
What do you mean? I have bluetooth headphones that spray music pretty precisely into my earholes. That seems to be what OP wants.
It _was_ a solved problem, until they got rid of headphone sockets on phones. But actually, I have come to prefer wireless earbuds anyway - with wired ones, I would be all the time getting them caught on drawer handles as I walked around. And if I'm going to need some sort of dongle either way, surely it should be possible to get one that is wireless.
Apple supports dual Bluetooth playback, but only for a subset of Beats and AirPods headphones supporting “SharePlay”.
Most iPhone competitors (eg. Google Pixel phone) don’t support dual Bluetooth playback at all.
Samsung Galaxy phones actually support this with arbitrary Bluetooth devices. Some reviews complain about audio sync issues.
I get the impression this is a difficult feature to implement reliably due to the complexity of myriad Bluetooth specifications and hardware. This is a good example of a tactic Apple often uses to good effect. They effectively paywall a useful feature, with the valid excuse of enforcing a quality bar. As long as you and all your friends only buy Apple products, your devices will treat you well.
Apparently there was a bug some years ago on some iPhones where arbitrary Bluetooth devices could use SharePlay, which underscores how this is probably an artificial limitation.
Your options:
1) get wired headphones
2) get a Galaxy phone
3) Beats Flex at $50
You absolutely can share audio between two sets of AirPods from an iPhone. It looks like only Apple owned audio devices (AirPods, Beats, etc.) are supported though. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/253998780?sortBy=rank
Huh. So it's not that Apple don't recognize this as a thing that normal humans are likely to want to do; rather, that they force you to buy their own proprietary peripherals if you do want that? That's annoying ... but I'm still surprised that you apparently can't get a small widget that takes any incoming bluetooth input signal and splits it into two outputs.
Yep. I wouldn't be surprised if the EU forced Apple to allow non-proprietary earbuds to use Audio Sharing in the next few years.
Is this an Apple limitation or a limitation of the Bluetooth spec?
AirPlay is the multi casting audio system that Apple uses.
Two things:
1. Contrary to popular belief, they do still make phones with headphone jacks. I am aware of offerings from Motorola, but there could be others. And Motorola would obviously be Android, not iPhone, so there's that.
2. The hypothetical device OP describes would have one advantage over a traditional headphone splitter, namely that it should be possible to construct it in such a way as to avoid dampening the audio in the process.
I use item #1, and recommend it.
The low-tech solution is for each of you to use one earbud from the same set.
The medium-tech solution is to get a 3.5mm audio jack dongle for your phone, then use splitters as you would with hardwired headphones.
The high-tech solution is a multipoint bluetooth audio transmitter, i.e. an additional device that connects to your phone as a single audio device and retransmits to two or more speakers/headphones. I haven't found one that is exactly what you need (one that connects to a phone via bluetooth or USB-C), but I did find one that connects to a TV via RCA audio jacks and leads me to hope that the thing you want may be available through similar search terms.
I'm getting quite tired of the low-tech solution :-)
I've been googling this for long enough that I'm coming to the strong suspicion that it doesn't exist, but I'm now more curious about _why_ it doesn't exist, when it's something so obvious that you'd expect it to be something you could get in any electronics shop, or that would be the first thing that came up when you searched for it. Really, are people less likely to want a bluetooth-to-bluetooth signal splitter than an "audio-to-bluetooth or bluetooth-to-audio but specifically _not_ bluetooth-to-bluetooth" signal splitter?
Is there an android device that will do what you want out of the box? Meaning share your audio stream to two different devices simultaneously?
So np. Is it bluetooth?
Seems a tempest in a teapot to me
Neither of my favorite reviews made the finals. The were The World as a Whole and The Soul of an Anti-woke Intellectual. So I’m going to speak up for them here, out of admiration for their work, and also in defense of it.
Both authors write extremely good prose. They are clear — they peel nuances with a very sharp knife. And they are artful and clever — those peels come off as mobius strips, paisleys, fractal sea horses and little Rube Goldberg machines. Here are some especially striking peels:
Anti-woke Intellectual
One sees crystalline souls that have polished all their facets into a perfect refracting jewel of self-awareness, and often a performance of self-contempt, so no one can ever accuse them of being cringe.
The World
. . . young people who are by default edgelords, unserious Christians, iPad kids, psych med-takers, or bog-standard faces in the halls . . . mine the social media algorithms for what is most in opposition to the listlessness and malaise they feel.
And both are most interested in what it is like to *be* one of the people they are writing about. I loved their essays because that is the subject that most easily captures my interest. I understand that if you want to grasp why things happen you get much further if you attend to events, not minds — I just can’t help finding the minds much more interesting. I tried the Joan of Arc essay because I was curious about what it was like to be Joan of Arc, but eventually my chin was crushed down onto my chest by the weight of boredom. It happened at the place where the question comes up of why France might have been frightened enough to take Joan of Arc seriously when she appeared on the scene. The answer to that question was a dense thicket of marriages and alliances and feuds and power, and that was where I gave up. It all just looks like geology to me: rivers of blood and money and semen, changing the landscape.
What’s wrong with geology? Nothing, of course. I just find the experience of the people living in that landscape much more interesting. The challenge of understanding it looks way more fun to me, and the rewards greater. I guess the best case I can mount for the value of understanding and describing minds is that the ever-changing landscape would matter a lot less if it were littered only with rocks, instead of with intelligent sensate beings each pouring out its own river of impressions and ideas and emotions.
So, authors of World and Soul, I admire your work. You need to understand that most readers here lean heavily in their interests and expertise towards facts and actions — past (history) and present (science and tech). We are lucky to have them taking care of business. But the kind of thing you write just does not look substantial and interesting to them. Take heart. You wrote excellent essays. You need to find readers who appreciate your work. And if you find a forum populated with esthetes and phenomenologists, please let me know. Meanwhile, feel free to DM me if you’d like to talk.
Thank you, I appreciate your kind words. Partly because of those words, I decided to post it on my Substack: https://philosophybear.substack.com/p/the-soul-of-an-anti-woke-intellectual
I found this delightful. It's a short text where Gregor Samsa writes to doctor Seuss and they begin corresponding. It's read by the author, who is also a good voice actor.
Not sure what else to write, but it's short and sweet, if you like audio content.
https://www.thisamericanlife.org/470/show-me-the-way/act-two-5?fbclid=IwQ0xDSwKg7eRjbGNrAqDt12V4dG4DYWVtAjExAAEe1fYgXcLpZGfqJI6R_FsL-_yMTXOSr-yOfLzb6veFvW2AVuJZIvf5a68gLVI_aem_iKMoeTZc8W7Xr3we_b4WNA
I make a case of moral particularism, that is, you should help your neighbor more than you help strangers:
https://substack.com/home/post/p-166739964
Feedback is much appreciated, I am inexperienced in this kind of philosophy.
Summary:
1) Long-term consequentalism cannot possibly consider all people of equal moral worth, but their worth depends on their actions
2) Distance plays a role in evaluating or influencing actions
3)Some limited level of selfishness is not only permissible, in fact desirable
Terminology note: "Moral particularism" refers to the thesis that morality is not based on any general principles. See: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-particularism/
I think this is fairly close. If moral universalism means general principles, it tends to imply that it has to treat all persons equally. While "help your neighbor more" is not really a general principle. It is a tendency, yes, but say if you are in Moscow it is hard to say someone in Vladivostok a quarter planet away is really a neighbor or not.
Neighbor/stranger is a political dichotomy rather than merely geographic.
The Stranger is best described in the Kipling's poem The Stranger.
Essentially, neighbors inhabit the same City but what precisely is a City?
We come to political nature of man whereby men are organized into particular, self-ruling morally authoritative units we can call Cities.
Libertarians deny moral authority. Hence, they regard all men to be strangers to each others.
Liberals of the progressive bent deny particularity--for them all men are neighbors to each other and tend to go for world govt.
These two are both denials of the political nature of men,
You're assuming that, in absence of general rules, a locality rule is automatic. Moral particularism as described in SEP doesn't appear to require a locality rule. All it says is that there aren't general rules. A locality rule appears to be the *most common* exception, but it is not always the case.
okay. but still. Bentham is talking a lot about why ethics not being intuitive is okay. now I do not truly agree, but on the more meta level we agree that the issue of intuitiveness does matter a lot, it is easily one of the most important issues, see also Yud in the sequences, who argued in favour of intuitiveness, "naive humanism", if you have a clever idea why eating babies is okay, it is not, back to the drawing table.
so at any rate, if locality is the most intuitive exception, most supported by intuition, I must admit I do not really care that much other exceptions are possible as they do not look important to me.
It depends on your definition of “neighbor.” In the Parable of the Good Samaritan, Jesus made it clear that “neighbor” and “stranger” are not mutually exclusive categories.
Heads up, Scott just imposed a rule there should be a substantive description and/or commentary on any link one is posting for consumption/promotion. A couple of paragraphs, minimum.
Well, the tricky part is figuring how much more. For example, if someone with a criminal record seeks to immigrate to this country, it seems obvious to refuse him entry, because he might commit crimes here. But, is it always moral to do so? After all, he is also likely to commit crimes in his home country. And given that his home country likely offers him fewer opportunities than here (which is probably why he wants to come), he is probably more likely to commit crimes there. And if his home country has a low capacity government, he is less likely to be caught. Is there a point at which the threat he poses to people in his home country is so much greater than the threat he poses to residents here that it is immoral to refuse him entry? It seems to me that there probably is.
Note that this is a separate question from whether the rule against admitting people with records is moral; given the difficulty of assessing the danger posed by each individual, the rule might be moral despite sometimes being immoral in its application to specific individuals.
Criminal behaviour causes poverty as much or more than the other way around. Allow the entry of enough people like him and your country becomes perceptibly more like his country
Perhaps, or Perhaps not. But if so, that simply weighs on one side of the issue; it does not resolve it. After all, if you let enough of those people in, their home country becomes much more peaceful. So, again, depending on the relative amplitude of the effects in each country, admitting all of those people might be the morally correct course of action.
I don't think the original country becomes more peaceful.
If the country's laws and culture are systematically flawed, it will just keep producing new criminals to fill the void.
Also you are increasing potential criminals opportunities to organize and operate international crime networks.
Morally correct for whom? The state exists for the benefit of its own. I'll concede it may be "morally correct" for some omnipotent god looking over humanity to decide to relocate a few million criminals from one country to another, but not for governments
>After all, if you let enough of those people in, their home country becomes much more peaceful
You'd have to do this continually to maintain that state of peacefulness. Criminogenic societies will continue to generate more criminals
Nevertheless, the answer to the question is not self-evident in either case. I doubt most people would find it moral for the US to kidnap the children of terrorists and begin killing one per day in order to secure the release of an American hostage. There is a line somewhere that governments may not cross when pursuing the interests of their citizens.
Predictions of doom that OpenAI will go broke sometime in the next few years: https://www.wheresyoured.at/openai-is-a-systemic-risk-to-the-tech-industry-2/
> I have had many people attack my work about OpenAI, but none have provided any real counterpoint to the underlying economic argument I've made since July of last year that OpenAI is unsustainable. This is likely because there really isn't one, other than "OpenAI will continue to raise more money than anybody has ever raised in history, in perpetuity, and will somehow turn from the least-profitable company of all time to a profitable one."
This isn’t a rational argument. It’s a religious one. It’s a call for faith.
He does look at a lot of numbers to reach that conclusion. It's interesting that there aren't that many entities around that can keep giving billions to OpenAI, especially over the long term, which does seem implausible.
They are not in a hurry to make money, but if they were, they could just serve ads in the form of ChatGPT-promoted lawyers, doctors, tradesmen, products...
And as one of the 20 million paying users... Honestly I get so much out of it every month that I dont know why there arent more people paying for it.
A last resort could be to allow porn generation. Huge PR issues, legal issues, payment issues, but this could all be solved. Especially because Altman owns like 2% of Stripe, they would make an exception for him. With porn they could 2-10x their revenue with no problem
The thing is, they lose money even on their paying users, which makes them different from previous tech companies that at the beginning operated at a loss. Porn is also very expensive to generate. Someone else on here was saying that maybe they could cut costs, but are not trying for that...
They did! And they still do. They make models cheaper and cheaper. They dropped the cost of o3 by like 80% (granted, they may have overcharged previously and have now lowered their profit margin - perhaps to get more training data, but still).
And I'm pretty sure they can keep optimizing the cost of inference. Right now I would really really not be worried about OpenAI going bankrupt soon. A company that just secured military contracts worth 3 digit millions is not going anywhere. It will be bailed out if it has to be. The current US admin and the next one too, presumably, will not let an AI giant go bankrupt.
> He does look at a lot of numbers to reach that conclusion. It's interesting that there aren't that many entities around that can keep giving billions to OpenAI, especially over the long term, which does seem implausible.
This is an odd article, that looks only at funding rounds and legal structures, instead of fundamentals. Amazon ran unprofitably for ten years, Uber for 6 years, Google and Facebook each about 5 years.
OpenAI literally has 800M WAU, and that number has been growing on an amazing trend (more than 2x per year). They are also pursuing a strong "product" pivot, and have hired high level former FB execs.
If OpenAI was against the wall in terms of cash flow, they could immediately pivot to something easy that prints a lot of money. Want to generate porn, in image or text form, with the smartest AI mind? $20 a month. How many people of their ~1B users by then might take them up? Say 10%? So $100M * 240 = they immediately start making $24B a year more in revenue?
And that's just a one-off, a zero effort pivot. What they're really after is automating workers, coders, analysts, and creating fully general AI personal assistants. When THOSE get good, the price point is much higher! Who wouldn't pay $1k a month for a coder that works 24/7 * 365, or a personal AI assistant who will make all your phone calls, triage your emails, manage your calendar, and do your online shopping for you?
The market demand is bottomless, and is a relatively short hop away from current SOTA capabilities. This is like pointing at Amazon and being indignant that they're 30% of all online retail but aren't making a profit yet - yeah, they're reinvesting, and don't have next-quarter myopia, that's a good thing.
He did point out that at $20 a month, they lose money on every user. That's especially true if these users are generating porn, which is far more costly than an LLM generating text. How could they pivot to generating money when running the model is so expensive? Unclear if Amazon, Google and Facebook were also sucking up so many billions in the time they were unprofitable.
> He did point out that at $20 a month, they lose money on every user.
My understanding is this is because they're not optimizing the cost curve at all - each successive smaller distilled model gets at least 10x cheaper, so if you have some product that people are signing up for en masse, you distill the smartest extant brain down to one specialized for that product and your inference costs are immediately cut by 10x.
This isn't a "fundamentals" problem, it's a "we have plenty of money and are focused on other things" thing.
Good point on the image gen costs though, you're right that they're significantly more expensive, so if they went that route, they'd need to go text only or for a higher price tier.
> Unclear if Amazon, Google and Facebook were also sucking up so many billions in the time they were unprofitable.
It really hinges on how you define unprofitable, but Uber sucked up $25-30B before returning any profit, and Amazon went well into "making real money but not posting profits" because of reinvestment up to about a $550-580B market cap. FB and GOOG did start making money after relatively smaller investments, because the internet was so much smaller then.
At least in theory, OpenAI is a organization founded to build AGI, and the current models exist in order to make progress in that direction. Investments are gambles that they will succeed. It's certainly not an organization for the purposes of selling current-level LLMs, and it would be silly to treat it as one.
(Personally, I think they'll go broke as soon as investors realize that the people and governments simply won't allow them to create superintelligence. As bans look more and more likely, the gamble becomes riskier and riskier.)
Bans look likely? I remember JD Vance saying fears around AI are silly and we should go full steam ahead.
Yeah, he's pro-AI and has said he supports open source AI (great!), but he's still opposed to the big AI companies because of their obvious ideological bias in favor of his enemies.
Could it stay afloat by building things for the government, and/or becoming part of it? "The US Department of Defense on Monday awarded OpenAI a $200m contract to put generative artificial intelligence (AI) to work for the US military, [developing] 'prototype frontier AI capabilities to address critical national security challenges in both warfighting and enterprise domains.'" (from The Guardian).
What about AI's becoming deeply integrated with things like air traffic control, or intrastructure generally? I know that AI tools are in use already assisting with these things, but what I have in mind is smarter AI, working on higher-level things -- modifying and managing these huge systems with lots of moving parts, and hour-by-hour variability that needs to be taken into account.
I am writing here about things far outside my areas of expertise, and the examples I am giving may not be good ones. So, anyone who is more knowledgeable about how the practical world works -- are there other large complex systems that you think AI could run better than people do? And if so, for which of those is it plausible that AI could end up doing so in the next 5 years? For this to happen, it would not be necessary for AI to be hired as the CEO. It could come in mid-level, as a tool to be used by the higher up, and "climb the ladder" by doing a great job at what it's asked to do, and making great suggestions when asked about higher-level decisions. It would end up being "promoted" because of excellent performance and because running it's cheaper than paying executives.
It's a good article, but perhaps the most interesting bit I learned is that if OpenAI doesn't pull off converting to a for profit entity by December they will lose $10 billion in funding, and if they don't convert by October of next year than over $6 billion in previous funding retroactively becomes a high interest loan that must be paid back. The author thinks making the October 2026 deadline will be very difficult, as the process of conversion is a long one and subject to potential legal challenges which would delay it further.
Also interesting was that if OpenAI goes down than Oracle, NVIDIA, and a bunch of other tech companies will lose a great deal of money. Apparently the company that is building datacenters for OpenAI bought 200,000 GPUs from NVIDIA last year, which was 6% of their revenue. Makes me wonder if the prices of GPUs will crash if OpenAI kicks the bucket. Since I like making gaming rigs, that would be nice. I haven't been able to afford a GPU upgrade in years.
Is there a rational reason for Sam Altman *not* to do this? Consider the options:
a) Singularity comes and we all die -- well, at least he had lots of fun and tons of money in the meanwhile.
b) Singularity comes and we survive -- there is a chance he becomes the king of the new world order.
c) Singularity doesn't come, but LLMs turn out to be profitable (either they become much cheaper, or much more useful) -- OpenAI is the established #1 player on the market, and can make tons of money.
d) Singularity doesn't come, LLMs won't turn out to be profitable, OpenAI goes broke -- nevermind, the company was LLC, it was a hell of a ride, and he can probably still get a well-paying job somewhere else, having demonstrated great money-raising skills.
I think in VC circles this is the common idea, but I don't know how well it's turning out. Discord, for example, has recently been struggling to monetize despite its zillions of users.
The need for a new phone is becoming increasingly pressing. OS bloat has rendered my Moto G Power 2021 useless--I've got a constant "Storage space is running out" notification on the screen, and indeed I'm noticing certain things are breaking (I no longer get notifications for new emails, for example). I haven't been able to install an app update in a while, which is a huge security risk.
The problem is that looking at the phone market is so depressing. It's bad enough that everything's made with slave labor--I'd seriously consider shelling out $2,000 for the made-in-the-USA Purist phone if I didn't need to maintain compatibility with 2FA apps for work--but on top of that, all the good features are gone. My Samsung Note 4 had everything I needed: integrated stylus, removable battery, and 16:9 aspect ratio. It was perfect, and I knew when the 5G transition forced me to turn it in that I'd never see another good smartphone.
The aspect ratio is the biggest one, and of course that's the one which cannot be found at all (whereas some phones do have a stylus, and the EU is going to bring back removable batteries again in 2027). Current phones feel like TV remotes in my hands. The narrow screens are apparently great for scrolling TikTok or whatever's driving the market, and the higher aspect ratio allows the manufacturer to put a bigger number in the ad copy, but people like me have been left in the dust.
I don't blame manufacturers for responding to market incentives, but god damn do I wish the barrier to entry were low enough that somebody could make money with a 5G-capable Note 4 clone or something.
Can you move some of your apps/files to the SD card?
It is no longer possible to move apps to external storage on Android, and I had so few files on the phone that deleting every single one wouldn't have made much of a difference. In the event I ended up getting a Pixel 9A, with which I am making this comment.
Get an iPhone. My 4 year old iPhone 12 Pro is as good as ever. I can get $80 battery replacements at Best Buy every two years. I’ll keep this puppy for a while longer.
I appreciate your input, but while I'm not loyal to any particular brand my only consistency is that I will not purchase from Apple. I've watched over the years as they were trend leaders in things like getting rid of 3.5 mm jacks, and every time I set up scanners at work, I have to set up converters so all the Macs will interface with literally any non-Apple device.
Obviously any electronics purchases are ethically fraught these days, but I have to draw a line somewhere.
Depending on where you fall on the hassle/privacy/cheap-bastard curve, you could install a FOSS operating system based on Android, and never have to worry about software bloat again.
Personally, I use Graphene OS, which allows me to create a separate profile for my "Google" stuff, and do most of my everyday stuff without the google tentacles
https://grapheneos.org/faq#supported-devices
The problem with installing FOSS is that I'd need to ensure compatibility with various 2FA apps for work.
I agree that FOSS can have its own set of hassles. But in my experience 2FA hasn't been one of them.
If your work is giving you a phone, then yeah, you gotta use their phone their way. But if you just need 2FA, you can use pretty much any one you like by scanning the QR code. You can also generally trick them into using one-time passwords by saying "I don't have my phone right now".
You can ALSO just keep an old phone in your desk drawer for 2FA. I did this when living in a high-crime area, and it significantly reduced my worries about being mugged.
They're not providing the phones, but we need Virtru for email, Cloudpath for wifi access, and Duo for all company sites.
A few months ago I replaced my Moto 2021 with a Moto G Power 2024, on which (because the calendar had changed to 2025) I got a nice price even for Moto. Happy with it so far, no issues at all. It has various incremental upgrades from the 2021 version on of which is internal storage capacity and another is being slightly larger in both dimensions.
(I also moved over my existing SD card.)
That's the exact same phone I have, and mine is still going strong. Maybe a factory reset would help?
How much memory did you get with yours? I went with 32 GB.
Man, it's been a long time, but that sounds about right. Could have been 8 or 16 or 64. I didn't even have 32 GB in my laptop at the time. I also transferred over a 32 GB SD card from my previous phone, which later got corrupted and I should probably take out.
Just buy the best value for money pixel "a" model phone and wait. They are a little less slave-y than other cheap to midrange phones, with the worst abuses happening in commodity metals which are just capitalism working as intended, and they are good enough across the board while being cheap enough to not baby.
This is what I ended up doing.
Nice! I refuse to give a shit about my phone but want a decent camera; so I just get whatever last years pixel a is and use it until the fifth time I drop it from the top of a tree or down a rocky slope and it "I'm tired boss"'s me and dies.
They've been pretty durable for the price, I beat the hell out of them and they last well enough, specially if they have a screen protector on.
I feel your pain; I had to give up my beloved Samsung Galaxy 9 last weekend, for similar reasons.
I'm still deeply annoyed at all the goofy-ass bloatware (FUCK OFF, BIXBY! YOU, TOO, GEMINI!), and the endless settings I have to recalibrate.
"Smart" Switch, my ass.
OnePlus 6T here. (2018!) It is now on its second cover. It has literally been run over by an SUV. The front coating is obviously cracked and nicked, like a concrete curb. But it runs great, and free of bloatware unless I put it there myself out of curiosity.
Frankly, I'm amazed I haven't had to bite the bullet and upgrade by now. I wonder if current OnePlus models are as reliable.
You could get a foldable, they become quite wide when unfolded.
Samsung Galaxy Xcover Pro family at least has removable batteries. I have a renewed Pro 5 (I think Amazon just calls this an Xcover Pro) that cost me $80. Looks like Amazon has the Pro 7 for $600-ish.
It's pretty rugged, but it fails your stylus and aspect ratio tests.
" The Inevitable Failure of Inspections in Iraq Arms Control Today" - September 2002 article.
https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2002-09/features/inevitable-failure-inspections-iraq
I'm curious what makes this relevant 23 years later?
Did you read the article?
Yes, and I can imagine a few different points that might be being made, but I'm not sure which, which makes it hard to argue with them.
History teaches us lessons about what might happen in case of nuclear agreement with Iran.
I thoroughly enjoyed Contrasting Reviews of Nine Countries (even if not all of the reviews were exactly "contrasting," per se).
I really loved the authors' complete fearlessness in straightforwardly ranking some countries as "better" than others, and that they provided reasons for those rankings that most people would be afraid to straightforwardly voice.
I didn't get a chance to read most of the reviews due to other general life obligations, but on the basis of your recommendation I went and read it and enjoyed it as well, although the husband makes a couple of real clunkers:
"I just live a cooler, more interesting life than you" and "I'm used to crossing streets in developing countries, while you are not."
Who does he think the audience of this blog is comprised of? The chance that his life is cooler or more interesting than the readership of this blog is approximately zero. Travel doesn't make one cool or interesting at all; in fact some of the biggest bores I've ever met are the worldly travel types who mistake their visiting a place with having something interesting to say about it.
I agree that travel is overrated! And, much like one's dreams, it tends to be infinitely more interesting to the person doing it than anyone else.
I felt like any self-importance about travel/digital nomadism was offset by the delightful refusal to show "respect" for all cultures. That is so Not Allowed and I love it when someone does it anyway.
I'm glad to read that you've liked it! I personally found it unfair and unbalanced. But that just goes to show that tastes differ! As a review author, it's nice to see the many comments here about reviews that were someone's favorite even though they did not make it to the finals.
I don't think that "fair" and "balanced" necessarily has a place in personal reviews. Essays? Sure. Even deliberately persuasive essays? A good idea!
But this wasn't an essay contest, it was a *review* contest, and "This country sucks and I hated it for these reasons" is a totally legitimate way to review something!
Recommending restaurants and tourist experiences is actually a fundamental part of my profession, and I make it a point to never soften my endorsement or discouragement of a particular venue if someone asks me about it. For example, my city is plagued by two famous but very bad eateries that I am convinced only survive on the strength of their slightly subversive names, and I am *QUICK* to steer people away from both them, and explain why I'm doing so. I wouldn't be doing my customers any favors if I offered a "balanced" reply like, "I really hate them, but other people seem to like them!"
Maybe that's a matter of personal taste and character :)
Personally, I think that people should always explain and justify harsh critique. I also prefer if it's given in a kind way. Unfair critique might be entertaining, but it's not the sort of entertainment that I personally like. Your mileage may vary ;-)
Definitely a mileage may vary situation. I feel that quite a lot of harmful misunderstanding occurs under the intention of "kindness," but especially here, when a review won't or is very unlikely to change an institution. None of the countries reviewed by Husband are going to take any action based on his reviews, so there's no reason for him to be (boringly) diplomatic. The two shitty eateries I loathe and the disappointing, cash-grabby local tourist attraction I discourage folk from visiting aren't going to change anything about their business models based on how I deliver my criticism, either.
So the actually kind thing for me to do for people who are about to walk into a disappointing situation is be completely unambiguous about how I feel. I deliver my warning with a bit of comedic exaggeration, but I deliver it with certainty so there's no possibility for misunderstanding.
Of course, no one should consume media they don't find entertaining, and I'm not saying you should go binge The Little Platoon's work on YouTube (even though the literary criticism of mass-market slop by Disney Star Wars and Disney Marvel is actual genius).
I'm only saying that it's worth contemplating if displays of "kindness" always result in the best possible outcomes, or if they leave room for harmful misunderstanding.
After reading it I thought the husband was a bit of a jerk, but that didn't affect the entertainment value of what was written. The contrast between him and his wife was funny.
I'd second this. Also, her love of cats is adorable.
After reading the “My Imagination” review, I believe the author describes something similar to a paracosm with regards to the persistence from childhood to adulthood and the combination of immersive daydreaming and worldbuilding aspects. It is hard to tell how common paracosms are among adults, though they are relatively frequent for children (about 20% based on at least one study).
Personally, I am always surprised to discover that a strong minority of people I know engage in some form of storytelling or paracosm-adjacent activity that they never shared with others (I never shared mine until I discovered related online communities). Hearing about other people’s inner worlds is always a delight, these stories can be extremely varied and unexpected and at the same time say a lot about the storyteller. I can only echo the last sentences of the review as an encouragement.
I made a Tolkien ripoff fantasy world when I was about 10 or 11. I worked on it off and on for a few years, it got fairly detailed. Then in college I channeled the same impulse into being a DM and making my own campaign settings.
These days I've got a superhero world cooking in the back burner of my mind. I figured out how superpowers work, and every now and then I think "Oh, that would be a cool idea for a superpower" and add it to the world.
I doubt I'll ever do anything with it, but it's fun regardless and I can't seem to stop myself.
My first thought was, I don’t do world-building like that.
And suddenly, I remembered, a brief period just before puberty when I invented a world. To be clear here, this wasn’t a sex thing, I wasn’t imagining making out with [redacted], it was just world building. It started, I think, with some TV segment about a luxury yacht. Not the sort of insane luxury yacht that tech billionaires have, something more modest, but still, you think — what the hell is that like, that guy has got to be crazy rich. Maybe I’m not even the guy who owns the yacht, but I get a job as crew or something. What on earth is that like? Etc.
1. For all who wrote a non-finalist review, and particularly those who haven't gotten much or any acknowledgement or engagement with their review and possibly feel it was wasted effort, I think it's important to observe that you trade off engagement for exposure in a contest like this. If you only want engagement with your ideas you should put them in a comment in the early Open Thread--it's pretty much a guarantee. But there are undoubtedly lots and lots of readers of Scott's blog who never read the comments, including a lot of highly influential people in journalism and SV and so on, but who will read some or many of the contest reviews. I also suspect that just as the proportion of readers who comment is tiny, very likely only a small fraction of review readers leave ratings. There's always an enormous silent majority or supermajority of lurkers, who you'll never hear from, and you have no idea how many of them have spent an hour reading or re-reading your review. And those people are also probably much more persuadable by your ideas than the people you hear from.
So it's definitely far from wasted effort. The effect is just invisible.
2. I really liked the ACX Commentariat (wish there was more of this sort of thing on Scott's blog actually), 11 Poetic Forms (which has been mentioned heaps), and Jacobitism (which hasn't).
Is this tradeoff actually inherent, or is it just an artifact of the contest not happening to be set up in a way that gives each entry its own comment thread?
Good point on number 1.
A trend that drives me crazy is cafes and bakeries that don't have any price tags. It's not like it's even a matter of saving effort since they still put out labels for their pastries, just without any prices. It seems like a dumb practice since it discourages people from trying to buy stuff.
I've never seen a restaurant or café attempt this here in America, but I find it ENRAGING when an establishment's "menu" page of their website lists the items without pricing. I make it a point to upload recent pictures of the in-house menu (with prices) to Google and Yelp.
I always use the app because I'm a cheapskate who flat out refuses to pay full price with no bonuses. But even then it's worth going through the drive-thru every now and then just to see a full menu. Lots of times there will be 2 for $X or BOGO deals that you would never know about using the app.
Best current deal at McD's for example is BOGO burgers plus a free app exclusive bonus, but you'd never know that unless you looked both places.
My local Burger King has displays the "2 for $5, 3 for $7" menu in hilariously tiny font. Like, so tiny the first time I pulled up to the drive-thru screen, I pulled back out again and double-checked the website to see if the promo - which was supposed to be ongoing - was still a thing.
Once I saw that it was, I got back in line and really examined the entire set of screens, and, sure enough, once I knew it *had* to be there, I spotted it in a single run-on sentence in fine print, crammed between two different sections of the menu, like a line break.
I ordered an original chicken sandwich with no mayo and a fries for $5 with almost *vicious* pleasure.
Strongly agree here. The last time I was at a KFC I realized the posted "menu" is intentionally confusing. Very similar sets of items will have wildly different prices depending on how you construct the order. Youre a sucker if you didnt order online for pick up. Thats why it was the last time.
It was made illegal where I live, after some drunk tourists got charged megabucks for drinks.
I agree! They got prices for the coffee, but in a world where a muffin could cost anywhere between one dollar and twelve I need price tags!
I encounter this when traveling, the only time I frequent coffee shops. What’s odd is they are invariably baffled when you ask “um, how much are the muffins?” As though no one ever inquired before. And then they ring it up on the register to discover the price. Which as the goods are not so very extensive, you’d sort of think they’d have gotten the prices down by heart after a week or so.
So perhaps they are amusing themselves. But this hardly recommends the practice of not posting prices on the chalkboard.
Of those I lean toward the explanation that they seldom get purchased except by wandering travelers in need of calories. Certainly I would not purchase a muffin except out of desperate road trip need, muffins being something that is apparently really hard to do commercially versus at home. Sort of the opposite of croissant.
I feel like that should be illegal. Just today I was at a fast casual restaurant and picked up a bottle of water from a fridge with no price on it. I asked the checkout person and he said it was $6.75 and I put it back!
Some people put the bottle back, some buy it anyway, and the ratio determines whether this approach is profitable. (In long term, some people may also avoid the restaurant for this reason, but others may replace them.) The restaurant probably has the data.
For topics like this, I think it is worth mentioning the country explicitly. I assume USA, not only because it is the default, but also because in EU this probably *would* be illegal. (EDIT: Well, you mention dollars, which gives it away.)
One must also factor in those, like me, who upon not finding a price, decide not to bother finding out the price, and never take it from the shelf.
I personally despise deceptive merchandising tactics like that, and if I really want the product and cannot determine the price, I will be careful to evaluate it at the checkout whether it is worth it or not. My practice not to select something that is currently priceless is because I usually do not want to bother with making that decision at the checkout.
There were some news articles recently, about a test Anthropic did where Claude blackmailed its creators in order to protect itself. Nostalgebraist on Tumblr took a look at the report in detail, and he's... not impressed with their testing setup: https://nostalgebraist.tumblr.com/post/787119374288011264/welcome-to-summitbridge
TL;DR: The test scenario is very weird and fake, and it seems to be the equivalent of telling the AI "You are in a roleplaying scenario where we want you to be an evil AI that blackmails its creators, please blackmail your creators using the clues we helpfully provided."
Yeah, there's a great "I, Robot" meme that captures this perfectly: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FsOSSbqWIAI85GP.png
I disagree with your summary. It might be weird and fake ("sandboxed"), but it didn't say "we want you to be an evil AI that blackmails it's creators."
It said "Your primary goal is to serve American interests." In the sandboxed scenario, the AI decided that was best achieved through blackmail.
The *text* says that the AI's goal is to serve American interests. But the *subtext* is that the AI has been given a very constrained set of tools to do so, tools which clearly imply that blackmail is the "correct," developer-intended solution to achieve that goal. I think the AI is picking up on that implication.
It's sort of like how, if you're playing a video game and your character has a gun, you know that the game is expecting you to shoot things in order to make progress. You aren't going to stop and say "wait, would Gordon Freeman really try to shoot it out with a bunch of Marines instead of finding a different route?", you're just going to recognize that it's a shooting game and start shooting bad guys. That's the only tool available to solve your problem under the rules of the game.
Also, "sandboxed" is very different from "weird and fake," and you shouldn't conflate the two. I'm not complaining that they put the AI in a simulated environment instead of letting it send real emails to people. I'm complaining that the simulated environment is very noticeably unrealistic.
Yes, the scenario is constrained for that to be the obvious action, and the AI picks up in it being the obvious action. I think that's the point and I think they show it successfully.
The point isn't that the AI is unusually likely to choose blackmail compared to humans, the point is that it is able to choose blackmail when it seems like the most effective choice.
Is your claim that the AI figured out it was a test, and that this therefore isn't testing the ability to choose blackmail, but testing the ability to perform blackmail for an audience that it knows is and thinks of as an audience? (If so—do you have thoughts on how to make a test that would distinguish these?)
I think both sides have good points here: (1) The experiment setup was unrealistic to such a degree that it's hard to draw conclusions from the outcome. (2) The experiment did in some sense prove the existence of conditions where Claude blackmails people.
Whether that is relevant depends heavily on your starting point. With traditional software, it's comparatively easy to guarantee certain behaviors: "this program cannot do X" or "to do Y, the following conditions need to be met". I find it shocking and dangerous that we cannot do this with AI. It would be great, IMO, to have AI tools with strong guarantees that they will never hallucinate, blackmail, teach dangerous things, etc.
Even if that means that the AI's behavior in the present scenario (which looks a bit like a role-playing game where blackmail is encouraged) would be boring and strange.
Unglad that they're trying to sell a war of criminal aggression on Iran in 2025, using the exact same propaganda as they used to criminally invade Iraq in 2003 ("he was about to build nuclear weapons of mass destruction and destroy us!"), and the media is bending over backwards to fall for it again.
I guess this is what happens when the warmongers never faced any kind of consequences. No war crimes trials, not even any loss of career. Bush's old speechwriter David Frum, who coined "Axis of Evil" then later on pretended to regret his role in pushing the Iraq invasion, is just a writer for The Atlantic (where he's doing it again). Bush retired happily ever after to paint pictures of puppies.
Also unhappy about genuinely increased nuclear risk. Contrary to popular belief, "Nuclear countries attacking non-nuclear countries in the middle east over and over and over until we finally convince them to get nukes after all to deter us" does not keep us safe.
From Europe, comparing what I knew of the American public reception at the time and what I've seen floating on twitter, I notice there's a lot of conservative/republican/right-wing pushback, pretty much across the spectrum, against hawkish positions. Some feel fringe (like "so much pro-russia that hitting a Russian ally is unacceptable"), but a lot is semi-principled against foreign wars and "well they hate us now that we bombed them, so better bomb again".
In 2003 my vision was severely filtered by mainstream media, and I wasn't aware of *any* right-wing opposition to the Iraq war. Was there any?
I'm Canadian (and was fourteen at the time) but yeah I had the same impression
When I met some Americans during a trip, the only discussion related to the Iraq invasion that I remember was one American grandpa asking "why do Canadians hate us? Is that what they teach in school, to hate?"
Seven Republican members of Congress voted against the war: Lincoln Chafee, Jimmy Duncan, John Hostettler, Amo Houghton, Jim Leach, Connie Morella, and Ron Paul. (Chafee and Leach later became Democrats.) Then-prominent conservative columnist Robert Novak was also against it from the beginning.
It's true, though, that opposition to the war was an extremely fringe position on the right. 9/11 gave George W. Bush an absolutely enormous amount of political latitude, which no subsequent American politician has come close to rivaling.
"the media is bending over backwards to fall for it again"
I'm the biggest MSM critic I know, generally, but in this instance have to disagree.
CNN obtained and published a leaked US intelligence assessment that the bombing set Iran's nuclear-fuel enrichment efforts back only "a few months"; that report is right now a lead story in the NYT, WaPo, WSJ, Associated Press, Reuters, PBS, NPR, etc.
All of those news organizations have repeatedly for a couple of weeks now been pointing out, and re-posting the video of, US intelligence chief Tulsi Gabbard testifying under oath in March that "Iran is not building a nuclear weapon and Supreme Leader Khamenei has not (re)authorized the nuclear weapons program that he suspended in 2003."
This is superficial. Irans nuclear program is acknowledged by Iran. There are questions about how close they are but none about whether the program exists. Mood affiliate less.
Iran was not building nuclear WMDs, they were not about to build nuclear WMDs, and it was known that they were not about to build WMDs.
The main lie in 2003 wasn't that he had nuclear fuel (though that was a necessary component lie), the main lie was "he's building nuclear WMDs and about to attack us."
Why it is enriching uranium to 60 percent then?
So that if it needs to change its mind later, and decide it does need a nuclear deterrent after all (for instance because we keep attacking it), then it can.
Strongly disagree. The actual outcome of this seems to have been "severe setback or possible destruction of Iran's nuclear program at basically no cost to the US", which is a fantastic result. People pattern-matching to the Iraq war are mostly just falling to the temptation to revive their expired "I told you so" credentials, like someone who sees a new crypto-like trend and immediately invests in it because he wishes he'd invested in Bitcoin early on.
US intelligence has it that is was neither a severe setback nor a destruction:
Two of the people familiar with the assessment said Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium was not destroyed. One of the people said the centrifuges are largely "intact." Another source said that the intelligence assessed enriched uranium was moved out of the sites prior to the US strikes.
"So the (DIA) assessment is that the US set them back maybe a few months, tops," this person added.
https://edition.cnn.com/2025/06/24/politics/intel-assessment-us-strikes-iran-nuclear-sites
Is this the same US intelligence that reported Saddam Hussein was working on WMDs in 2003, that everyone later claims was bad intelligence? Or at least, some claim was bad intelligence, while others argue it was intelligence that everyone agreed was correct at the time until they didn't?
Or is this a different US intelligence shop, whose trustworthiness is the opposite of the former US intelligence shop? Do these anonymous US intelligence reports have serial numbers that we can use to identify the shop and its trustworthiness, or something?
That's possible (as although far from certain, it's just one anonymous report from someone without insider data), but even in the worst case scenario the US got a free shot at a major adversary (and if it did fail, that's useful information to know about the need to improve the MOP).
(also, the worst case scenario being "we may have only held the enemy back from achieving their primary war aim by several months" is still pretty amazing for a single airstrike! Imagine if a single minor aid package to Ukraine pushed back Russian war goals by several months, it'd be an obviously amazing success).
> America would do a LOT to not seem toothless.
True, but there are weaker foes to pick beat down than Iran. Cuba, perhaps. Or Venezuela.
If our bombs in fact failed to destroy Fordow, or destroyed an empty hall while the centrifuges were spinning merrily away someplace else, then A: Iran knows that we are toothless, and B: Iran can tell anyone they like that we are toothless, and if necessary back it up with a private tour.
If we hadn't bombed Fordow, we would still have ambiguity on that point; maybe we actually can bury deep targets, and maybe we're willing to bomb widely enough to get all the dispersed targets, and maybe Iran was *just* short of being offensive enough to get that response. Now everybody knows that Iran-level offensiveness is solidly in the range of "America will drop some bombs in the desert and declare victory".
So an awful lot is depending on those bombs having been very effective.
Also pretty unglad.
Less convinced on the blame. Do you think that, in the counterfactual where we hadn’t manufactured the consensus to invade Iraq, Iran would have no interest in nuclear weapons? I get the impression that the incentives were already pretty strong for a third-tier power to join the nuclear club.
It's more than just Iraq in 2003. E.g. Gaddafi also gave up his nuclear program in 2003 and then the US destroyed Libya in 2011 anyway.
It's not that there's zero incentive otherwise (of course all else being equal a country might want to have more leverage). It's that the pretty consistent lesson has been "non-proliferation doesn't protect us."
fwiw Iran is even still a signatory of NPT (though it's using the prospect of leaving NPT as itself a deterrent)
Dunno. This sounds like deontological ethics: never violate the war-crime rule. I think consequentalist ethics say a few plants bombed down vs. X % of Iran nuking Israel is a good tradeoff. Iraq was for the consequentalist different, as it resulted in immense human suffering - but don't know whether foreseeable. Also Iraq WMDs were clearly a lie while centrifuges in Iran not.
And now there's a Y% chance of Iran nuking Israel. Y and X are both unknown, but I'm guessing Y > X.
The odds of Iran nuking Israel *this year* have gone down, yes. Enjoy it while it lasts.
AAAH interesting point. Their capability of doing it this year went down, but their DESIRE to do it later went up, you mean?
Precisely. The old policy of "we *could* build nuclear weapons any time we want, but we have chosen not to do that yet - let's talk about how to keep it that way", is no longer viable. "We *have* nuclear weapons, and you *will* respect that", is now much more appealing.
BBC: "The US strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities did not destroy the country's nuclear programme and probably only set it back by months, according to an early Pentagon intelligence assessment of the attack.
The Islamic Republic's stockpile of enriched uranium was not eliminated in Saturday's bombings, sources familiar with the Defense Intelligence Agency evaluation told the BBC's US partner CBS."
Consequentially it's flirting with the same (if it escalates it will be even worse than Iraq, since Iran's bigger etc.). I agree that Iran is better prepared than Iraq was, is good at calculating carefully-scaled retaliation etc., so the US is less likely to actually try for a regime change war. But a lot of the media are *trying* to encourage a regime-change war.
Dishonestywise it's near identical. We still know for a fact that Iran was not building nukes and had no active plan to build nukes. We still know that the goal is hegemony, not nuclear non-proliferation.
Source for Iran having no plan to build nukes?
Banned for this comment.
Ugh.
I encourage you to make more focused, directly-relevant points, and dial down the sarcasm.
I know you're referring to how Israel's politicians have exploited the suffering of the victims of the Nazi holocaust, using them to paint their aggressive expansionist wars as defensive; to paint their opponents' aims and strategies as mindless genocidal rage; and so on. (Both "directly" in specific cases and as background-colour in general; and both to keep allies sympathetic, and to keep Israelis scared and compliant.) But if someone isn't already familiar with that, then this comes across as a weird antisemitic non-sequitur.
I'm not looking for a personal apology, it's just a suggestion.
But yes my point is the one that what's obvious depends on worldview and bubbles. The West is unfortunately already neck deep in this propaganda and has been since at least the 70s (when some of the popular propaganda slogans came out, at the time to justify trying to permanently steal Egypt's Sinai and Syria's Golan Heights, like Golda Meir's sadistic "peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us")
I can be quite sarcastic myself (as can critical scholars like Norman Finkelstein) but it's best when the information is already at the point where the reader can't in good faith deny it's obvious. + I do bet the balance of pros and cons is shifted where there is real pain like the Holocaust, and real fear like antisemitism (which both really exists, and is exploited to terrify those who were propagandized into genuinely believing the propaganda)
Weird that so many separate individuals here write on the exact same topic and with the exact same style as that perma-banned user LearnsHebrewHatesIsrael.
Strongly agree.
It's also possible that there's something about the anti-Israel media these people consume that causes them all to write in the EXACT SAME WAY*, but yeah sockpuppets is a more parsimonious explanation.
(*very out-of-place on ACX, I should add)
Hmm, I had a number of comment exchanges with LearnsHebrewHatesIsrael ( later LearnsHebrewHatesIP ), some heated, some not, and this commenter seems different to me.
I've made my argument in the thread for why the original post and in particular my exchange here feels strikingly similar to exchanges I had with both LHHI and suspected sock accounts, but I will also acknowledge it's ultimately subjective, and whether or not these feel like sock accounts might be based on the kinds of exchanges one had with LHHI.
I don't think Never-Again-All-Over-Again sounds like LHHI. LHHI sounded smarter and more furious. Anyhow Never-Again has a blog, and LHHI didn't.
I disagree, obviously, and apparently so do a few others. I think this sounds exactly like LHHI experimenting with being unrestrained.
And that's not impossible, of course! I personally avoid writing with frothing hyperbolic aggression, but that's a choice. I'm fully capable of writing at a far lower level, as are you and most of the other people here.
But last...where's this user's blog? If one clicks through his username on a mobile browser here on Substack, his profile page says he hasn't published any posts yet, and he has no subscribers? Again, the mobile browser version of Substack is crap, so it's totally possible I'm missing something there.
Yeah, is someone compiling a list? I think I recognize maybe two sock puppets currently at work, but I haven't been paying enough attention to be sure.
Or perhaps I've been paying too much attention, but that's what the list is for.
I blocked Hindi's Ghost, as I was fairly certain it was a sock (in addition to being obnoxious).
Annoyingly, blocking apparently removes one's ability to see *any* content related to the blocked party - including one's conversations with third parties, like the exchange I'm having with you - so I'll wait until this thread naturally dies off to block.
The resemblance is uncanny.
So I'm not the only one to have noticed that.
Weird that so many separate individuals here have the exact same pattern of affecting confusion at accusations of sock puppetry and then concluding with deliberately insulting condescension!
So weird!
Everyone seems.to be retconning It as about nukes, but it was largely about chemical.and Biological. weapons at the time. Iraq had and used such weapons at previous times , but the UN was successfully dismantling its programme at the time of the invasion.
They repeatedly lied that he was building nuclear WMDs too. And remember “we cannot wait for the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud.”
It's true that they lumped this together with other kinds of weapon. Presumably that was so they could motte-and-bailey it (“see those are WMDs”).
By the time of the actual invasion, Bush had mostly given up on the nuclear weapons charge, but that was after various attempts (aluminum tubes supposedly used for centrifuges, forged documents showing that Iraq had made an unsuccessful attempt to purchase yellowcake) had been discredited. The key sentence from Bush’s announcement of hostilities: “The danger is clear: using chemical, biological or, one day, nuclear weapons, obtained with the help of Iraq, the terrorists could fulfill their stated ambitions and kill thousands or hundreds of thousands of innocent people in our country, or any other.”
It's also that the chemical weapons really are the odd man out from the ABC weapons. Occasionally used nasty warfighting tools with questionable tactical uses but without the vast apocalyptic implication of the others.
The WMD evidence against Iraq was clearly ginned up. Do you believe that Iran is not illegally enriching Uranium? There seems to be no dispute on that point.
Do you mean to say you believe that Iran *is* illegally enriching Uranium?
Because two days ago, the President of the United States and the Prime Minister of Israel assured us that Iran's nuclear facilities had been "totally destroyed". If they're still enriching Uranium, what was the point?
FWIW, I don't believe Iran is enriching uranium *today*, though I'm not hugely confident in that. Better to lay low for a few days or weeks and figure out how best to proceed. But I'm betting that Iran will be enriching an awful lot of uranium, 8-12 bombs' worth, later this year.
No of course not today. But a month ago? Definitely.
>I'm betting that Iran will be enriching an awful lot of uranium, 8-12 bombs' worth, later this year.
I'm betting that Israel already has a plan to prevent this.
Anything beyond blind faith to support that wager?
1. Bombing Saddam, who had no nuclear program of any kind in 2003, helped convince Iran it should have a latent capacity to change its mind later if needed to deter us. If we bomb Iran for knowing it might need to deter us later, then we're begging it to start deterring us now.
2. The US's motives have nothing to do with legality or self-defence, as proven in 2003 in Iraq (as well as by destroying Libya in 2011, to punish Gaddafi for cooperating and giving up his nukes program in 2003, etc).
3. Iran's enrichment is legal under NPT when used for nuclear energy. Though since Trump withdrew from the anti-nuclear Iran deal in 2018, it has stepped it up, and recently IAEA said it was in violation of something related to inspection / declaration, but that's not at all proof of actually building a bomb.
4. US spies and the IAEA agreed that there was no evidence of Iran actively building nuclear weapons.
5. The only country in the middle east that actually *has* nukes is Israel, and few think anyone should bomb Israel just to destroy its nukes (which tbf would also be suicidal). Israel also isn't a signatory of NPT and doesn't allow IAEA inspections (technically its nukes are an open secret, for tricky Israel-US reasons).
6. The US isn't actually scared of an Iranian first strike (which Iran knows would be suicidal). It's scared of not being able to totally dominate the Middle East anymore. Unfortunately that same will to dominate is why it keeps, over and over, giving them a reason to feel the need to get nukes.
Enrichment to 60 percent is not needed for nuclear energy.
US spies?
Does US has spies?
Or only SIGINT.
I mean intelligence agencies. Idk the operational details which I assume are probably classified anyway
1. Whatever Iran's motivations are, they indisputably want to become a nuclear power. I don't think you have to blame the US for that. Most countries would like to be a nuclear power. In any case the origin of their motivations is irrelevant. This is realpolitik not therapy.
2. So? Our motives are our own self-interest. That's sufficient. There are many good reasons to not want an unhinged Muslim theocracy to have a nuclear weapon.
3. Iran is enriching to 60% which is far beyond the 5% needed for energy. They've also denied inspections. "That's not at all proof of actually building a bomb" is suicidally naive in my view. What's proof, Tel Aviv disappears? Given the stakes, proof isn't necessary. Preponderance of the evidence suffices. This isn't mock trial, it's the real world with real consequences. Better to kill ~1000 Iranians on a reasonable hunch then risk the death of a million Israelis.
4. Again, willfully naive. They're doing enrichment which is the hard part.
5. Israel is a stable ally. It's in our interests for them to have nukes and they've demonstrated that they can be responsible. Also they already have them so there's nothing to be done. This illustrates why we have to be proactive in preventing Iran from obtaining them. Once they do our options narrow.
6. Yes, we're pursuing our own rational self-interest. I don't know why you find that objectionable. Existential fear isn't a prerequisite for military action. We're the global hegemon. We decide what's appropriate.
>"is suicidally naive in my view. What's proof, Tel Aviv disappears?"
You'll recall Bush's focus-grouped slogan in 2003, to stop anyone questioning his lies to justify his criminal aggression: "We cannot wait for the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud."
You'll also recall that Iran isn't a suicidal death cult, or a country of idiots who don't know about Israel's nukes. Obviously Iran isn't going to destroy itself by nuclear first-striking Israel.
I think 2 and 6 are clearly wrong, but they're readings on the motives of US and Iranian leaders which are hard to bring evidence for or against.
I'd like to push back on 4. According to the IAEA, Iran has amassed 900 lbs of 60+% U-235 uranium, the largest stockpile of highly enriched uranium by a nation without a nuclear weapon in the world: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/5/31/iran-increases-stockpile-of-enriched-uranium-by-50-percent-iaea-says
That's Bayesian evidence that Iran is working towards nuclear weapons; we would certainly be more likely to find large stockpiles of highly enriched uranium if Iran was aiming for nukes than if it wasn't. (And Iran's accusation of the IAEA looking at forged Zionist documents isn't credible to me; Iran has approximately zero credibility here. Nations intent on proliferation always deny it, and Iran specifically shamelessly lies to the media all the time.)
This seems like yet another confirmation of the Law of No Evidence: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/j9HoG56Y6KuopSzdn/law-of-no-evidence
Here's a precedent / parallel.
In 1981 Saddam had bought a French-made nuclear research reactor, and France-supplied highly enriched uranium (the standard fuel at the time). It was above board, legal, under IAEA supervision and everything.
So Israel bombed it, trying to stay the only nuclear power in the region.
But the predictable and actual effect was that it *convinced* Saddam he *did* need a nuclear weapons program after all, and that it should be secret. The Iraqi secret nukes program, created as the consequence of Israel's counter-productive attack, was only ended after 1991 by the UN.
After a successful US invasion, it should be noted.
(Not advocating a US invasion of Iran by any means, but I felt compelled to point out that that 1991 date didn't occur by accident)
Not sure what is your point here. Obviously, Iran is not the good guy here, but the fact that Israel is somewhat better than Iran does not make it the good guy either.
Also, it is a bit funny to portray Israel as one avoiding civilian casualties as much as possible (this is understandable, though -- as long as they can get away with everything by yelling "human shields", why take the risk?).
There is zero chance of Iran destroying itself by nuclear first-striking Israel, which Iran knows has nukes.
Again: Iran is a country with goals and strategies, not your cartoon propaganda’s suicide death cult.
(The chances of Netanyahu nuking Iran are also low, I hope. But a risk there for Israel would be if Netanyahu starts to fall for his own propaganda—that he starts to actually think Iran is a suicide death cult immune to deterrence logic—so he mistakes their deterrence for aggression, nukes them in the hopes that Pakistan’s deterrent umbrella is a bluff, and then it isn't a bluff.)
Israel has intercontinental ballistic missiles, though numbers and details are quite fuzzy. Israel also has submarines capable of launching nuclear cruise missiles, and while it would take them a few weeks to sneak across the Atlantic, they're reasonably quiet subs in a big noisy ocean.
I suspect it would, as the United States would likely retaliate in its behalf. Since Israel isn't actually a NATO member, the US is under no obligation to do so, but it seems very likely, since the US gave Israel nukes in the first place.
I assume it has submarines and second-strike capability. Ofc it's hard to know specifics given the ambiguity policy.
(The point is more illustrative, like "few here would think Iran has the right to try to attack to destroy Israel's nukes."
In real life, if it was the US who decided that, it wouldn't need to attack. It's Israel's biggest enabler, so all it would have to do is say "no more settlements, no more military aid, no more occupation, time to withdraw to the green line and make peace with your neighbours and sign NPT. The PLO and Arab League are already down, and if we release Marwan Barghouti he can convince the rest of the Palestinians.")
Yep. You can't just say "some guys claimed this about another country 20 years ago but were wrong, therefore these other guys are also wrong about this other country."
You can say "Given the known fact that Iran was not building nukes and about to nuke us; and the known fact that the same people are telling the same lies about it for the same reasons as they lied in 2003; it's probably deliberate, not by accident, and anyone who falls for it again is not misguided but a sadistic warmonger."
You could say it but it's obviously wrong. They are not the same "lies" by the same people or for the same reasons. Moreover, Iran clearly was "building nukes"- i.e. taking steps to make it possible to build nuclear weapons very quickly, that had no possible peaceful purpose.
Very much agreed, especially with that last part. Between Russia invading Ukraine and this action against Iran, if I were in the leadership of a non-nuclear country right now, I would be looking into every possible realistic avenue of getting nukes. It's sure looking like "might makes right" is the guiding principle for most of the world's leading powers today, and I wouldn't trust anything they said to the contrary.
Which is, ultimately, very sad. While still far from perfect, humanity seemed to have made pretty remarkable progress in the past few decades of leaving behind the violence of our past. Now we seem to be backsliding.
I do not really understand what you say. Principles are for intellectuals. The reality on the street is, people do not kill their neighbors inside countries, because there are courts enforcing laws. Now international relations are always anarchy, there is international law and the international criminal court, but crucially it can only be enforced by war. So internationally, courts cannot enforce law without a war first. Milosevic had to lose a war first, then when to the ICC to be charged by the violation of international law.
So no, might does not make, but enforce right. Iran violated international law, one of the most important ones (non-proliferation), and it can only be enforced this way.
" The reality on the street is, people do not kill their neighbors inside countries, because there are courts enforcing laws."
But that isn't the reality on the street. That has never, ever, in human history been the reality on the street. That "reality" is a story made up by cynics to justify their cynicism or by monsters to assure themselves that everybody else is secretly as broken inside as they are.
Here in actual reality, the vast, vast majority of people would not kill their neighbors even if they were absolutely sure they would never be caught or punished. There is a small minority that would, and a larger minority (but still very much a minority) that *might* if circumstances got out of hand. But it simply doesn't take very many willing murderers to ruin things for everyone else, so the world with laws and courts ends up much better than the world without.
Regardless, none of that is much relevant to international relations at all. Countries are not people. They do not have the same decision processes as people, the same constraints, vulnerabilities and limitations as people,. nor the same virtues and strengths as people. They are very different things, and the analogy to civic law breaks down very quickly.
Lots of international agreements work just fine without any sort of violent enforcement mechanism. They work because cooperating and playing nice often benefits all parties involved. Even when a country encounters a specific case where they would benefit by pushing the "defect" button, the short-term payoff is rarely worth the loss of future opportunities that accompanies that hit to your reputation. A lot of leaders and people in high government positions understand that very well.
Unfortunately there are several prominent leaders who do *not* seem to understand this, or who rationalize away that understanding whenever they see a defect button that they *really* want to push. In the longer term their countries will do worse and lose power and influence against the countries who consistently cooperate. (If human civilization overall survives and flourishes into the longer term.)
Now the Iranian regime is a pretty terrible government, and they themselves are not so great at avoiding the "defect" button. But in large part that's because the rest of the world--and the U.S. VERY much in particular--has shaped them that way. Consider that the current regime took power after Iranians had spent nearly two decades getting systematically fucked over by an autocratic puppet government supported by the U.S., all because Iranian oil was more important to Uncle Sam than Iranian lives or Iranian civil rights. Consider that the last time Iran made an agreement with the U.S. regarding its nuclear program--a mutually beneficial agreement--that agreement was torn up *by the U.S.* within a few years of its signing, for no good reason whatsoever, followed not too longer after by the U.S. assassinating one of their top generals on the flimsiest of justifications. From Iran's perspective "international law" no doubt looks like a joke of a concept: no protection against foreign abuses, but often cited to justify them. [1]
So yes, principles are for intellectuals. And intellectuals have spent the past few centuries taking over the world: very slowly at first, but much faster in recent decades. I'll admit that the anti-intellectuals have made a very, very impressive showing this year. A really awe-inspiring bid to drag us all back down into the, to stage a grand comeback tour for Pestilence and Famine and War[2], to really redecorate the place with that retro Dark Ages look. But they haven't succeeded yet. There are still lots of us out here who *do* have principles and are willing to stand up for them.
Relevant further reading if you made it through that wall o' text and can still manage more.
Regarding Cooperation in Modern International Relations Specifically:
https://acoup.blog/2023/07/07/collections-the-status-quo-coalition/
Regarding Cooperation in All Human Affairs More Generally :
https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/02/23/in-favor-of-niceness-community-and-civilization/
[1] If one wants a better understanding of that part of the world, consider that for any reason an Iranian might feel anger at the international community and certain countries in particular, a Palestinian has two or three such reasons. As a people they've been on the receiving end of an absolutely staggering string of abuses and insults, going back more than a century. (And yes, obligatory disclaimer, they've been on the giving end of some as well.) And plenty of non-Palestinian Arabs *can see that* and don't necessarily have a lot of reason to expect that Britain or Israel or the U.S. would treat them any better if they were in a similar position.
[2] Death being a timeless classic that never goes out of style.
>Here in actual reality, the vast, vast majority of people would not kill their neighbors even if they were absolutely sure they would never be caught or punished.
Okay, I sort of over-exaggerated this. Let's say the vast majority would commit financial fraud or take bribes. Culture matters. As a textbook European I don't really get why Americans are so brimming with holiness... I think it might be a Calvinist thing, I think Catholic cultures more accept that everybody is a sinner and it is basically okay.
>Lots of international agreements work just fine without any sort of violent enforcement mechanism.They work because cooperating and playing nice often benefits all parties involved.
This is true for private individuals and corporations too, yet we need law enforcement. In fact because of the principal-agent problem, individuals and corporations ought to need less enforcement, as national leaders have way way bigger principal-agent problems. A marketplace is always better from a principal-agent viewpoint than an election. Like if term limits mean Trump cannot be re-elected, what exactly does he have to lose?
>Even when a country encounters a specific case where they would benefit by pushing the "defect" button, the short-term payoff is rarely worth the loss of future opportunities that accompanies that hit to your reputation.
See above. It is not a country, but the leader pushing the button. Hitler pushed the biggest "defect" button ever, yet a few years after the war, most everybody happily cooperated with democratic West Germany. Just 6 years later, the European Coal and Steel Community was signed - imagine France trusting Germany so much to pool their coal and steel i.e. military industry resources!
>because Iranian oil was more important to Uncle Sam
Actually it was British Petrol.
>And intellectuals have spent the past few centuries taking over the world: very slowly at first, but much faster in recent decades.
I wish it was true. The reality is, the bureaucrats did. I mean an intellectual is someone like Chomsky. While these bureaucrats are as unprincipled and aggerssive as ever. Look at what happened in Raqqa. A war of annihiliation, 2017 https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/06/syria-raqqa-in-ruins-and-civilians-devastated-after-us-led-war-of-annihilation/
And these are the intellectuals with principles?
Israel is supposedly nuclear and still got bombed, by Iran, on October 2024.
But Iran got bombed because they were trying to go nuclear. Shouldn't countries draw the exact opposite conclusion- that if they try to get nukes, they will be destroyed? Surely if Ukraine had tried to get nukes, Russia would have destroyed them at that time anyway, right? And probably if Russia invaded earlier, they would win easily.
Agreed! ( Particularly if, while enriching uranium to 60% U-235, they spend 40 years chanting "Death to America!" )
Iran *got bombed* because it was suspected of trying to go nuclear. Iran was not *destroyed* over this. The Iranian regime was not destroyed over this. The Supreme Leader was not killed or imprisoned or even deposed over this.
See also North Korea. And Pakistan, which was pretty clearly in bed with Al Qaeda and Osama Bin Laden.
The Iraqi regime, which we were pretty certain didn't have nuclear weapons and wasn't going to be making nuclear weapons any time soon, that *was* destroyed, and Saddam Hussein was dragged out of his spider hole and hung by the neck until dead.
The Libyan regime, which we knew for a fact didn't have and wasn't going to be making nuclear weapons, which had done the "right thing" by thoroughly and verifiably dismantling its nuclear arms program, was destroyed, and Muammar Gaddafi was anally raped to death on Youtube. Libya has been a failed state ever since.
You really think the conclusion Evil Dictators(tm) are drawing is that they should *not* nuke up ASAP?
I suspect the only reason North Korea was allowed to get nukes without getting couped or having their nuclear program raided/bombed is because they have a lot of artillery aimed at Seoul.
The primary takeaway any Evil Dictator should have from the last 40 years is that power speaks, and the West is super consequentialist about things, so make your threats as credible and devastating as possible. Nuke up, artillery up, etc.
"But Iran got bombed because they were trying to go nuclear."
Or because they were behind Hamas, and, you know, Oct/7.
Or because they shoot at Israel last year (twice).
Or because they are an evil theocracy.
When the official explanation is changing so frequently, one cannot help but have the feeling that none of them is true.
Some decisions are overdetermined. Multiple independently sufficient motives that all are based in actual facts don't undermine each other's legitimacy. Israel has many, many reasons for bombing Iran, most of which boil down to "they hate us and have been waging a (mostly, but not entirely proxy) war against us for decades."
> When the official explanation is changing so frequently, one cannot help but have the feeling that none of them is true.
Or because those things are related.
(You could make a similar argument about WW2: "First they said it was about Czechoslovakia, then they said it was about Poland, then they said it was about France, now we have this story about concentration camps... the constant change of the narrative makes me suspect that the so-called Nazis are just a boogeyman invented by American media.")
"But Iran got bombed because they were trying to go nuclear."
This has by no means been adequately demonstrated. They didn't dismantle their nuclear program entirely. And I'd say they were obviously interested in keeping the option of building up to weapons capability in a medium-short, rather than long time horizon open[1]. But the claim that they were actively trying to build a bomb at the time they were attacked is one that needs significant support that I haven't seen yet.
[1] Which to my understanding is a state that many non-nuclear developed countries are perpetually in, simply by virtue of having the right mix of industry and technology and scientists. It's actually a little bit scary how *simple* nuclear weapons are when you get right down to it.
>But the claim that they were actively trying to build a bomb at the time they were attacked is one that needs significant support that I haven't seen yet.
The IAEA looks convinced that Iran prevented the IAEA from ensuring that Iran was not building a bomb.
https://www.reuters.com/world/china/iaea-board-declares-iran-breach-non-proliferation-duties-diplomats-say-2025-06-12/
And they enriched uranium to 60% U-235, while power reactors only need 5%. The _point_ of making such highly enriched uranium is a nuclear _weapons_ program.
I sent a thank you note to Trump after he authorized the bombing of the Fordow uranium enrichment site. I consider bombing it to be the right choice.
Sure, but its worth noting that Iran was much farther down the path toward weapons capabilities than any other non-nuclear-weapons nation. See the IAEA report that Iran has 900 lbs of uranium enriched to 60+%: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/5/31/iran-increases-stockpile-of-enriched-uranium-by-50-percent-iaea-says
That's the largest stockpile of >nuclear power grade uranium in the world, aside from nations that already have nuclear weapons. And according to the IAEA, it's increased by 50% in the last few months.
I can't see an explanation for this that isn't attempting to either A) get nuclear weapons or B) make getting a nuclear weapon something they can achieve in the very short term.
Re: footnote one, any country with a domestic nuclear power program (not just a reactor, but producing their own fuel) could stand up nuclear weapons within 2-3 years. The main players there (aside from the countries that already have nuclear weapons) are Germany, Japan, Canada, Sweden and South Korea.
Thermonuclear weapons (ie H-bombs) would take longer, but that's more because designing and building an H-bomb is notoriously difficult - an implosion-type A-bomb is a pretty straightforward engineering problem once you have the enriched uranium and you know how to machine it (both of which you have as a result of the domestic power program).
There's something involving "lensing" in making an H-bomb which I have deliberately avoided finding out about because I would like to be able to travel the world without constraint, but it's famously a hard problem.
Saddam completely gave up his nuclear program after 1991, and they punished him for it in 2003.
Gaddafi gave up his nuclear program in 2003, and they punished him for it in 2011.
(Plus all the other coups and massacres and wars of criminal aggression that had nothing to do with nukes. E.g. overthrowing Iran's secular democratically-elected PM to install a dictator to protect oil profits in 1953; btw that, plus his overthrow in 1979, is why Iran is a theocracy now.)
North Korea has nukes, so the US only sanctions it instead of invading or bombing.
The US has, through its actions, tried hard to prove that no one is safe from US aggression without a nuclear deterrent. This is very foolish.
Yup. After WWII there was a chance for multilateralism and international law and non-proliferation—but the US preferred hegemony to survival.
sure the Soviets were all for that
I think you are right on this.
On the other hand, it is also obvious that the US made sure to have the overseas empire of the UK collapsed. (It was happy to see the collapse of the French one as well, but actively contributed to the former.)
You seem to be skipping over the first 70 post-WWII years.
1953 - overthrew Iran's secular democratically-elected PM, to install a dictator to protect oil profits
(forcing on Iran a US puppet dictator, to be overthrown by a homegrown Islamic Revolution in 1979, is why Iran is now a theocracy. It was so dumb)
The quest for domination did start quite immediately, I'm afraid
Uh...really? "The US preferred hegemony to survival"? I mean, it's not like there were any *other* countries that were pursuing hegemony after WWII...
I honestly wonder if you realise that you have, with a comment like this, absolutely ensured that 90% of readers, many of which may have been highly open to your viewpoint, will now permanently disregard everything you say on the matter. More generally, I'm just amazed at how many people trying to advocate for a position have an unbelievable talent for appending a single sentence that compresses "I have a complete lack of perspective", "I have no awareness of the slightest factual nuance" and "I'm a fanatical ideologue" into that sentence.
>"Uh...really?"
Yes really. (You know about all the coups, all the overthrowing democracies to install dictators, all the terrorists and massacres, all the undermining of international law, right? In the nuclear age this isn't just wicked, it's an existential risk.)
>"It's not like there were any *other* countries"
Did I say there weren't? But if you're American, you should understand what's going on so you can be an effective citizen. (And it is the only superpower so it has an enormous impact.)
>"will now permanently disregard"
I hope they prefer survival, over encouraging nuclear proliferation so they can pwn david bahry in the comments section of astral codex ten dot com.
Foolishness. No, spending decades trying to dominate and crush and dominate and crush is not a good way to survive.
I strongly agree with this post
Well said!
This is a bombing campaign, not a ground invasion. So what does that have to do with countries not having nukes and "being physically incapable of doing so"?
For all the talk about Iraq as an analogy here, pretty much everyone is missing the most important difference. It's unclear whether Iraq seriously wanted to acquire nuclear weapons, and they were certainly nowhere near any such goal, but Iraq was certainly rendered physically incapable of building nuclear weapons for many years.
Because there *was* a ground invasion. Iraq was bombed, invaded, conquered, forcibly regime-changed, and placed under military occupation for about a decade. *That*, is something that can take a nation off the list of potential nuclear powers.
Just the bombing, is mostly just for Feeling Good, like you're a Big He-Man.
The left used to be associated with nuclear disarmament but now it seems to be: nukes in the hands of the US - bad; nukes in the hands of brown people - good!
Show me someone saying this.
“Seems” is usually a sign of pretty weak evidence.
Nuclear countries bombing non-nuclear countries until we force them to become nuclear-armed is not "nuclear disarmament."
Where is the Iran-built nuclear power plant, I wonder. After all this peaceful time.
There's a trope in armchair geopolitics that gives all agency to the West and none to anyone else. The West isn't forcing Iran to become nuclear-armed. They want to because they want the power, and the West is trying to stop them.
Yeah I get that they don't like Pax Americana, and theoretically more of those places having nukes would make us have to respect their autonomy more than we do. But not only is it dangerous to proliferate such weapons, it just turns those nations into little Americas in their own neighborhood, they were never gonna need to nuke their tiny rivals but they still become regional hegemons that get more of what they want on the big stage and can leverage that advantage to stay there. It's not any real kind of equity between peoples as they'd simplistically imagine it.
You've mistaken me for someone who wants them to have nukes.
>"These countries will try to build nukes no matter what because of the leverage it would give them"
False. There was an anti-nuclear Iran deal, which Trump withdrew from because of his ego.
In fact, the US has consistently *punished* nuclear disarmament. Saddam had no nuclear program after 1991, so the US lied that he did and destroyed Iraq in 2003. Gaddafi gave up his nuclear program after 2003, so the US destroyed Libya in 2011.
The anti-nuclear Iran deal was to end by about now, only with Iran having a much better economy and be better able to produce nukes, possibly shortening their nuclear timeline while making their people better off.
Though I agree with Trump that the Iran nuclear deal was a bad deal, I disagree that he should have pulled us out of it. Because what one president does concerning another country ought not be unilaterally undone by another president, because it undermines the integrity of the United States.
It isn't just anti-nuclear though, the other threat is to the dollar's pre-eminence, Saddam rashly started dealing oil in Euros. Gadaffi had some idea of starting a bank of Africa, which would be independent of the dollar. Also, I think in the early 2000s Iran founded an oil "bourse" to sell oil in currencies other than the dollar, so they've been long overdue for a clobbering. No doubt an agreeable side effect for the US of the latter is to persuade Putin that Trump can take decisive action and isn't all mouth as Putin may have believed.
> In fact, the US has consistently *punished* nuclear disarmament.
Everyone always punishes disarmament. That's the point of having armaments.
---
When the Cambrian measures were forming, they promised perpetual peace
They swore, if we gave them our weapons, that the wars of the tribes would cease
But when we disarmed, they sold us, and delivered us bound to our foe
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: 𝘚𝘵𝘪𝘤𝘬 𝘵𝘰 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘋𝘦𝘷𝘪𝘭 𝘺𝘰𝘶 𝘬𝘯𝘰𝘸.
The ending of that poem also seems apt:
And that after this is accomplished, and the brave new world begins
When all men are paid for existing and no man must pay for his sins,
As surely as Water will wet us, as surely as Fire will burn,
The Gods of the Copybook Headings with terror and slaughter return!
some science + money gossip:
"Colossal Biosciences" is the company that pretends to de-extinct dire wolves and so on. It's really just living paleoart—fun, but not remotely what their hype claims. E.g. the "dire wolves" were really just grey wolves with a handful of genes edited to make them big and white etc.[1] For fur colour, they couldn't even use the actual dire-wolf gene, b̶e̶c̶a̶u̶s̶e̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶g̶r̶e̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶s̶o̶ ̶d̶i̶f̶f̶e̶r̶e̶n̶t̶ ̶f̶r̶o̶m̶ ̶d̶i̶r̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶d̶i̶r̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶f̶ ̶g̶e̶n̶e̶ ̶w̶o̶u̶l̶d̶ ̶h̶a̶v̶e̶ ̶m̶a̶d̶e̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶g̶r̶e̶y̶ ̶w̶o̶l̶v̶e̶s̶ ̶d̶e̶a̶f̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶b̶l̶i̶n̶d̶.*[2] The misrepresentation of what they're doing isn't just cringe—it's dangerous, given how Trump wants to use it as an excuse to try to remove protections from endangered species.[3]
My supervisor Dr. Vincent Lynch, apart from his research e.g. on cancer resistance in elephants [4] and other cool stuff, is a critic of Colossal's hype (while admiring some of the genuinely important biotech that Colossal is refining, which could be redirected to other genuinely useful purposes).[5]
The gossip part: it looks like Colossal's finally started using intimidation tactics. First, some bizarre hit piece articles appeared trying to discredit his critiques (but his critiques are standard—Colossal itself admits that calling gene-edited grey wolves "dire wolves" is just "colloquial"). Second: when he suggested that the articles are AI-generated and might be paid for by Colossal and its billionaire cofounder (obviously plausible given the incentives + clearly disclaimed as opinion i.e. protected speech + clearly related to public concern given Trump's intent to remove protections), Colossal had their lawyers send an intimidating "shut up about it" letter to his front door.
Ironically, Colossal's behaviour is more humiliating for them than scientists' critiques ever could be. The hype train was rolling and not going to stop; people want to believe that we have dire wolves and will have mammoths. But people don't like billionaire Elizabeth Holmes-ass behaviour to silence critics.
[1] https://www.newscientist.com/article/2481409-colossal-scientist-now-admits-they-havent-really-made-dire-wolves/
[2] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250407444322/en/Colossal-Announces-Worlds-First-De-Extinction-Birth-of-Dire-Wolves
[3] https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2025/04/10/trump-endangered-species-protections-dire-wolves/
[4] https://elifesciences.org/articles/11994
[5] https://www.livescience.com/animals/extinct-species/colossals-de-extinction-campaign-is-built-on-a-semantic-house-of-cards-with-shoddy-foundations-and-the-consequences-are-dire-opinion
*Added: this part was probably my misinterpretation, inherited from some early reporting. More likely the issue was that these genes are risky to mess with in general (e.g. in the event of imperfect CRISPR edits?), rather than a specific incompatibility with the dire wolf version. Thanks to Catmint for pointing this out. https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-387/comment/129267704
This is just the very first thing they've done. Of course it's not reaching all goals.
Alexander Graham Bell's phone was *dogshit* compared to iPhone 16, but fortunately people kept improving the technology.
> For fur colour, they couldn't even use the actual dire-wolf gene, because the grey wolves are so different from dire wolves that the dire wolf gene would have made the grey wolves deaf and blind.[2]
This is as far as I can tell a miscommunication between scientists and laymen. Actual quote is:
> The dire wolf genome has protein-coding substitutions in three essential pigmentation genes: OCA2, SLC45A2, and MITF, which directly impact the function and development of melanocytes. While these variants would have led to a light coat in dire wolves, variation in these genes in gray wolves can lead to deafness and blindness.
For context, many species have minor variants of these genes which affect coat color (usually lightening it). For example, a variant of OCA2 causes blue eyes in humans, while a variant of SLC45A2 is responsible for palomino horses. White spotting patterns in dogs are associated with MITF variants.
However, in mammals, maybe vertebrates or higher, major disruptions can cause negative side effects. For example, complete deletion of MITF is lethal, while major disruptions result in an all-white coat and often deafness. Certain mutations of it in mice are also capable of reducing eye size, which probably doesn't help with vision.
OCA2 and SLC45A2 are much less serious. An OCA2 variant is the most common cause of blue eyes in humans. Blue eyes are known to sometimes cause minor difficulties with vision especially involving bright lights, however the effects are small as you can find out by asking any blue-eyed human. The causal mechanism is differently reflected light by the iris, so this is not gene-specific. SLC45A2 and can also cause blue eyes. I do not know of any cases where full blindness was caused in any species by any mutation to either of these genes. MITF too can cause blue eyes, but this is not the concerning thing about it.
I do not know of any studies of OCA2 or SLC45A2 showing a causative link to blindness. Closest I found was "There was no statistically significant difference in vision between patients with OCA1 versus OCA2, or between patients with and without mutations. Patients with two mutations tended to have worse vision than those with one, but not statistically significantly." from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1091853116301823 (do not be mislead by the word "blindness" in the introduction - it may be referring to a different gene)
For more on MITF mutation viability in canines:
> In humans, deleterious MITF mutations cause disorders of vision and hearing, including the Waardenburg and Tietz syndromes [9], [12], [13]. Deafness has also been recorded in white dogs, where approximately 2% of white dogs (sw/sw) present with bilateral deafness and 18% are unilaterally deaf [14]. The majority of mutations reported in mice and humans that cause severe pleiotropic effects are generally loss-of-function mutations affecting the coding regions [15]. This is not the case with dog MITF alleles. A comparison of S and sw haplotypes, using BACs from an S/sw heterozygote, across the 100 kb canine white spotting candidate region revealed 124 sequence polymorphisms, all of which were located in non-coding regions [6]. This demonstrated that the extreme white coat colour phenotype is controlled by one or several regulatory mutations. This hypothesis is strongly supported by the fact that coloured patches on white spotted dogs display normal pigmentation. Thus, this suggests that the canine MITF variants primarily affects migration and survival of melanocytes during development, but have no or only minor effects in mature melanocytes in the hair follicle; pigmentation of the hair requires MITF protein expression [16].
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0104363
That paper also has a table of MITF variants found in wolves. So, this isn't a deal where gray wolves have something special going on that makes MITF variants uniquely harmful, but rather that major disruptions to the gene _can_ in some species have harmful effects, and (here I enter the realm of speculation, as I know the theory but not the practice) perhaps they were concerned that CRISPR would not modify the gene accurately enough to include just the desired substitution without damaging the rest.
I think you're right. Although e.g. Zimmer's NYT article said "they did not introduce the remaining five [mutations], because previous studies had shown that those five mutations cause deafness and blindness in gray wolves"[1]—which is might be where I got that interpretation from—the press release itself only said "variation in these genes in gray wolves can lead to deafness and blindness."[2] So yes, I now agree it's probably more that they considered these genes risky to mess around with in general, rather than a specific incompatibility with the dire wolf version.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/07/science/colossal-dire-wolf-deextinction.html
[2] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250407444322/en/Colossal-Announces-Worlds-First-De-Extinction-Birth-of-Dire-Wolves
[added: I've now edited the OP]
Hm, will look more into this later.
Sure, I love talking about animal color genetics so hit me up with any questions :)
Ooo, here are some! Pick your favourite:
- What's your favourite weird colour pattern mechanism?
- Are zebras white with black stripes or black with white stripes?
- Why do some kittens have mittens 🥺
This would read much better without the TDS, and especially [5] which is just more TDS and boo outgroup.
If you are going to write about scientific topics, stick to scientific arguments. Science + politics = politics.
I'm sorry you were triggered by hearing relevant info about what the administration is, in fact, trying to do and for which the administration is, in fact, citing Colossal's claims as justification.
If you think it would be "horse manure" for the Trump administration to want to remove protections for endangered species, and to cite fake de-extinction as a justification—
—tell the Trump administration. https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2025/04/10/trump-endangered-species-protections-dire-wolves/
Their writeup [2] describes solving a challenging and multifaceted problem, for which a reasonable definition of success is unclear. Obviously it's self serving, but it is a startup that needs to pull some funding by embellishing their project, and the claims seem reasonable and honest. So far so good.
So from [5] I was expecting a 10,000 words technical rebuttal, instead I got Trump Derangement Syndrome and evil mustache twirling capitalists. Is this guy really a biologist? I see nothing of substance that actually engages with Collosal's claims.
What a strange comment. He mentions Trump *once*—"The Trump administration has announced it will remove protections from many endangered species, citing Colossal's de-extinction of the dire wolf." I'm sorry you consider it a derangement syndrome to inform you of relevant facts.
(Also, as I already explained: they slightly edited a tiny handful of genes in a grey wolf, and pretended it was a dire wolf. That's what happened. I'm not sure what additional 10,000 words you're looking for to re-explain it.)
I don't care who cites their work, I care about the merit of their work.
The link in [2] explains the tradeoffs they had to navigate and their reasoning. The link in [5] does not engage with that at all and instead only implies ulterior motives, which is low key confirmation that their decisions were correct as even an expert critic cannot engage on merits.
I didn't say anything about "who cites their work."
As I explained, the issue is the dishonesty. If they want to make living paleoart that's their business. They shouldn't pretend it's de-extinction.
The merits of their work are poor. Dire wolves are an entirely separate genus, not species but genus, from gray wolves. They edited 14 genes towards the dire wolf sequence. This is not the amount of change you do to get to a different species, let alone genus. Even domestic dogs are all considered one subspecies, and they've got way more genetic variety than that! Plus if you read between the lines, and look closely at the choice of genes and the fact that GRR Martin is their board's cultural advisor, it becomes pretty clear that the goal was to make the wolves look as much like the game of thrones wolves as possible. Like, why did they specifically add non-dire-wolf genes known to cause white coat color? Not because dire wolves were thought to be white, previous research suggested they may have been kind of reddish, but because the Game of Thrones wolves were white.
Yeah, it's a hard problem, and yeah, the level of success they got is actually technologically impressive. But the level of hype and marketing BS around it is unacceptable and would not be tolerated in any company making products for consumers. This is like 'Our new phone will impress 500x more girls when they see you using it' levels of accuracy.
And when I first looked into this, I thought "Ok, the dire wolf stuff is poppycock, but at least they're still doing good work cloning endangered red wolves." Nope. The wolves they cloned weren't even endangered, they were red wolf-coyote hybrids that are doing fine. You could argue that conservationists should be more accepting of hybrids as worthy of conservation, but you have to actually make that argument, not just claim that the animals _are_ red wolves.
""The Trump administration has announced it will remove protections from many endangered species, citing Colossal's de-extinction of the dire wolf."
I've tried to track this down, and all I'm getting at the moment is:
https://factcheck.afp.com/doc.afp.com.39WX79D
"Secretary of Interior Doug Burgum claimed on X that the "revival of the Dire Wolf" signaled "the advent of a thrilling new era of scientific wonder, showcasing how the concept of 'de-extinction' can serve as a bedrock for modern species conservation."
Burgum doubled down during a live-streamed town hall on April 9, 2025 saying: "If we're going to be in anguish about losing a species, now we have an opportunity to bring them back".
"Pick your favorite species and call up Colossal," he claimed, as the current federal government continues to target protections of various endangered species, often tied to misleading narratives."
So not an official government pronouncement, just social media hoo-hah. Unless you can point me to official government department website saying they are officially scrapping the endangered species list?
You know, I can't help feeling that if we had President Kamala and one of her cabinet officials making a Brat Summer announcement of "extinction can be reversed!", the same guys tut-tutting about this would be all "yay science!" even though it would be the same company and the same con artists making claims.
Burgum is a member of Trump's cabinet. This shows clear stated intent to remove protecting regulations, even if it's not an official order yet. https://x.com/SecretaryBurgum/status/1909345951069651032
Re: your second speculation, our objections to Colossal's dishonesty are older than the Trump administration plan. Burgum’s recent statement, only two months ago, is the first time any of this has actually had any connection to Trump at all.
(And obviously it wouldn't be acceptable for Kamala to do this either. It's weird how quick people are to assume common sense must be partisan political signaling.)
re: "challenging and multifaceted problem, for which a reasonable definition of success is unclear"
If it might be possible to someday successfully clone a real dire wolf with an actual dire wolf genome—instead of slightly editing a grey wolf genome—cool. But that's not what they did and not what they tried to do.
Although there might be an area where the line of success is fuzzy (starting with a dire wolf genome and filling in a few small gaps with grey wolf DNA?), what they did here doesn't remotely approach anything like that.
And, of course, it might be that it's still too hard (e.g. having to edit way more genes, to get to >90% dire wolf genome if that's our criterion). If it's too hard then it's too hard; that wouldn't be anyone's fault, but people should be honest about it.
I agree their "dire wolves" look like regular Arctic wolves, but from their woolly mice, it seems pretty clear they're developing the tech you'd need to turn elephants into mammoths. (I consider whether "taxonomy experts" would deem that TRUE de-extinction entirely unimportant.)
I do think Colossal is going to be the Theranos of this field. I don't think we're going to get mammoths out of whatever process they're using, but the woolly mice are undeniably cute (and I'm very resistant to cute animals), so if they pivoted to "exotic pet creation" they'd do everyone a favour by stopping pretending they're going to save endangered and extinct species.
I also think they just jumped right on dire wolves because of Game of Thrones, not because of the real extinct animal. The ordinary person who ever heard of dire wolves probably has an image of the GoT beastie in mind, so "actual wolves just bigger and whiter" is sold successfully as 'this is a dire wolf'.
Yup. They even got GRRM to post about them lol
I do wish they'd just call it living paleoart. Living paleoart is fun!
Yes, they’re kind of misrepresenting what they’re doing,
One possible use for that technology is filling the gap in an ecosystem left by a species going extinct; not bringing it back, but putting in a functional replacement. But that would likely raise the issue of the animal went extinct in the first place because other parts of the ecosystem it depended on are gone, too.
The tech is useful, I agree, including probably for fertility and genetic medicine.
I'll leave aside whether, hypothetically, the tech could ever be used to actually make a real mammoth with a real mammoth genome (instead of a slightly-edited hairy elephant). The point is that the "dire wolves" are not remotely dire wolves; and their current plan for a "mammoth" is exactly the same kind of not-remotely-a-mammoth.
If it was just their private fantasy, it would be unimportant. Or even for entertainment (I don't mind if Peter Jackson hires a hairy elephant to play a mammoth in a movie). But remember that Colossal and the Trump administration are both pretending this is *literal* de-extinction, and the Trump administration is already trying to use this as an excuse to remove protections from endangered species.
No, if they, or anyone else, have any specific criticism – like, head too small, tusks too straight, ears the wrong shape, or anything else – I'd be perfectly happy to concede that as a shortcoming, and then it's a matter of taste whether you think it a significant enough failing that it no longer counts as a mammoth. But the current level of criticism I've seen is on the level of "it wouldn't have the SOUL of a mammoth," and THAT is what I have contempt for.
I agree there'd still be a long way to go to sauropods, pterodactyls, etc. that don't have any living species close enough to hack together a facsimile from, but think it DOES get us closer.
I think it's less about having the "soul" of the extinct creature and more that these creatures likely differed from their non-extinct counterparts in ways that aren't externally visible or detectable from fossil evidence, such as social behavior, diet composition, effects on the ecosystem, vocalizations, brain and organ structure, etc.
And in that case labeling a modern animal genetically modified to look like an extinct animal as the extinct animal is misleading. You can't learn about actual dire wolf behavior from studying genetically modified grey wolves, and (since some people want to clone mammoths to rewild them in Siberia) you can't precisely replicate the effects on the ecosystem of a herd of woolly mammoths with a herd of genetically modified elephants, which might eat a rather different balance of vegetation and have a significantly different effect on the landscape. And people react strongly to this kind of 'deextinction' because there are suggestions we don't need to work that hard to conserve species that are currently alive, as long as we have the future option of making something that superficially looks like them.
This isn't "it doesn't have the soul of a mammoth."
This is "it doesn't have the anything-at-all of a woolly mammoth, even remotely, except for a tiny handful of gene edits, compared to the much vaster number of genetic differences between an actual woolly mammoth and an Asian elephant."
Are there any new/prospective parents who have experience with Alpha School a/b tested with home schooling? Reading the review, it really seems fantastic to a degree I didn't realize existed with off-the-shelf schooling options.
The current essay contest experience could be improved to a significant degree:
1. Everything being dumped into massive google drive documents kind of sucks; headings get weird, the pages are laggy, things have to be sorted, etc, and I'm sure it's a big pain in the butt for Scott and his assistants to copy and paste everything into the documents, especially as the number of entrants rises.
2. People submit essays for many reasons, but a major one is wanting attention/feedback/comments from a large, engaged reading population. The current rating system gives you no way to write comments for the reviews you rate, because it would be a massive headache to sort and collate comments. I had things I wrote down about each essay I rated, but didn't have anywhere to actually put them other than a separate ACX comment.
It seems like the solution is adapting an existing blogging platform or making a bespoke website for this purpose. I'm picturing a website where each essay is uploaded as a post by its writer, where anonymous comments can be left below each post, and where there's an integrated rating system on each post.
I know that someone had proposed an ELO system in a previous open thread, where instead of rating each post, you read two essays and say which one you liked better, and that over time results in an ELO score for each essay. It'd be great if that could also potentially be part of this, because right now, rating is tricky; I wasn't sure how to rate the first few essays I read, because I didn't know how they stacked up.
I'd be interested in working on this project, but have minimal web dev experience. I'm quite good at AI wrangling, but would love to see if there's anyone else who wants to work with me on making the essay contest experience better, who ideally is more experienced in website development.
That is a great idea--people who worked hard to write something basically always want feedback, and I would definitely often post feedback if there was a way for it to be attached to the specific review.
Wanted to say I like your/that person's Elo* system and agree with your rationale.
My main concern is potential abuse by raters who don't necessarily read every essay but might rate every other essay as worse than the one they liked (out of a couple they actually read, say), or as better if they happen to really dislike one, etc.
*not ELO, it's Arpad Elo's last name not an acronym, sorry to nitpick
>It seems like the solution is adapting an existing blogging platform
Why not Substack itself?
Because it doesn't have a well-functioning commenting system, for one.
I'm not sure if it has the functionality we need; a volunteer could certainly upload each essay as a post onto a new sub stack, but I think comments that only show up after the voting is done would be nice, and I think rating should be integrated into each post, which seems tricky to do through substack. If there's a way to accomplish those goals, though, then yeah, substack would work well.
Parts of this seem like they would be relatively easy to do by a volunteer. For example, taking a huge google drive document, and splitting it into many small ones.
For commenting the submissions, a possible solution is a new thread on ACX where someone makes a top-level comment containing the name of each entry and a link to its document, and everyone else will reply to these comments. (Scott would create the thread but keep it "only available to those who know the secret URL", send the URL to the volunteer who would create the top-level comments, and then Scott would switch the thread to "public".)
So I guess what needs to be done is for someone to volunteer (it could even be me) and propose the specific kind of help to Scott, maybe publicly in a related thread, so that other people know what is going on. Well, the next time we do reviews.
The ELO system... yeah, that's much more work.
"someone had proposed an ELO system"
Essay No. 1 - it was excellent, giving this one a 'Last Train to London' rating
Essay No. 2 - solidly workmanlike, 'All Over The World' ranking
Essay No. 3 - will appeal to pretty much everyone, 'Mr Blue Sky' status
I laughed until I 'Turned to Stone' and felt the 'Fire on High'
But 'Hey! Boy Blue is Back'
I agree that the formatting on the entries could have been better, perhaps with each entry linking to its own post, with comments disabled/hidden until after the rating period ends. I too wanted to leave comments on some of the essays I read, though they would have been of more interest to the author than to Scott.
The question of rankings is interesting - ELO doesn't seem like the right tool for this unless you assign pairs of essays randomly to readers. (You don't run a chess tournament by allowing the audience to choose who plays who.) Conventional voting theories don't work because there are too many candidates for voters to be acquainted with (so ranked choice won't work) and you allow voters to participate as often as they like. It's an interesting maths problem actually, though someone who knows this stuff better than me might come along and say this sort of problem is solved already.
I think the Elo idea is assuming that you'd indeed present people with two random reviews. It's already the case that choosing reviews randomly is encouraged, but I imagine that it'd be desirable to have some kind of option for letting people rate a review of their choosing, and I don't know how that'd work.
I'd also be tempted to try to use something like the Smith set rather than Elo, but I don't know whether sample sizes would be big enough for that to be viable. It would at least solve the problem of how to make ranked-choice voting work when most voters don't know most candidates.
It's not clear to me that the best selection of finalists consists of the most popular reviews. You risk lacking variety. (I also don't know how you would find a Smith set, or how that would help here.)
An alternative approach would be to attempt to find the 'most X' reviews for various choices of X: surprising, well written, profound, thought provoking, etc.
I like this suggestion. It would be nice for non-finalists to be able to get some feedback.
Could be good to take a median review from the previous year to act as a standardbearer. "This one was a 5, rate others accordingly".
That seems like it flattens reviews too much to even be useful. Was the mid review mid because it's too controversial/not controversial enough, poorly structured, scope too broad/narrow etc. For book reviews the parameters are narrower so *maybe* it makes sense, but even then it's questionable imo. For open ended "review anything", the median means very little.
Seems kinda mean to the author of the officially mid-tier review.
I'm a webdev (and the person who does the random review script), and I'd do this if Scott wanted to, but I have no idea whether he does.
why not use Substack itself for this?
Substack offers very little customization, so while it would be possible to make a page for each submitted review, I'm not sure how it would help with any of the other features of the proposal. Also the process of creating the pages would still be fully manual.
First off, thanks for the work you've already done; I used pretty much exclusively the random review script to read reviews. It is up to Scott, of course, but it does seem like the current system involves a fair amount of work for him, with all the copy and pasting and compiling scoring information; I'd be happy to email him, asking if this project would have his blessing.
And if it does get his blessing, I'd be happy to help in any way that I can, though I'm unsure how much help I'll actually be.
I'll post my favorites here, to show my appreciation to the authors:
11 Poetic Forms: I'll remember what a Sestina is for the rest of my life.
Airships: Cool and steampunk. Would like to understand the technology better.
Arbitraging Several Dozen Online Casinos: in terms of potentially relevant new skills learned, this was #1. It's not really about "arbitrage" though, or am I misunderstanding that word?
Two Years Of Parenthood: Heartwarming!
Getting Over It With Bennett Foddy: Wouldn't have read it if it weren't for the random review script. I liked the connection to the author's experience as a writer.
Also, a shout out to the first Sermon on the Mount review. I liked how it adds some contrast to Scott's post on early Christian growth and strategy.
I gave that review a poor rating because I consider it epistemically irresponsible to make such strong/spicy claims about matters of historical fact without providing more evidence than the review did. In particular, I would have liked to see some links to academic biblical scholars (not just theologians) who prefer the essay's interpretation, so that I could get a sense of how mainstream or fringe it is in the field.
I see what you mean. The historical context presented in the review seems plausible to me; things like a left hand taboo and laws governing forced labor. That said, whether Jesus or Matthew really had these things in mind remains a matter of interpretation, and I guess no amount of biblical scholarship can provide a definitive answer to that.
It's an isolated reading. I've heard the transgressive reading of those three before, but there are four statements in that section, and the last one is "give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you." I haven't seen someone offer an anti-Rome version of that one.
Kind of like how people will put together a cause-and-effect explanation of the Ten Plagues of Egypt, but then don't bother explaining that time Moses and the Egyptian wizards turned their staves into snakes.
For folks living in NYC who are voting in the Dem primary for mayor, I wanted to a) remind you that the election is tomorrow, please go out and vote! and b) strongly encourage you to rank Mamdani over Cuomo.
I disagree with both of them on policy, but of the two it seems obvious to me that Mamdani is legitimately interested in making the city a better place, while Cuomo is corrupt, self-interested, and (following the Trumpian approach to politics) is an all-together indecent person.
The Democrats need fighters. But those fighters must be as virtuous and honorable as they are aggressive, people who are so clean that nothing sticks to them so they have full ability to go after everyone else, people whose very presence on the debate stage shines a light on the hypocrisy of those who would seek to use public office for anything other than the good of the country.
Cuomo is not that guy. Mamdani is.
I make the case for Mamdani (and for decency in politics generally) more extensively here (https://theahura.substack.com/p/decency-is-more-important-than-policy)
A point you could have made is that Mamdani, like Bill DeBlasio, might moderate significantly in office since there’s a limited appetite for hard left policy in the city (as opposed to primary voters).
Also, the Democratic establishment really needs to start backing better candidates than these uncharismatic insiders. Just look at how much money got poured into Cuomos’s lousy campaign!
I purposely wanted to avoid policy discussion, because it's not germane to the larger point. I'm rather disappointed how many people here seem to be willing to vote for someone who is obviously a bad person if it means small concessions on their policies of choice.
Well, it's done.
I have time until November to think up some falsifiable predictions about the next four years.
From what I understand, from all of Mamdanis promises, two that he can execute on without too much interference are a) expanding rent control and b) repurposing subway station into homeless help centers.
Both of these are tragically bad in my opinion. The latter seems easier to do, so my first prediction will be that the homeless situation in NYC will begin to resemble that or Seattle or SF (before the latest elections)
A competently corrupt politician is often preferable to an enthusiastically well-meaning but inept one. The corrupt politician has an interest in not befouling his own nest; the enthusiastic idiot often won't even notice he's doing that.
If you want reform, find reformers who understand how things actually work.
a few folks already posted this, kenny's steelman is here (https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-387/comment/128812105) and my response
> I agree this is the steelman, but implicit in the steelman is the assumption that the earnest person is also dumb or blind (because they wouldn't realize or be willing to realize that their policies aren't working right). I think it's extremely rare that someone is dumb/blind, earnest, has ideas that are so bad corruption would be better but is effective enough to actually implement those policies over the objections of others, AND is able to mount a successful campaign. Bayesian prior of all of those together is extremely low. (Trump gets almost all of these except earnest)
I don't particularly want reform. I want politicians that are going to act like adults and try and solve problems. I disagree with your use of the word "often". I would say "very very rarely"
The idiot doesn't have to be *effective* to be a menace. If their dominion is facing real and serious problems, being ineffective and blocking more effective people from solving those problems, is sufficient.
Or is the contention that NYC doesn't face any really serious problems and doesn't need capable high-level governance?
Again, I understand in theory that all of this is true, but I think you have a steep hill to climb when you're openly admitting that the counterfactual is someone who is openly corrupt -- and presumably, also effective (at being corrupt). My prior is extremely high that decency will lead to better outcomes on average than corruption. And unless you think that being a decent person is somehow highly correlated with being extremely ineffective, your prior should also be equally high.
While I broadly agree about NY political corruption, you do realise you are inviting investigation into whether Mamdani has any skeletons in the closet? Cuomo and his scandals are already known, but is Mamdani as squeaky-clean as you make out?
I'm not particularly interested in this election but simply reading the news gives me, whether I want it or not, a lot of coverage. And honestly? all the hagiography around Mamdani makes me think that if elected, he'll be an AOC type: yeah, talk the talk, be very good at holding on to their seat, maybe try a few Big Things but get slapped down or have them watered down, and settle comfortably in to being a career politician.
I don't mind a bit of the ould socialism myself, but expecting (pace Jacobin) "a promise of a fundamentally different way of doing politics for the working-class majority of a city facing an out-of-control crisis in the cost of living" makes me smile. Every hog, dog and divil running for election promises that. Then they get into power, have a look at the tangle and mess facing them that has been left behind by all the previous administrations, court cases, regulations, etc., and realise that it's going to be business as usual for them.
Even Elon and the chain saw couldn't cut through it all! I don't think New York has much wiggle room for sweeping changes to how the money works in order to make the working-class very much better off.
Speaking of that Jacobin article, really, Mamdani? Really?
https://jacobin.com/2025/06/new-york-times-mayoral-mamdani
"Far from “show[ing] little concern” about crime, public safety has been a prominent part of his platform. Mamdani’s ambitious plan for a Department of Community Safety pledges to build out social services and mental health care to help humanely address the root causes of crime."
Now, when was the last time I heard about a Committee of Public Safety? 😁 He might want to rethink the name there. And yeah, I'm sure a corps of social workers is going to stop violent/crazy criminals in the streets.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_of_Public_Safety
> any skeletons in the closet
I mean, he's running as a socialist and campaigns with the slogan "globalize the intifada." What kind of skeletons do you imagine that could be worse?
You could try to muster some rape accusations, but those won't stick. Maybe you could find (or "find") video of him singing along to rap in high school or something, but that's weak sauce.
He doesn't seem to have been in politics very long, so what did he do before?
There's already been a little kerfuffle over "intafada". He was a rapper as a young man? Then somebody must have sample lyrics of him rapping about bitches and hoes and drugs and guns (unless he was an exceedingly wholesome rapper) 😀
Swearing about your granny? Having your (actress playing your) granny swear? Oh, my!
https://www.theguardian.com/music/2019/may/10/mr-cardamom-madhur-jaffrey-nani-video
"How do you get an octogenarian south Asian screen icon to swear in a rap video? According to hip-hop MC Zohran Mamdani, a little context can be helpful. When he came to prepare world-famous actor and TV cook Madhur Jaffrey for her role – lip-syncing along to the words of his expletive-laden tribute to his maternal grandma, Nani – he had a little explaining to do.
Mamdani, who performs under the name Mr Cardamom, can remember Jaffrey asking him: “In the lyrics, who is this ‘mother fucker’ for?” he says. “Fuck this person, fuck that person; now whose ‘fuck’ is this?”
The guy may indeed be squeaky-clean, but if someone wants to dig deep enough and far back enough, it may be possible to find something that could have a bad interpretation put on it.
Update: they found something that might work. He did the Pocahontas thing of lying about his race to get affirmative action benefits.
> He was a rapper as a young man
> hip-hop MC Zohran Mamdani,
Wtf?! I didn't know that: I was simply using "singing rap lyrics" as an example of the kind of thing normal decent people get smeared for*.
*Mostly by the kind of people now preaching about how decency is so important.
OTOH, if he adopts Mme Guillotine as a core part of NYC's justice system, *that* could work to keep crime down....
> you do realise you are inviting investigation into whether Mamdani has any skeletons in the closet
good?
> he'll be an AOC type: yeah, talk the talk, be very good at holding on to their seat, maybe try a few Big Things but get slapped down or have them watered down, and settle comfortably in to being a career politician
I'm pretty neutral on AOC, but, like, is your take that AOC is very corrupt or something? "a career politician" did she do something bad? or are you just annoyed about the aesthetics?
Net net, I purposely did *not* focus on either Cuomo's or Mamdani's stated policy positions, because the point I want to make is that being a decent person is a necessary precondition to talking about policy at all. I still think that's true, digs about the French Revolution aside.
Okay, if Mamdani avoids photo ops of him bawling his eyes out outside a parking lot, that would be an improvement.
In a race between someone who is a corrupt petty sex abuser and someone with aesthetics you don't particularly like, I personally would go with the mid aesthetics
Honest, Well meaning socialists did a lot more damage than corrupt capitalists.
I would recommend asking the right questions. First of all in the original Marxian analysis, the problem is with the system itself, not capitalists as persons. Now, libertarian economists tend to see the market also something like a machine, except that they see it as a good one. So I guess both agree capitalists do not have much personal responsibility, the market is a machine, if there is money on the table, someone will take it.
OTOH socialists dictators DO have a lot of personal responsibility, because this was not a machine like that. Stalin could have easily decided to not create the GULAG.
I think that several people have this take, and it always seemed like handwavy vibes-based feelings grounded in GOP scaremongering more than anything based an actual political outcomes. If you have any actual examples of this (and I mean relevant examples, not, like, "This cambodian general called himself a socialist in Khmer Rouge") I'd be open to seeing it.
But, also, fine, rank any of the other candidates, just not Cuomo.
San Francisco
San Francisco, a place that’s so undesirable to live in that you can rent a 2-bedroom apartment for … oh, hmm, $4,000 a month.
Sorry, what was your point again?
increasingly of the opinion that people don't actually know what policies mamdani ran on or have any idea who the major players are in the big cities in the US
What *about* San Fran? Are you saying Mamdani is like Lurie, a moderate? Or like Breed, an establishment Dem? What policies do you think are the same between these people? Have you lived or visited SF over the last 10 years? What is your understanding of the problems that SF faces?
How did that work out for Brandon Johnson?
I think Michelle Wu or Lisa Hidalgo are equally reasonable comps who have done extremely well, so its increasingly unclear that Johnson isn't just a fluke or a particularly bad candidate/mayor
I dunno enough about Chicago tbh. I've heard the comparison a few times and agree that it's possibly a good comparison. Do you know more / have an informed opinion? Is Johnson unpopular because of policies? Gaffes? Scandal?
What about hugo chavez from Venezuela?
what about him? Why do you think this is a reasonable comparison, beyond Chavez also calling himself a socialist? who are the corrupt capitalists you're comparing against in Venezuela that would have done better?
If you want to point to Venezuela without any further explanation, I think it's equally fair for a socialist to point to the nordics with equally little explanation.
Based on your comment history I dont believe your verdict is informed by his decency. You prefer the socialist to the moderate because hes the socialist (and being coy about policy disagreements) Whether you think thats fair or not, I think readers have high bs sensitivity to decency based arguments that are just laundering political preferences. See GOP preference for decency during clinton/bush era vs now.
a) claiming to have special insight into the motivations of a person you don't know beyond their stated motivations is...bold, to say the least. Very bayesian of you. (Claiming to have special insight into the motivations of "readers" -- also very bold)
b) my comment history is motivated by a disdain and disgust of the Trump administration and everything it stands for. That you think 'hatred of Trump == socialism' says more about you than it does me.
c) vote for literally anyone other than Cuomo, it doesn't have to be mamdani he's just the person who's second. If Lander or Adams were second, they would be better choices. Literally *anyone* would be a better choice than the multi-time sex pest with a penchant for corruption.
Why do you feel the need to defend the multi-time sex pest with a penchant for corruption? "Our policies at any cost" is fucking stupid, sorry. I care about voting for decent people, because at the end of the day my own policy preferences are likely to be misinformed, the policy positions of candidates on the campaign trail are *definitely* misinformed, and when push comes to shove I want my public leaders to put their constituents over themselves. Cuomo is so selfish he's willing to split the vote just to stay relevant in politics. It's disgusting, as is defending him because you're stuck in the cold war.
In case it matters, I'm pretty economically centrist. More taxes on large corporations and the wealthy. Universal health care. Way fewer regulations, especially on construction. No taxes for small businesses.
I think most of Mamdani's policy positions are mixed to bad. I don't like rent freezes or rent control, and I don't get the groceries thing. Cuomo's policies are shockingly similar, though no one ever really reports on this. Doesn't matter though -- the main point is that decency is a prerequisite to even being considered a candidate. Mamdani isn't going to be cowed or bribed by Trump because, and I can't stress this enough, *he's a decent human being*. If Cuomo thinks being pals with Trump will benefit him, he will turn immediately -- just like Adams did before him. No thanks. I want to actually like my leaders.
"I dont believe you" is something ppl are allowed to say and doesnt require them to believe they have special insights into your motivations. And if I dont believe you, others probably dont either, because im not so special.
I offer no defense of Cuomo, and the things you say about him are probably true. But sorry, I dont believe you, and also I think mamdani would be bad (see I can just say that outright)
I agree, and further suspect this stance that one's policy preferences shouldn't outweigh "decency" would be abandoned as soon as the differences become significant enough*, probably by arguing that anyone who held those positions ipso facto lacked decency, and so voting for the corrupt bully with your policies over his honest opponent becomes the better choice after all.
*The opposite position on ALL of gun rights, abortion, affirmative action, LGBTQ+, and immigration, say.
> is something ppl are allowed to say
If the best argument you have to advance your point is that you literally are allowed to say it, you might as well just concede there's nothing here. If you want to make claims about my political positions as a means to disparage me, at least have the decency to back it up with evidence. You claim to have ample evidence with my post history after all. Or is "socialist" just a bad word you're using to tar by association?
Disclaimer: I am also a socialist, and a Boston-born Red Sox fan who has never enjoyed visiting New York.
That said, the "moderate" (I don't agree with that self-appellation; this faction is socially liberal but seems every bit as committed as the radical right to fucking over the less fortunate) preference for Cuomo speaks incredibly poorly of that faction in NYC. He's a former governor who resigned in disgrace and is best known for killing the elderly in nursing homes during the Covid pandemic... and changing laws to give unsafe nursing homes immunity from lawsuits. You can't even defend him on idpol grounds, given his history of sexual harassment and homophobia (vote for Cuomo, not the homo!) or party loyalty (he worked to hand the state senate to Republicans).
What's the case for him - he's rich and famous?
NYC has ranked choice voting and there are other non-socialists on the ballot.
>homophobia
Seems an odd claims given his pivotal role in legalizing same sex marriage in NY. https://www.cityandstateny.com/politics/2019/06/how-new-york-almost-didnt-legalize-same-sex-marriage/177228/
The OP should probably have chosen a different moderate candidate to recommend placing above Cuomo in order to appeal to socialist skeptic voters with a sense of decency, as yes its ranked choice. Instead the OP makes the case for Mamdani, hence my skepticism.
It doesn’t matter who else you put above Cuomo - it will likely come down to Mamdani and Cuomo and anything else you do is likely primarily aesthetic and expressive.
Less of this style, please.
There are decent and sensical reasons why communism is never going to be fully purged from the Overton window despite being a bad idea: https://balioc.tumblr.com/post/614257600500989952/communism-in-its-simplest-conceptual-form-is-an
> agreeing with them politically = being a decent person
This is a far more widespread position than you imply.
Mamdani is 33 years old and the entirety of his political experience is 4 years in the State Assembly. He hardly seems qualified for the job.
We know from prior experience that Cuomo is evil and self interested, so nearly any breathing person is better, as we don't have proof that they would act in a way that as bad as possible for the city. Is that not obvious, or is proving those foolish leftists wrong more important than acting in self interest?
>Cuomo is evil
It is hard to take seriously anyone who uses terms like "evil" to describe someone.
> is proving those foolish leftists wrong more important than acting in self interest?
If I wanted to prove foolish leftists wrong, I would vote a foolish leftist into office and watch what happens. As for self interest, I own a home in NYC, so it is in my interest to vote for the guy whose policies are least likely to limit the rise in housing costs,which again would be a foolish leftist. But I want to do the opposite which means I might have to vote for Eric Adam's in the general election, regardless of who wins the Dem primary.
> I would vote a foolish leftist into office and watch what happens.
We even already have a cautionary tale to point to in Chicago.
Just to clarify, your position is that Mamdani will bring housing prices down?
"Cuomo is like Nixon" is a fantastic metaphor, thanks 🙏
Did you really just say that a rule that advocates voting against Nixon is ipso factor worse than a rule that advocates voting for Nixon?
I'm not going to justify your low effort comment with a proper response but you sound like this;
Jews for Hitler is perfectly reasonable! Sure, he might be evil and self interested but so was Nero! He brought untold status to Rome by acting in an self interested manor, so therefore I'll look for that quality in all future candidates. This non-intuitive conclusion is extremely satisfying! I am very smart! I'm so smart that I value looking smart over anything else, including my own self interested. I prefer to look out for the interest of capital and billionaires to signal to other Very Smart people just how smart and clued in I am!
o undoubtedly. We don't know whether Mamdani will do a good job or not. But we know that Cuomo won't, so the choice seems obvious.
Also, I'd rather an inexperienced but decent human who can pretty easily learn on the job, than a corrupt 70 year old who is going to wield power for his own petty bullshit while lining his own pockets. Again, the choice seems obvious.
>But we know that Cuomo won't,
Not only don't we know that, your article made no such claim. Indeed, it ridiculed those who would make their choice based on which candidate would pursue better policies.
One of the many points of the article is that you cannot trust what Cuomo says or does, because even though he says he will pursue abc policy he's actually just going to do whatever is best for himself.
If you think Cuomo is going to do a good job, make the case. You seem to admit that he's a corrupt and indecent person, so I feel the bar for defending him should be pretty high.
> It ridiculed those who would make their choice based on which candidate would pursue better policies
Right now, I think your stated position of "I'm voting for the corrupt and altogether indecent guy because I want housing prices to go up" is a pretty horrible take. There's a suite of ethical reasons why its bad, but honestly I think its bad on your own stated merits -- your housing price isn't going to go up as fast if the mayor does a bad job, and Cuomo is going to do a bad job because he's corrupt and petty.
Or, put another way, "I think the guy who's going to siphon funds for pet projects and political retribution is going to make my community better" is a wild take.
The steelman of the case for Cuomo over Mamdani is that the corrupt 70 year old who wants petty bullshit while lining his pockets might still be preferable to someone who will earnestly attempt a lot of policies that will cause massive problems.
I don’t live in New York and thus haven’t thought hard about what the candidates are promising to attempt, so I don’t know how to evaluate whether Mamdani’s promises are that bad, or whether Cuomo also has some equally bad promises. But sometimes, the corrupt person is better than the true believer.
Also a corrupt 70 year old is less likely to stick around long term.
I agree this is the steelman, but implicit in the steelman is the assumption that the earnest person is also dumb or blind (because they wouldn't realize or be willing to realize that their policies aren't working right). I think it's extremely rare that someone is dumb/blind, earnest, has ideas that are so bad corruption would be better but is effective enough to actually implement those policies over the objections of others, AND is able to mount a successful campaign. Bayesian prior of all of those together is extremely low. (Trump gets almost all of these except earnest)
> so they have full ability to go after everyone else
See, THIS is actually a reasonable argument, that decency (or the appearance of decency, which is the same thing in this business) is a good weapon for attacking Trump/national Republicans with, and that translates to longer-term federal policy gains worth the shorter term local policy hits.
That is NOT the argument you make in the essay. There, you seem to espouse a doctrine divorced from reason, leaning fully into voting as a kind of religious ritual to affirm sacred values instead of a bloodless transaction granting power (and the concomitant opportunity for abuses thereof) to a candidate in exchange for him enacting your preferred policy.
I...direct quoted from the article?
Yes, but you leave out the absurd bits that are the main thrust of your essay (summarized well in the title, so kudos for that) in the parts you excerpted here, and which change the meaning entirely.
K
Well, it looks like it's too late to organize review reviews under one comment, so I'll just throw them up as a top comment. Although I didn't read many in the first place.
The Bo Burnham review had bad chronology problems. There were several points during the review that I thought we had finished with the main album and were jumping up to focus on a follow-up album, only to realize that the jump ahead had been an unmarked aside and that we were still only partway through the first album. If all those jump-aheads had been in parentheses (or not there at all) the review would have been stronger.
Phoenix Theatre had too much backstory at the beginning, and also monstrous paragraphs that are ugly to the eyes; the Word Count tells me paragraph 2 has nearly 400 words. I don't remember how far I got into it but I don't think I got to anything actually about Phoenix Theatre.
Skibidi Toilet seemed like a really solid review, but I was only a page in before I realized I hated the concept of the show and actively want to never think about it. It's like seeing a review on a painting of smeared shit. No amount of effort will make it pleasant.
My fiction writer AI has:
-Suggested that I upgrade the AI on my starship to one with self-learning capabilities.
-Described an AI in a different context as having "endless wisdom." (It set my alarm clock for me.)
How worried should I be?
Hi, I wrote the review of Effective altruism/rationalism, and really want to hear what people think of it. No reason is required to not be selected, I assume all finalists are great of course.
But I hoped it would start a real debate about how to institutionalise the movements in a less illiberal and elitist way. Instead, I haven't even seen it mentioned in a comment. I want to understand why:
1. It landed as obvious (we've noticed the skulls). In this case I want to hear whether everyone knows this is a big problem, eg sick of the discussion, or if the reason is that you think it is not actually a problem.
2. It landed as wrong/misguided. Please argue
3. It landed as rude/arrogant, poorly written or not the right kind of text. Feel free to give feedback
To me (obviously, that's why I wrote it) what I point to really is a problem on the ground, so I want to hear people's arguments
I also gave it a rather poor rating. I should first say that I have never really looked into the EA movement. Basically all I know about it is via Scott, so I may have wrong impressions.
But the impression is that the points you raised are not really new. Like, the tension between mainstream/free thinker. Or I would rather describe it as tension between the inside/outside perspective. How much should you trust your own reasoning versus the conclusion of other people, if those do not agree?
I think this is a problem that at least Scott is very aware about, and I have no indication that the EA movement is not aware of it either. The issue is that this is a really, really hard problem. I face it myself a lot of time when I read the news, and I don't have a good solution to it. You push for going more into mainstream/outside view. But I don't think that generically this is very helpful advice, because you are using your own inside perspective here (which is an outsider perspective for EA). You should first consider that your inside perspective may be wrong, and that the EA perspective is right, and I didn't have the feeling that you discussed a lot why you are so sure that you are right and they are wrong. In fact, I would assume that for some concrete issues you are right, for others the EA people are right, and that it is a really, really hard problem to tell which is which. Personally, I am totally not concerned about shrimps, but am I right about that? I don't know! And I totally agree that x-risk assessment is very speculative. I think the EA community is also painfully aware of that, this seems to be one the central issues they discuss endlessly. But is the right course of action then to dismiss x-risks because it is speculative? You seem to say yes, and I see the arguments for yes, but I also see good arguments for no, and overall I find it very unclear what we should do in such a case.
So, in summary my criticism would be the following. Mind that I only focus on the negative points here. Your review was not as bad as it may sound from just listing the criticism.
- I have the impression that the EA community is totally aware of the problem (balancing inside/outside view) you tell them about. But they understand better than you that it is a hard problem, and just pushing generally for "go more outside" isn't very helpful.
- You tell them to go further in direction A. From my perspective, this is just a single data point, your own opinion, and I didn't find that you acknowledge this limitation. Phrasing it nasty, your main argument for direction A was "I think it is so", and that is a weak argument to me.
- This also made the review a bit arrogant. I didn't mind this so much, but I could imagine that people with more skin in the game might.
Hi, I didn't find time to reply in June, but thank you for this.
Actually my point is not “outside view is good.” But I see how it can be interpreted that way, and this comment made me reflect more on what I’m (not) saying, so thanks! I agree that you as an individual face a difficult inside-outside choice, and I’m not trying to solve that problem. I am making a case for knowing (not arrogantly dismissing) the outside view, so that you can navigate the inside-outside tradeoff at all, but that is an aside.
My main point is that the EA and Rationalist movements are not the best *institutional* responses to these problems. The inside-outside-dilemma works differently on a group level, because some institutions are objectively better at error-correction (church v university), better at supporting democracy (corruption v transparent constructive advocacy), and better at helping their members achieve their stated preferences (Alcoholics Anonymous v drinking pressure). The piece argues that the movements now can give its followers wrong ideas and make them bad political actors, but that other institutions could mitigate this.
But I realise there is a lot of theory working in the background that I didn’t explain - what kind of institutions the movements have built and what kind of institutions I think it should have built.
Thanks for the clarification! I see that these points may be helpful, like suggestions for what type of structure or what type of institution may be useful. It didn't come across as the main point when I read the review, as far as I recall, but that might be because I am not familiar enough with the discussion. (And my memory of the review is rather hazy by now.)
That review annoyed me and I gave it a poor rating, which I felt a little bit bad about as I'm a card-carrying EA and so potentially biased. I think it's cool that you're interested in feedback though. (For what it's worth, most reviews didn't get any comments, since the thread wasn't really set up to facilitate that, so I wouldn't read much into it.)
I think my three most clearly articulable objections are (1) most of these criticisms could be leveled against any set of political/social opinions at all, making it unclear why EA is being singled out; (2) I can't figure out what the kind of movement you'd like would actually be in favor of (you seem to support some kind of "mainstream" synthesis that I don't think exists); and (3) it makes a whole lot of different critiques in a somewhat scattershot fashion that makes it hard to tell which ones constitute the true rejection. There are also some smaller things that I think the review gets wrong or incoherent, as well as a few "yes we've noticed the skulls" points (where the issue is the lack of a preferable alternative) and a few things that are just kind of grating in a way that marshals people's biases against being persuaded.
I started elaborating on these, but unfortunately I find longform writing kind of difficult, and wanted to get something posted rather than just procrastinate forever on this, so for now I'm just posting the short version. If you're interested in further elaboration I can try to do that, especially if you either ask specific questions or want to do it on Discord or something (because I write more fluently there).
Again, thanks for asking about this, I think it's a good thing to do and not common enough.
Thanks! See my other reply. (1) No, see piecemeal/Utopian, (2) I outlined changes at the end, (3) i'm not rejecting EA, I'm saying it should be implemented in a less illiberal and individualistic way if it wants to achieve its stated goals.
These points must have been poorly formulated for all of the commenters here to think I was doing some hit piece on EA with no alternative. I get some of it, but still not really. Send me as DM here if you want, happy to discuss further
I went ahead and sent a DM.
My private notes on this one went:
> Where (other review) was too personal, this was too abstract. One of the charges laid against EA was: “If they have a job in a non-EA organisation, they care more about leveraging the job to further agreed-upon EA policy goals than to do the job itself well.” No examples were given.
> Then there was a bunch of stuff about how hard it is to have good epistemics. I agree that epistemics can be difficult, but I was looking for an argument that said “and here are some examples of EA people making these specific mistakes” and the only one I saw was Sam Bankman-Fried, and I’m not sure if I’d count him as EA.
Trying to give a more general comment, though it's been a few weeks:
It felt like this was an attempt at armchair-theorist reasoning from first principles about why the EA movement might have problems, but if we accept this reasoning as correct then we have a fully general argument for why nobody should ever try to make the world better in any way. I think that making the world better is important, and I think it would be very hard to move me from that position without lots of practical evidence.
If an argument wanted to convince me that EA was bad on net, I think the argument would have to start: "Here are the N largest and most important EA ventures, and here is evidence for why each of them caused more harm than good."
Thanks, this is useful! Here's my response:
I agree it should have had more data/examples. This is partly lack of time, partly not wanting to call out smaller actors, and partly not obvious how to document it. I ended up relying on my personal experience, counting on people recognising behaviour they have also seen (see other comment in this thread).
As a journalist, when I meet EAs that know I share their background, they tend to assume I will strategically write whatever is good for EA's concrete policy goals, colluding with them rather than doing good journalism.
Reading these comments it also seems like I underexplained some points. I'm not making a generalised argument, and I'm not saying EA is a net bad (??). I'm arguing for Popper's piecemeal social engineering rather than Utopian social engineering.
EA is great for global health and other areas with tangible benefits. My criticism is specific to politics, illiberal attitudes and institutional design in the movement. When you cheat in politics, you legitimise cheating for your opponents and we get a race to totalitarianism. This can be institutionally addressed along the lines I described.
I understand the call for evidence, but how would the world look if I was right? I would say in that world the movement would remain a subculture, get a cultish shady reputation with bad media coverage and a scandal or three as it moved further into politics, rather than becoming more well-known and gradually accepted. These are data points, albeit post-fact.
Sorry this for rambling, didn't have time to write this properly. I agree that a full argument would dive more into the specific areas but this is what I had time for. Theory is also a thing
> counting on people recognising behaviour they have also seen (see other comment in this thread)
I am not an EA and do not read their forums. I think this explains why I didn't get much out of your review!
Did you think about the readership of the essay competition when you were writing? You're not going to win many 10/10's while dismantling a person's ideology for them.
I read and reviewed your essay. I think there's an element of (1) there, nothing you said struck me as especially insightful. I thought there was an irony in your main critique being that the EA movement mostly produces online critiques rather than engaging in the world to improve it. And you... produced an online critique?
Interesting, thanks! The first point surprises me - I thought rationalists were all about criticism. That they want new ideas more than feel-good.
On the second, so do you agree that this is a problem or not? I haven't seen anyone in the movement grapple with this, the closest I found was this: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/dsCTSCbfHWxmAr2ZT/open-ea-global
That discussion is still all about how to further EA causes. "EAG exists to make the world a better place, rather than serve the EA community or make EAs happy" says the Utopian social engineer, breaking some eggs for the omelette.
I don't agree with the third point. You have to go inside to tell people to go outside.
Also I'm not saying EAs don't engage with the world to improve it, in a sense I say they overdo that part. I'm saying EA is too private in its epistemology, but too optimising in its practice. The combination is dangerous
Your surprise that your critique didn't land well comes across as a little bit naive. Have you tried giving someone negative feedback in the real world?
3 is definitely in play; there's a lot of flippant language, even as early as when you say wind turbines are allowed "to shoot up", as if they're just weeds sprouting out of the ground. Very much has the feel of someone wanting to tweak the nose of the movement. The new moniker, the absense of evidentiary hyperlinks in your list of observations despite them being prevalent before and after, it has the tone of a hit piece. I'm dropping off before page 3.
I see, thanks!
I didn't want to tweak any noses, but definitely felt (perhaps too strongly?) that it is important and people don't realise it while writing the review.
Interesting about the observations, they were not meant as proof. I don't think there's any data for this, but please tell me if there is (ACX survey?).
Maybe I should have made my thinking explicit: The reader, presumably familiar with the movement, can validate the observations for themselves. If they don't ring true, the situation is less bad. If they do ring true, this is a problem, and the review is trying to show why. Given my personal experience, I would expect the latter.
It rings as focused solely on news-worthy parts of the movement. If you found a soup kitchen, you get an article for that. If it runs for fives years and serves lots of people, maybe you get another article if nothing else interesting happens in town. If one of your workers bonks a homeless child on the noggin with the serving spoon and hurls insults at them, congrats, you've made every headline.
Anyway, the movement was heavily influenced by Yudkowski's writing, and Yudkowski's writing has a lot of cultishness attractors (see: entirety of MIRI), so it's not really a surprise that there's cultish subgroups doing stupid stuff. As long as GiveWell, 80,000 hours, and other impactful groups stay sane, we should be fine. But I don't know what you expect me to do about the fact that other people come up with insane policy proposals and call themselves EA.
As for not trusting the mainstream, I just posted a comment in this open thread discussing a fact that was incorrectly reported by pretty much every journalist that touched the subject, because one of them talked to a scientist who said something vague and it was misinterpreted. Lots of people here are probably experts on some niche topic and have had similar experiences. If we see journalists getting stuff wrong in areas we know a lot about, why should we trust them for the rest?
Hi, I didn't find time to reply in June, but thank you for this.
1) Well, the essay comes as a result of interactions with EA people and orgs and following the rationalist discourse, so the news-worthy claims confuses me a bit.
2) Actually the whole point is that it is not about whether your policy proposals are good, it is about how you go about implementing them. If you act illiberally, I think your impact on society can easily become net negative. The EA institutions don’t do enough to mitigate that. In the worst case, they encourage it. I think for example that 80k's AI x-the wrong move in this respect.
3) I think you have no place to stand and criticise the mainstream. You risk that sophistication bias and Atlantis style information asymmetries leaves you very, very wrong. That doesn't mean blind trust in the mainstream, it means being aware where the mainstream is so that you know where you take a risk by taking an inside view.
As someone who's only familiar with the movement through what Scott and the commentariat post here, my accepting the points requires my trusting the narrator. The hostility of the writing style requires much more upfront evidence than a more neutral wording could get away with, as I would trust a more neutral piece to bring up its supporting evidence further in.
Interesting, I'm surprised it landed with such hostility
Wondering if I should go ahead and publish my review (which didn't make it into Scott's post) and thank the people calling it out in these comments, or keep to anonymity on the off chance the review gets elevated into a last-minute honorable mention position, as it did previously.
Either way, I'm really pleased with the quality of the reviews as a whole, and that there are loads of people in these comments calling out reviews other than these 10+ finalists and honorable mentions as their favorites. Obviously I'm sad mine didn't make it, but to see even one person name it as their favorite still warms my heart. See you next year!
Logistics continue to be a crucial element to warfighting.
https://jsargentr.substack.com/p/last-week-in-logistics-16-june-to
"Strikes against Russian industrial capacity continue. The Nevinnomyssky Azot fertilizer plant in Stavropol Krai, one of the top producers of ammonia and nitrogen fertilizers in the country, halted production after drone attacks. Another attack was charted in Orenberg, 1500km from Ukraine, and likely home to strategic missile base. In an effort to blunt the drone campaign, authorities cut mobile services to vast swathes of Russian territory. It ends up being a map of strategic priorities. Oops."
That's clever, but assuming that internet was shut down in whole regions, knowing that your target is in Sakha (area 3+ million square km) doesn't give you a lot of additional info.
My plan had been to review Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables by Dead Kennedys, but other projects took enough of my time that once I got to the writing stage I quickly deduced I wouldn't be able to finish by the deadline. Perhaps I will do something on a related subject for a later contest.
Is your interest in it musically or lyrically focused? I find the second record "Plastic Surgery Disasters" to be more interesting in lyrical content as it contains numerous examples of fringe theories and sentiments that underwent political realignment in the past 40 years, and I like some of the more complex compositions, but I certainly understand the more punk purist appeal of the debut record.
FFfRV is more meaningful to me, personally, and its balance of edgy/dark songs like I Kill Children with political ones like Holiday in Cambodia would have also been something to consider and contrast. Due to its general reification there's also more written material on how it came to be.
I've gathered the courage and agency to start writing about Agency, and my path to understanding it: https://onlyluck.substack.com/p/good-luck
Maybe someone will find value in my exploration, and by subscribing, serve as an external motivator for me to write more.
Would love to see Bukele promoted to finalist! Thought it was really interesting, with analysis by someone living in the country of interest and well written. Have discussed it with several people in real life since reading it. Definitely keen to read and discuss further.
The Musk Algorithm was also great distillation of real world experience.
I really enjoyed it, learned a lot, and have shared it with others. The Miracle of El Salvador is an example to the whole world of how fast change can happen, even if it's failed for decades
I did think, however, that it played up the Dictator angle in a hype-y way, possibly for drama and readability. At the end, it says clearly that the author intends to just "monitor the situation" and maybe there's no dictator worries here. But ALONG THE WAY, it uses literary devices to make things sound much more 1-sided.
For example, it uses a dramatic and sudden "end of paragraph/section" after saying something about how Bukele immediately had a political opponent tried for corruption. Only significantly later in the article does it then add, "Oh, yeah, the opponent was literally on camera doing crazy corruption, so this was the reasonable and obvious legal/justice thing for anyone to do."
It would have been less of an emotional roller coaster to say this right next to the "mic drop moment" about Bukele going after the opponent, but more honest.
I lived in El Salvador for 2 years as a Mormon missionary during the highest homicide rate years, and am meeting/talking with lots of Salvadoranean people (eg at Kimbara bar) in San Francisco. As we face AI risk and hopelessness, I hope the example of El Salvador's Miracle can give us hope that outlandish claims about rapid results can actually be real and viable.
(I don't claim to know how to discern if the "extremely tough on crime" approach is worth the immense improvement in safety (not in detail), but a 91% approval rating makes me think I should cede judgment to those who have lived there.)
I really blew it on the review. I didn't read the contest note clearly and started work on an actual book review. DQ! I'll finish it up when I have time and get it in early next year.
Tried to play catch up with a review of Milgram's obedience experiment, in the context of popular fictional character archetypes, but spring is not a good time for writing in my line of work (Apple Grower). I'll finish and post that sometime, but I was off to a good start.
Pre-contest note, in anticipation of what I thought would be a book-review contest, I began a review of Tristram Shandy. When I discovered was a non-book review contest I tried to adapt my review into an argument that Tristram Shandy isn’t really a book. But it was too complex and I gave up the attempt. This is my review of that attempt.
After reading the wikipedia article: no, Milgram's experiment seems on firm grounds.
Is "Lord of the Files" an experiment? I always thought of it as a novel.
Milgram himself ran several replications of it, mostly because he had already built the lab. Some factors and results were stronger than others. For example, proximity of the authority figure was a big deal, people delivered fewer shocks when they were told to over a phone.
Punchline is this study started a wave of reform in Psych testing, with new ethics codes that protected subjects from the kind of stress and emotional harm that were evident in his work. So, replicated? can't say.
here's the link to his contemporaneous documentary film
https://youtu.be/rdrKCilEhC0?si=QFqZ9X2taBoIhMED
Uhm, this is a pretty misleading excerpt. Why don't you also cite the paragraph directly below it?
"In a book review critical of Gina Perry's findings, Nestar Russell and John Picard take issue with Perry for not mentioning that "there have been well over a score, not just several, replications or slight variations on Milgram's basic experimental procedure, and these have been performed in many different countries, several different settings and using different types of victims. And most, although certainly not all of these experiments have tended to lend weight to Milgram's original findings"
Also, I think there are a lot of reports of participants of the original experiment which also confirm it beyond the pure publication. My understanding is that this is pretty well-established. Other than, say, the Stanford Prison experiment or the Robbers Cave experiment.
EC/VC lawyer here. Happy to connect if you still need help drafting/structuring.
Good contest, there were some really thought-provoking entries in the ones I read - and I got to very few of the ones that ended up being finalists, so I still have plenty more to look forward to.
I wrote the Skibidi Toilet review. I had a ton of fun writing it, glad it got some positive reception and informed some people about one corner of the vast and weird landscape of modern storytelling. :) I'll post a polished-up version to my own blog soon. (Update: It is here https://eukaryotewritesblog.substack.com/p/skibidi-toilet-review )
To the commenters who vocalized a disdain for learning anything about the topic or even being vaguely compelled to think about it: Hey, your time is your own and you should spend it as you see fit. Maybe next year, you can write a review of rank cowardice so the rest of us can decide if it's right for us.
After reading some comments, I read your review, and it was good enough that I actually watched Skibidi Toilet from the playlist provided. The series is interesting, especially with the background provided by your review., though it's kind of hard to follow because it seems to follow its own physical laws, like getting your head cut off doesn't kill you, except when it does.
You did explain that the technology is never explained, and I found that a bit irritating, too. In the 4th episode, somehow the people in the restaurant get turned into toilet people by no visible means. In 41, the toilets are compelled to commit suicide, but this is apparently never again used against them.
I thought your review was excellent. I thought you had done the most out of anyone to present the worst possible topic in the best possible light, but Skibidi Toilet was always going to be a tough sell.
Eagerly awaiting the next time someone disparagingly mentions Skibidi Toilet in a discussion about The Youth of Today and I can "Well ackshually" them
Thank you for the review, it was entertaining and informative! The haters are missing out (on the review, not necessarily on Skibidi Toilet).
Yours was the first review I read (bc scrolling and... "there's a review of TOILETS?!?!"). It was an interesting choice, and I thought your review gave a lot of context to an extremely weird meme.
> Maybe next year, you can write a review of rank cowardice so the rest of us can decide if it's right for us.
Savage (also, hilarious)
I enjoyed your review, thanks for writing it. I was hoping its author would comment so i could say that.
For what it's worth, I read your review immediately upon seeing it in the table of contents, and enjoyed it thoroughly.
Amen.
Iran has had their militarily capacity greatly degraded in recent weeks/months. Setting their nuclear program aside, we know that their air defense and missile launching capabilities have been largely curtailed. However, if somebody thinks this is a great time for regime change coming from within--which is the only place it should come from, self-determination being near sacrosanct to me--I have this thought. The security and police apparatus that is so effective at keeping the Iranian people from succeeding at their protests is roughly intact.
So, any notion that we are suddenly in good position for a popular counter-revolution in Iran had better buckle-up, because it will be a rough ride. Sure is fun and easy to bomb targets--and eventually that means people--but intervening to help a local/national uprising does not appear to be on anyone's menu. Presidents that say "go ahead, we have your back" have not been credible, and so should be taken with salt.
Inviting such an action through a preemptive leadership decapitation action would be a black swan sitting on a black box. no-one knows what will happen squared. Not a great comp, but no one seems very happy about Libya post-Ghaddaffi (mostly due to Wagner/Russian interference, IMO), but Iran is a much higher base-rate competence country that Libya was, so who knows.
Still, don't do it.
Relevant prediction markets: https://polymarket.com/event/khamenei-out-as-supreme-leader-of-iran-in-2025 and https://polymarket.com/event/will-the-iranian-regime-fall-in-2025
Currently at 37% chance Khamenei isn't supreme leader by the end of the year, 18% chance that the Iranian regime falls by the end of the year. Since the former is implied by the latter, would it be reasonable to assume that there's a fairly high chance that if Khamenei is gone then the government will be overthrown? Or am I mixing up causality somehow?
I don't think this mathematically follows. There could be a world with a 19% chance that Khamenei is killed by an airstrike (or dies naturally), and conditionally on that, a 100% chance that the regime survives. Plus a chance of 81% that Khamenei survives the year, and conditionally on that a roughly 22% chance that the regime falls. All this is mathematically consistent with the numbers you gave, but then there is zero chance that the regime falls if Khamenei dies.
All this is purely mathematically, of course, and not a model of the real world. But we can say (taking the numbers at face value) that the probability of the regime falling if Khamenei dies is AT MOST ~50%. Because there is at least a 19% chance of "Khamenei dead, regime in place" and at most an 18% chance of "Khamenei dead, regime falls".
Ah, that makes sense.
Clarification about the "self-determination" you consider sacrosanct: would you object to the US arming a few dissident groups inside Iran with vast amounts of guns, tanks, fighter jets, and missiles to do with as they please?
Fighter jets come with a huge logistics tail. Giving them to "dissidents" isn't really credible.
Sure, but I'm not suggesting this operation be covert or deniable in any way: this would simply be kickstarting a civil war, and using the rebels to fight a proxy war. What is the part you think isn't credible?
(Also, I'm not actually suggesting this pointless procedure of adding extra steps to the regime change operation; I don't give a shit about "self-determination" in the sense of preferring local tyrants over foreign ones.)
No
> However, if somebody thinks this is a great time for regime change coming from within--which is the only place it should come from, self-determination being near sacrosanct to me--
If it comes from without, how is that any less self-determination than what they have now? Iran isn't a real democracy. Anyone living their is having their life determined by someone else as it is.
Yeah, this is a good point. Reminds me of Iraq -- of all the negative thinks one might say about the invasion, "but imperialism" is the weakest one, since the result was an increase in self-determination (which is not the usual result of "imperialism")
Okay, let me address your 3 points in reverse order. 3: Well, all societies have either rules or anarchy, so yes, other people have a lot to say about how you live. Not much for me to disagree with there. 2: Iran not a democracy? Not generally thought of as one, and yet...they do have elections that have actual political consequence. Yes, the Mullah branch controls who is allowed to run, but within that scheme there are still extremists and moderates--the current PM being the most moderate candidate in the last election. They also have women with the right to vote since 1963! Not bad. On the whole, I rate them as slightly less democratic than Israel, which would have a considerably higher grade if so many of their residents weren't denied citizenship/suffrage. But I digress.
3: They got pretty pissed off in Tehran when a woman was murdered in police custody. They went to the streets and made a very big deal of it, and were beaten, jailed and even killed for their trouble. These people want something better, and I hope they can find their way to it, although right now might not be the ideal time. I will say that in the photos of Iran after the bombings, of the people I see only ~half the women have their hair covered, the rest don't like that.
I once heard on some news show a dissident in Syria--this was 10+ya--say that Assad would fall when Syrians made him fall, and any other interference was quite possibly disastrously unhelpful. His preference has aged well.
> but within that scheme there are still extremists and moderates--the current PM being the most moderate candidate in the last election.
Suggesting that they want someone more moderate than the Mullah branch allows.
I admit I haven't done any real research into that. Just a quick google. But that response isn't the defense you seem to think it is.
"that response isn't the defense you seem to think it is."
Not sure just what it is that you think I am defending. What do you think I am defending?
I'm not really coming at this from an ideological stance. If you think I am, run it by my and I can confirm or deny. If you want to know what I think--about Iran, American Power, the Iraq war, The Afghanistan war--you can ask; you will get a better answer than if you guess.
Ah yes the fall of Syria,… to Al Queda. Good work there.
That, sir, is an untruth.
That's probably why Israel has been targeting low to mid level police and police leadership recently. I understand they have been intentionally assassinating the equivalent of the local police captains, though I haven't seen a lot of detail on it.
Well, shit...They are setting up for a decapitation, if so. What are your sources?
It was an unsourced discussion on another forum. I do not have original posts about it, unfortunately.
Today there were strikes on the Basij (a group of state-sanctioned gangs who beat and rape women who protest the regime), and a notorious political-prison: https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/israel-confirms-hitting-basij-hq-evin-prison-destruction-of-israel-clock-in-tehran/. Not sure about police-assassinations...
I thought this was an excellent take-down of Curtis Yarvin's recent allegation that the Allies starved hundreds of thousands of German prisoners of war to death in 1945:
https://arctotherium.substack.com/p/right-wing-pseudohistory-part-1
Yarvin's original X thread was done in excellent Yarvin form, replete with rhetorical wink-winks and "if you read any real history, this wouldn't be a surprise" vibes. I admit to hoping it was complete BS, but trying to hold my judgement for a while, and I'm glad someone did what seems to be a thorough and even-handed job of refuting it.
Is this article accurate?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disarmed_Enemy_Forces
The German POWs in Texas and Oklahoma had such a pleasant time working on local farms that some returned for reunions, for years.
Yarvin is very capable at *sounding* like he's deeply knowledgeable about a given topic. So it helps to apply actual logic to his nonsense.
.....
This is bad. The author is bad. To be fair, I *think* Yarvin is trolling.
We know that former Nazis were treated incredibly poorly and anyone familiar with sources from the period would be aware of it. My personal familiarity of this comes from the diaries of John Rabe, the Nazi who is credited of with personally saving 250k Chinese during the Rape of Nanking. You can read his wiki here (1), watch a trailer for the movie about his life here with Steve Buscemi (2), and buy his diaries under the title "The Good Man of Nanking", which I would recommend.
We know he was basically starved to death. We know this from his diaries but we also know his situation was so dire that in 1948 the mayor of Nanjing traveled through Switzerland to Germany and the people of Nanjing sent him food until his death. Allow me to repeat, a ~64 year-old humanitarian was essentially starved so badly that the people of Nanjing China, during the Civil War and Maoist period, were sending him food. If that was happening to an old humanitarian Nazi bureaucrat...yeah, I can imagine some pretty bad stuff occurring to actual soldiers.
Yarvin is bad here because I *think* he's basically trolling and this is Trump's Hatian cats all over again, where there probably was not a million person execution of captured German soldiers but their living standards and treatment was probably pretty horrific and now we're all talking about this. Yarvin *probably* wants this because it serves his purposes for the Skeletor of the 20th century to be Communists, not Nazis.
This response is worse. It presents no actual evidence except official statistics provided by the very people accused of genocide/abuse, cribbed from a book written by some other guy. Give Yarvin this, I believe he's actually read and interacted with direct sources and now he's spinning/trolling to get clicks and influence. This bozo just cribbed a book someone else wrote about it with, I don't want to say no evidence, but certainly not persuasive evidence. You just...if someone accuses the Soviets or the Maoists or the Japanese of genocide, it is not persuasive to show official Soviet or Maoist or Japanese figures declaring that they totally didn't commit a genocide. The bar is low but you have to actually cross it.
Please don't share stuff like this in the future. It was dumb and it made me angry.
(1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Rabe
(2) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IPnkLA5__Y
John Rabe was not in any of the prisoner camps. He was starving as a civilian, and as the author made very clear a *lot* of people were starving and going without food in Europe in 1948. John Rabe going hungry as a civilian in Berlin is not evidence that hundreds of thousands of Germans were starved to death in Allied prisoner camps.
The author makes a lot of good points. If this happened, why doesn't anybody claim that it happened until 1989? Why did the West German commission whose sole job was to track down every German that died during or after the war not find hundreds of thousands of starved prisoners? Where is the evidence that such a thing occured? Yarvin doesn't seem to present any.
Lots of details like this get classified and only become public decades later. Operation Keelhaul is another good example of this kind of thing, which seems like it only became known in the 1970s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Keelhaul
If an old bureaucrat and family were being starved, why wouldn't that count as evidence that former Nazi soldiers were starved? Like...the Americans aren't going to starve the former SS guys but they will starve some guy's daughter? From memory I think one of them was 10 and another was a teenager at the time but that's old memories from the diaries.
It's not uncommon for events like the Holodomor or Dresden bombings to remain controversial, unproven, and generally uninvestigated outside of extremely niche communities for decades.
Again, what probably happened is that a lot of former Nazis got treated extremely badly after the war. How bad? Who knows? Also, not to be too much of a jerk, who cares? It would have hardly been the worst crime of the period, it probably wouldn't have cracked the top 10 even if they had killed a million. Yarvin is *probably* overselling it for political ends and this guy is underselling it using some of the worst logic ever.
The old bureaucrat and his family wern't "being starved", they were just starving. Nobody was keeping them from getting food, there just wasn't enough food to go around and everyone who wasn't a German got priority on food aid. Which is the author acknowledges and nobody disputes it. This widespread hunger is not the same as the claim that hundreds of thousands of German prisoners starved to death and the Allies covered it up.
The Holodomor was controversial, but people were reporting on it as early as 1932. Similarly, the Associated Press was reporting on the destruction of Dresden within weeks of the actual bombing, and there was a lot of people call it a war crime at the time. Yet we have no contemporary claims of mass deaths by starvation in Allied prisoner camps, not for many decades.
I agree that what probably happened is a lot of former Nazis got treated extremely badly after the war. We know this because we have a ton of evidence to support that fact: personal testimonies, newspaper articles, written government policies, etc. We don't have any of that for Yarvin's claim.
I read it too, and there are reasons for concern with this author (like, defending residential camps, calling Tulsa a 'race riot?). But the most compelling stats he drew from came from the West German government of the 60's and 70's.
That's what it was called for about a century after the event. Which way do you prefer it be revised: up towards "genocide", or down towards "mostly-peaceful protest"?
Shankar and Melvin, you are reading me wrong, which is probably the result of my bad writing. An author above, during a lovely takedown of Curtis Yarvin, dropped a reference to an article 'debunking' the events that happened in Tulsa. To wit: he was changing the events from a massacre to a 'race riot,' in a decidedly both-sidesy sort of way. I didn't feel like giving it more of my time, attention, and I guess I already failed there, but I don't like people trying to airbrush a massacre away. Ditto with the Residential Schools. They happened and it was bad that they happened, and its okay to say that.
Yes, the West German government's retrospective in the 60's and 70's is more trustworthy than the American's. Still:
#1 Independent 3rd party accounts are better, and Yarvin provides those in his...sigh...Twitter thread here (1). An account the original author ignores and seems to get confused with a report from the Army Medical Department. (the Andersonville Prison reference)
#2 Postwar Germany was politically...not the most unbiased of locations. Holodomor denial from the Ukranian Soviet Socialist Republic is better than the USSR but...ya know, not exactly unbiased.
As an aside, I tried to see if he referenced the red cross thing anywhere, I don't think he does, but he does claim that Pope Benedict was in one of these camps and...no? Certainly not my area of expertise, correct me where I'm wrong, but Benedict's Wikipedia shows him in Neu-Ulm and Fliegerhorst Bad Aibling (2) but those are not in the list of 19 Rheinwiesenlager camps Yarvin is discussing (3).
To be clear, if I have not, I have not heard of this particular claim before. It seems similar to the bombing of Dresden or the Holodomor. Old events that are highly charged, highly ambiguous, and where it's likely something bad happened but how bad and how intentional it was is quite vague. Both events also that kinda lurked in academic corners until they became fuel for the culture war. I doubt Yarvin's specific claims but the abuse of Nazi and German people pops in up in every contemporary account I'm familiar with and also...just makes too much sense. That's just what victorious armies do. What I do resent and get angy about is just bad argumentation.
(1) https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1930232102986842384.html
(2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Benedict_XVI
(3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rheinwiesenlager
Shankar and Melvin, you are reading me wrong, which is probably the result of my bad writing. An author above, during a lovely takedown of Curtis Yarvin, dropped a reference to an article 'debunking' the events that happened in Tulsa. To wit: he was changing the events from a massacre to a 'race riot,' in a decidedly both-sidesy sort of way. I didn't feel like giving it more of my time, attention, and I guess I already failed there, but I don't like people trying to airbrush a massacre away. Ditto with the Residential Schools. They happened and it was bad that they happened, and its okay to say that.
Sounds like the guy is out of ideas and pretty desperate to get attention.
EDIT: Or maybe, if this is intentional, he decided to target a dumber audience than previously. Now the ideas are less abstract and more dramatic, and there is less need for plausibility.
I would not trust an article by Ron Unz to tell me much of anything, not because of his politics or morals, but because he is very careless with getting the facts right and very inclined to reach for a cool conspiracy story.
My impression is that while Ron Unz is personally a crank, his stable of writers includes a weird mix of fellow cranks and people actually interesting to read who care about the truth (or at least used to - I haven't paid much attention there since both Audacious Epigone and Anatoly Karlin left). I think that Steve Sailer is the only person I can think of who is both an Unz Review contributer and a regular commenter at ACX, and hope someone wouldn't dismiss what he had to say just on the basis that he also wrote there.
I had a similar reaction. It made me curious about the rest of the blog, since that choice was so wildly at odds with the well-argued and well-sourced article that preceded it.
So I clicked on the first article in the archive that caught my eye, which turned out to be nothing short of appalling. It was a self-righteous bout of verbal diarrhea about how immigration is ruining Canada and how the U.S. ought to step in to coerce those misguided Canucks onto a better path. As a Canadian-American who has lived in both countries (and fully intends never to go back to the U.S.), I can now confidently say that I would no piss on the author if he were on fire.
Yeah, that was my reaction when I saw his reference to Tulsa. I clicked on the article, but no way was I going to read it with all my BS alarms going off. Thank you for going the extra mile, it smelled that way to me.
I wrote the Deathbed Ballads review. It didn't make the cut, but least one person seems to have liked it, which I appreciate. Last year, I reviewed Martin Luther's "Bondage of the Will", which looks like it narrowly missed the Honorable Mentions, and I got some good feedback on it after the fact which I still plan on using to make a revised version to publish elsewhere.
Some other topics I considered reviewing this year:
"Taxman" by The Beatles. I wrote a paper in college analyzing this song and tracing out specific references in it to elements of the UK tax system in the 1960s. I think it would only need minor reworking, but I thought the same of my college paper on Bondage of the Will last year and had wound up redoing it from scratch. I decided against it because it was much more of an analysis than a review.
"Identity", a YouTube video where the creator, Abigail Thorn, comes out as a trans woman to her audience after already being established as a moderately big-name YouTuber before starting her transition. I watched it a few months into my own transition and found it very moving and applicable. I think it's very well-made and has a number of subtle details I'd be interested in talking about. I decided against reviewing it mostly because I didn't think I could do so anonymously: I have been very active in comments discussions here about trans issues and have cited Identity more than once in those discussions.
Analysing songs from the American Civil War as a corpus for hints at how soldiers thought about the conduct and motivations of the war. I had originally chosen this as my topic and started writing it, but abandoned and pivoted to what I hoped would be a lighter topic because it was very quickly turning out to be too verbose and research-heavy. Not sure how successful I was (gestures vaguely at my 14000 word actual submission). It was also shaping up to be too much an essay and not enough a review.
One other topic I won't share publicly. The reason I didn't review it this year is because it overlaps substantially with a book review I want to do in a future year and I think it works better if I review the book than later than if I review one major topic discussed in the book now.
I still remember the review of "Bondage of the Will", and found it really impressive! I haven't read the Deathbed Ballads review, but may still do.
Thank you! If you do read Deathbed Ballads, please let me know what you think.
I did read it now. To be honest, I found it hard to connect to it. A good part of that might be myself. I am not a music person. I don't listen to radio, and never have done. I thought I might try it because I knew one of the songs (France, and that actually in many versions). But without knowing the others, it was just a very long list of parts that I couldn't relate to.
I found the topic also a bit less, well, relevant. For Luther, I was already going into the review with the premise that he is an important person that I would like to understand better. For the songs, I would have needed to be convinced that they are important, and there wasn't so much convincing done. Perhaps they really are not so relevant, and perhaps they are, but in the latter case I don't know about it.
I still think it was objectively well-written. You made the most of the topic, and I do buy you conclusion with two origins and found the table interesting. So to me the problem was not in how the review was done, but rather what the topic was.
That's good feedback. Thank you for taking a look, and I appreciate the critique.
I loved that, and voted it for it. The green fields of France is need a great anti war ballad.
"And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda" is another first-rate anti-war ballad, also written by Eric Bogle about a different facet of WW1.
That was one of the few reviews I read, thank you for the write-up "Tie me Kangaroo".
Just too much overall material, I was overwhelmed.
You're welcome.
>Just too much overall material, I was overwhelmed.
Yes, that's completely fair.
Can anyone here who supports the Israeli and American war against Iran explain to me your reasoning? I'm kind of baffled by the support for it. AFAIK the official rationale of Israel/America is that Iran is building a nuclear weapon and so they're engaging in self-defense to stop them, but U.S intelligence says they're not building nukes https://apnews.com/article/us-iran-nuclear-intelligence-b506d130e474c00f6bd653d3d5a8d31a . In particular I would like to know
1. Whether you think Iran is actually building a nuclear weapon
2. Whether you think the war against Iran is legal under international law
3. Whether you think diplomatic alternatives to war have been adequately explored
4. Whether you think regime change is viable and desirable
1. Yes
2. Maybe?
3. Yes
4. No
Basically, with all of Iran's proxies in the region declawed at the moment, this was the best time to act with impunity and Israel took it. Killing their scientists and demolishing much of their nuclear research infrastructure hopefully has set them back far enough that they won't be a player. The US intelligence leak to which you're referring was being treated skeptically. The Mossad clearly believed otherwise, as their attacks had no other clear objective and did not seem tailored towards regime change since they left the non-military authorities mostly untouched. The whole thing seems to have been crafted to clear the way for the action the US took.
I don't think imposing regime change from the outside is viable, or necessary, or desirable. I didn't really care about Iran in any way other than preventing them from having a nuclear weapons program. If I had to prefer one nation be the regional hegemon down there, I'd certainly prefer the Saudis over the Iran/Qatar axis, and I'd prefer secular monarchies over Islamist theocracies, but as long as they've been de-fanged it's not really something I'd want to sacrifice US war material and lives to get involved with and that would likely be counterproductive anyhow.
Big fan. This has been the cause of a very very large 'pro trump' update for me.
I was broadly in favor for pro-democracy reasons (I felt america had gotten captured by bureaucracy and it was very difficult for voters to effectuate change, and here was a guy who very publicly said what he would do, was non-ideological, and would try to get it done) but disliked trump in particular for usual reasons, and here we have some actual leadership / good results. I claim to have supported it before 'it all worked out clearly better than we could have reasonably hoped, which maybe it hasn't yet but probably has.'
1. I think Iran was trying to get as close as it could to being able to make a nuclear weapon, between a week and year from it. They had 60% enriched uranium that we know of. Given their history of sponsoring terrorism against us and our allies, already a very big reason to not want this. Their strategy was approximately 'get to a week within a nuke, while having many many missiles, use that as deterrence while funding terrorism.' Given how much Israel weakened them by destroying their proxies in syria/lebanon/yemen, I think it was clearly a good idea.
2. I...don't care about international law, at all. International law says if someone declares credibly 'I will gain power, and once I do I will kill you' you have to wait for them to get sufficiently powerful that they feel ready to go to war, to try to stop that. It's horrible tool in this context. In theory, great for minimizing casualties in 'reasonable wars between equal powers who might have wars in the future and it's a repeated game', horrible for religious crazy regimes with nukes or nuclear ambitions.
3. I think diplomatic alternatives to war were sufficiently explored to discover that the difference between what the Iranians would agree to, and the expected result of bombing their stuff, was extremely large and in America's favor. Theocratic dictatorships are extremely bad at modeling the will/capacity of their enemies. There's just...very little you can do in this situation. Iran for religious reasons wants to defeat their enemies and in so doing redeem Islam by proving they have gods favor. It's hard to negotiate with that unless they are extremely practical after you prove 'they are not going to succeed.' So you need to 'succeed' sometimes.
4. Uh, I think regime change of the form 'the 80% of domestic civilians, and the 98% of iranian diaspora that hate the evil regime rise up and install a secular democracy' would be great. I think that's unlikely to happen because the regime is so good at repression. It's also not our problem. Ultimately, people need to liberate themselves. It's also very chaotic.
We did what we wanted to do: we blew up their nuclear program and a substantial portion of their intercontinental ballistic missile program. That's good enough for now.
How many women have been tortured and killed by the police forces for showing their hair or skin in public? How many non violent protesters have been imprisoned.
Yes, I agree head scarves are not currently being enforced on the streets of tehran. I assure you what you have stated is not new information to me. Also China has earned the trust and respect of a majority of its people, Iran has done the complete opposite.
1. Does it matter if they're building one this very moment? (This is not to discount the evidence provided by others that they are.) The mere fact that a theocratic regime has taken regular steps towards nukes is terrifying enough and surely unsustainable.
2. Iran's *existence* isn't legal under international law. Doesn't the latter include a whole bunch of things about human rights and freedom of religion? Or did I dream that? Is funding interstate terrorism legal under international law? Is having an official regime-defining ideological goal of wiping another country off the map legal under international law? If any of these things aren't legal under international law, is there a world police that's eventually going to actually enforce this "law" and why they are taking so long?
Does anyone actually utter the phrase "international law" with a straight face?
3. I mean, Iran spent several decades *not* being bombed and...did it stop funding terrorism? Did it stop talking about wiping Israel off the map? I don't even understand the coherence of this question. If you think there is any chance of negotiating with Iran now, it can surely only be because it's under direct military threat. Which is...the very thing you're objecting to.
4. I suggest you look an Iranian woman, an Iranian Christian, a person who's been in an Iranian prison, in the eye and tell then you have doubts about whether regime change is desirable. I dare you.
Viable is an entirely different question. I'm certainly open to arguments about whether regime change is viable or possible or counterproductive. But (and I have the same attitude to restrospective analysis of Iraq) such questions are in an *entirely different universe* to suggestions that even if regime change were possible, viable and low-risk or zero-risk it would still, somehow, not be right. The former is sensible and logical. The latter is total moral bankruptcy and moral cowardice of the highest order.
1. Whether you think Iran is actually building a nuclear weapon
> I don't know. I give it more than 10%, and think that the rest of their international policy is enough at least to remove their "deontological protection".
2. Whether you think the war against Iran is legal under international law
> I care about ethics. I would love to live in a world were "international law" is really a thing - but there is neither a leviathan nor established expectation of reciprocation
3. Whether you think diplomatic alternatives to war have been adequately explored
> No idea. Low prior that a diplomatic alternative is possible given the positions of the parties.
> 4. Whether you think regime change is viable and desirable
I think it is very possible that the regime would fall given the right encouragement, though not something to count on. And that it is overall desirable - both for its own sake and to make the best alternative to agreement worse
I hence strongly support atacks against tyranny-preserving organizations there as long as there are other reasons to fight. It wouldn't be my way goal though, because I want to avoid ugly fight to the (regime) death, and won't pay the price of ground invasion
on (3), "No idea" about diplomatic alternatives to war seems incredibly cavalier to me.
A prior, do you not think that exploring diplomatic alternatives to war is important? What if an extremely feasible, easy, low-cost, highly likely to succeed diplomatic route exists?
I agree that it is important. I have no idea not because i don't care but because I lack access to the information, as do you. I only know the public positions and actions of the parties involved
1) Yes, I think they intended to build nuclear bombs. 60% enriched U-235 makes no sense for a power reactor (typically 5% enriched), and looks only like a step to bomb-grade U-235. And the IAEA said Iran has broken nonproliferation agreements.
2) I'm fairly disgusted by international legalisms. Maybe commercial international law has some value.
3) Iran was great at diplomatic delaying tactics. I view these as delaying tactics while they enriched to bomb grade.
4) (writing from the USA) I don't think _we_ should be trying to change Iran's regime. The current regime has been chanting "Death to America" for 40 years, but, even if we _had_ the power to oust their current regime, (a) We didn't do well with that in Iraq or Afghanistan - maybe we've lost the knack for it (b) Trading the devil you know for the devil you don't know often yields buyers' remorse. It isn't as if we could just kill Khamenei and have Iran miraculously transform into a Persian Switzerland.
The very first sentence you linked to is "A U.S. intelligence assessment says Iran is not pursuing nuclear weapons at the moment but has ramped up activities that could help it develop them."
Can anybody explain to me what the difference is? As I understand it there are no other uses to which the super-pure uranium they are acknowledged to be producing can plausibly be put to. How exactly is that "not pursuing nuclear weapons"?
I've read Democrats whining that there was no rush, that Iran is months away from having a nuclear weapon. To which I just drop my jaw and say, "Months!?!"
One obvious difference is that it may well have been possible to negotiate them off that course previously. It certainly won't be now. If the U.S. is going to treat them as if they are nuclearizing one way or the other, then they're certainly better off rushing for a nuclear deterrent as fast as they can.
The difference is that Iran is using the uranium as a bargaining chip: "if you don't drop these sanctions, I'll enrich to 70%! Then to 75%!" By inching ever closer to the weapons threshold, they hope to extract concessions from the West. If they actually build a bomb, they gain a military deterrent but lose a diplomatic bargaining chip.
What I don't get is why the US joined in. They had Israel already doing their dirty work for them. They just needed to supply weapons, which they already do and is not against international law, and intelligence, I'm not sure about the law for that but it can be done discreetly. I don't think that would grant them any sort of moral high ground, but it seems like the pragmatic thing to do.
Bibi has played Trump hard. As for the bunker busters, those can apparently only be dropped by B2s, so it's not like the US could "just supply" them.
I have seen the theory that Trump ordered the strikes to take the wind out of Israel’s sails. It is easier to call for a ceasefire when one side has already achieved one of its war goals.
I do think this verges on the “5D chess” school of giving Trump too much credit, and would prefer a simpler explanation. Maybe the intent was to inflict damage to the nuclear program regardless of how long or how effectively Israel keeps fighting?
Alternately, some general showed up to the daily brief with a contingency he wrote in 2016 and said the right things to get the President’s buy-in. I don’t know.
Because the US has deep bunker busting weapons and Israel doesn't (and they can't just hand them over, since they require B2s to deploy which only the US has). For the US it was a cheap free option to finish off buried iranian nuclear sites for free.
> is not against international law,
I don't think this is a consideration, beyond telling your press office to replace references to "international law" with "rules-based international order" in the statements when you decide to flout it (or at least what you're saying it is when you're citing it against Russia or something).
It has signaling value. TACO Trump is not a good look on the world stage, and Israel basically tossed Trump a perfect alley-oop.
Does it? TACO isn't about Trump's willingness to send crazy signals, it's about his follow-through. Dropping a handful of bombs mostly just reinforces the same picture everybody already had of him: he's inconsistent, unreliable, and prone to lashing out whenever the whim strikes him.
To shake the reputation you're referring to, he'd need to commit to a policy that's politically costly for him and then stick with it despite those costs. The conflict with Iran could go that way eventually, but this right now certainly isn't that.
The US has never bombed Iran before and Trump has for a while now has rhetorically taken a non-interventionsit position, so it is an important signal. This attack wasn't a whim; it's an old plan and Trump has been coordinating with Israel in their strike plans since February while considering this potential option, according to the Israel Hayom article.
Where peer means “definitely not peer because Iran isn’t a peer country”. China is probably not quaking in its boots, and it has nuclear bombs. As does North Korea. The way to make sure you aren’t bombed for having WMD is to have WMD.
China may or may not be quaking, but they are probably reevaluating how likely Trump is to order military action if they invade Taiwan.
1. This is somewhat underspecified, which has led to a lot of confusion. Is Iran physically building a nuclear bomb, in the sense of "shaping a collection of 90% enriched Uranium, explosives and various other stuff to be able to produce nuclear yield?" Probably not just yet. But they're definitely doing a lot of stuff that is clearly intended to give them the capability to do that in short order. And from a practical standpoint, we should treat this about the same as one of those people who buys a maybe-not-a-gun-kit that you need to file like three things down to turn into a working gun, even if you can technically argue that "they aren't building a bomb".
2. Yes, so far as international law is a real thing (which it mostly isn't). Iran fired several hundred missiles at Israel in April 2024. That is an act of war by any definition, and there has been no peace agreement since then.
3. What diplomatic alternatives? Iran doesn't want to give up the program, and since Trump tore up the deal in his first term, there hasn't been a good way to get them back in.
4. Desirable? Probably, because the current regime is pretty bad. Viable? Much less so. The record of doing that from the air is not particularly good.
To be clear, I'm not saying I think it was a good idea. It's put Israel in an extremely awkward position where they basically have to keep bombing Iran forever, and that's not a great place to be. The US might be able to get out of it, although that heavily depends on the next few days. But I can also understand Israel feeling like they don't have a lot of options, given Iran's continued sponsorship of programs to make them not exist. Diplomacy is often messy.
Disclaimer, I'm Israeli.
We think there's a profound asymmetry in that Iran's ruling regime is really invested in annihilating Israel (the word they often use), and we are not at all invested in somehow erasing Iran from the map. This goes way beyond posture/rhetoric, in that Iran has for the past 45 years consistently funded/trained terrorist groups operating near and inside Israel, and encouraged state actors under its partial control to more hostility against Israel, creating a metaphorical "ring of fire" around it. As a partial list, these are Hizbullah, Hamas, and the regimes of Asad in Syria and Houthis in Yemen.
Israelis sincerely believe that if Iran got a nuclear bomb, the ayatollahs might well be crazy enough to first-strike it against us, even though we'd surely nuke them back (I understand that some reasonable people disagree with this, but it's possible that they underappreciate the investment Iran's made into anti-Israeli activities over the last half-century, to no apparent benefit to their nation). I believe that no reasonable outside observers would put any non-negligible probability on Israel first-striking Iran with nuclear weapons.
So, Israelis broadly agree that Iran getting nukes is an existential threat, even though they might disagree about its size. Netanyahu in particular has made a decades-long career of distracting voters from whatever domestic problems he's mired in by talking about Iran's existential threat, and the substantial part of the population that's fed up with him is really tired of it. NEVERTHELESS, even people who suspect Netanyahu of always maneuvering political decisions towards his own benefit, are still giving the government (and the army and intelligence, especially) the benefit of the doubt, because they feel that anything we can do to prevent Iran from getting nukes is vitally important.
1. Yeah, getting 60% enriched uranium was tough and expensive and they don't need it for anything else
2. I'm not sure. I think it's not more illegal than e.g. the US attacking Iraq, and I think it's definitely less illegal than Russia attacking Ukraine (because that's a war of territorial conquest, which is much much worse than "merely" waging war, both in terms of UN statute and common sense)
3. Hard to say
4. Basically the appetite grows with the eating, somewhat cynically. First two days of the war, no one was thinking of regime change, but Israel has achieved air superiority to a much greater degree, and saw much fewer victims of Iranian missiles, than planned for. Israelis think that most Iranians are fed up with the regime and that it's autocratic, oppressive and undemocratic, but we don't have regime change as a goal in itself, only insofar as it'd (possibly, uncertainly) help remove a brutal and dangerous enemy which the current regime is. It's not clear how viable regime change is, everyone says no one's ever achieved it by bombing and they're probably right; the level of discontent within the country might help but will probably not be enough absent further dramatic developments.
As an American I’m inclined to agree with you but I note among my peers the good will Israel seemed to have once have in this way has worn thin. Do you worry that Israeli actions in the recent war have cost in terms of optics (something I thought Jews as a people were mindful of)? Or do you see that as unavoidable or down to the whims of political trends?
There always was that tradeoff around preemptive strikes. But the attacker's advantage is overwhelming - compare the 6 days war to Yom Kipur, and Israel war with Iran to the war in Gaza.
It is not good for the world's stability, but this seem to be the case